Table 1.
Trial | Psychiatric morbidity | Cardiovascular morbidity | Drugs | No of patients | Cardiovascular adverse effects | Cardiovascular benefit | Psychiatric outcome |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Glassman et al (SADHART) 200214 |
Major depression* |
Myocardial infarction or angina |
Sertraline v placebo |
369 |
No significant difference |
Non-significant trend, suggesting sertraline protective against subsequent events |
Sertraline superior to placebo for most depression outcomes |
McFarlane et al 200115 |
Major and minor depression by standard questionnaire |
Myocardial infarction |
Sertraline v placebo |
27 |
Decreased heart rate variability with placebo |
Increased heart rate variability with sertraline |
Sertraline superior to placebo on depression scores |
Strik et al 200016 |
Major depression† |
Myocardial infarction |
Fluoxetine v placebo |
54 |
No significant difference |
Non-significant trend, suggesting fluoxetine reduced readmission to hospital for cardiac events |
Fluoxetine superior to placebo for most depression outcomes |
Roose et al 199812 |
Major depression† |
Ischaemic heart disease |
Paroxetine v nortriptyline |
81 |
Increased heart rate and decreased heart rate variability with nortriptyline. Significant excess of withdrawals in nortriptyline group due to adverse cardiovascular events (17% v 0%) |
— |
Paroxetine slightly but not significantly superior to nortriptyline in treatment of depression |
Strik et al 199817 |
Major depression* |
Nil (n=13), myocardial infarction (n=5), and hypertension (n=2) |
Fluoxetine v fluvoxamine |
20 |
No significant difference |
Ejection fraction improved by both drugs in patients with cardiovascular disease |
Both drugs effective in treating depression |
Fruehwald et al 200318 |
Moderate to severe depression by standard questionnaire |
Stroke |
Fluoxetine v placebo |
50 |
No cardiovascular effects reported |
— |
Improvement in depression scores at four weeks in both groups. Fluoxetine superior in open label follow up |
Wiart et al 200019 |
Major depression* |
Stroke causing hemiplegia |
Fluoxetine v placebo |
31 |
No significant cardiovascular effects reported |
— |
Fluoxetine significantly more effective than placebo for depression |
Robinson et al 200020 |
Major or minor depression* |
Stroke |
Fluoxetine v nortriptyline v placebo |
56 |
Increase in heart rate significantly greater in nortriptyline group than placebo group |
— |
Nortriptyline significantly more effective than fluoxetine and placebo for depression and anxiety symptoms |
Dam et al 199621 |
Depression by standard questionnaire (severity not stated) |
Stroke causing hemiplegia |
Fluoxetine v maprotiline v placebo |
52 |
No cardiovascular effects reported; fluoxetine group superior to maprotiline and placebo groups in functional indices |
— |
Fluoxetine and maprotiline associated with significant improvement in depression |
Andersen et al 199422 | Moderate to severe depression by standard questionnaire | Stroke | Citalopram v placebo | 66 | No serious cardiovascular side effects reported | — | Better outcome in citalopram group |
Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, fourth edition.
Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, third edition, revised.