Skip to main content
. 2014 Jan 27;9(1):e86992. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0086992

Table 1. Transition probabilities (p) used within the model.

State Transition probability (p) per cycle Transition/allocation to Probability
Non-invasive E2 (I) p = 3.0984×(2α)−1.343 (95% CI: p×0.87– p×1.13) D1 1.00
Non-invasive D1 (I) p = 1.652×(2α)−2.078 (95% CI: p×0.87– p×1.13) Composite 1.00
Infiltrated E2 (I) p = 0.4289×(2α)−1.391 (95% CI: p×0.23– p×5.15) Infiltrated D1 1.00
Infiltrated D1 (I) p = 68.869×(2α)−2.078 (95% CI: p×0.23– p×4.17) Composite 1.00
Composite (I/F) range p = 0.011–0.019 Composite 0.45
Crown 0.10
Repair 0.10
RCT 0.25
Extraction 0.10
Direct capping (F) range p = 0.008–0.168 RCT 0.95
Extraction 0.05
Crown on vital tooth (F) range p = 0.019–0.041 RCT 0.25
Recementation 0.15
Repair 0.10
Re- crown 0.40
Extraction 0.10
Root canal treatment (F) range p = 0.014–0.022 Non-surgical re-treatment 0.20
Surgical re-treatment 0.30
Extraction 0.50
Crown on non-vital tooth (F) range p = 0.015–0.328 Recementation 0.20
Repair 0.10
Re- crown 0.60
Extraction 0.10
Non-surgical (F) range p = 0.013–0.117 Surgical re-treatment 0.25
Extraction 0.75
Surgical (F) range p = 0.015–0.065 Extraction 1.00
Implant (F) range p = 0.001–0.015 Recementation/Refixing 0.60
Re-crown 0.20
Re-implant 0.20

Teeth were allocated to their initial health state (I) depending on the treatment strategy and the lesion stage (left column). For non- and micro-invasively treated lesions, transition probabilities per 6-monthly cycle depended on patient’s age (α) and were calculated using hazard functions (middle column). For all follow-up states (F), transition probabilities depended on the time spent in the health state (e.g. the time since a crown had been placed), with three time plateaus being modelled (<2, 2–5, >5 years). To introduce joint parameter uncertainty, a triangular distribution of parameters between their 95% Confidence Intervals (CI) was assumed. For hazard functions, 95% CI (given in brackets) were used within scenario analyses. To simplify the table, we only present the range of follow-up transition probabilities used within the model. Full details (time-dependent mean and 95% CI probabilities) can be found within the Supporting Information. If transition occurred, teeth were allocated to follow-up states according to allocation probabilities (right columns).