Table 1.
High-level summary of literature on the operational costs of SIAs
Reference | Vaccine/intervention details | Country/setting | Target population | Perspective | Cost data collection | Average versus Incremental costs | Year of cost data | Inflation-adjusted ops cost per person per dose, US$ | Comparable inflation-adjusted cMYP estimate, US$ (Year of cMYP data) | Cost components included |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
[33] |
Measles vaccine |
Catch up SIA in Afghanistan |
Children, 6 mnths - 12 yrs. |
External donor |
Retrospective |
Incremental |
2002 |
$0.194 |
N/A |
Training, incentives (per diems), transport, monitoring, social mobilization, and logistics |
|
|
Follow up SIA in Afghanistan |
Children aged 6–59 mnths |
|
|
|
2003 |
$0.244 |
$0.33 (2009) |
|
[34] |
Measles vaccine |
Nationwide SIA in Zambia |
Children, 9 mnths −4 yrs. |
National payer |
Retrospective |
Incremental |
2001 |
$0.028 |
$0.73 (2010) |
Social mobilization, supervision, planning/training, administrative costs, additional transport, additional personnel |
Tsogbe K: Measles Campaign CEA, Rwanda. Unpublished. |
Measles vaccine |
Nationwide SIA in Rwanda |
Children, 6–59 mnths |
National payer and External donor |
Retrospective |
Average |
2001 |
$0.284 |
$0.41 (2005) |
Micro- planning, social mobilization, training, transport, fuel, and per diems (defined as "operational costs") |
[35] |
Measles vaccine |
Pilot SIA in 2 provinces in Lao PDR |
Children, 6–59 mnths |
National payer and External donor |
Retrospective |
Average |
2000 |
$0.562 |
N/A |
Transport and travel, salaries and per diems, supervision, training, other campaign-specific costs |
|
|
Nationwide SIA in other 16 provinces of Lao PDR |
|
|
|
|
2001 |
$0.350 |
N/A |
|
[36] |
Measles vaccine |
SIAs conducted in Uganda |
Not specified |
Not specified |
Not specified |
Average |
2003 |
$0.531 |
N/A |
Not specified |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
2006 |
$0.686 |
N/A |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
2009 |
$0.534 |
N/A |
|
[37] |
Measles vaccine + VitA |
‘Nationwide' SIA -- 50/117 Tanzanian districts |
Children, 9–59 mnths |
National payer and external donor |
Retrospective |
Average |
2000 |
$0.312 |
N/A |
Transport and travel, salaries and per diems, supervision and training, other campaign-specific costs (includes social mobilization surveillance) |
[38] |
VitA + Measles vaccines + Deworming and nutrition screening |
Twice-annual Child Health Days in 2/10 Ethiopian regions: |
Children, 6–59 mnths |
National payer and external donors(i) |
Retrospective |
Average |
2006 |
$0.244 |
N/A |
Training, social mobilization ('sensitization and other promotional meetings'), transport, implementation, evaluation ('review meetings') |
|
|
- Amahara |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
- Oromiya |
|
|
|
|
2006 |
$0.163 |
N/A |
|
[39] |
Measles vaccine + VitA |
Nationwide SIA in Uganda |
Children, 6–59 mnths |
Not specified |
Not specified |
Not specified |
2001 |
$0.339 |
N/A |
Not specified |
[40] |
OPV |
National Immunization Day (NID) with costs from 10 provinces in China |
Children (Age range not specified) |
National payer and external donor(ii) |
Retrospective |
Incremental |
1994 |
$0.657 |
N/A |
Personnel [including per diems for all staff involved in SIA(iii)]; publicity and social promotion; training costs, logistical costs (including shipping, freight, fuel, travel cost, vaccine storage, vehicle depreciation, data collection forms) |
[41] |
Tetanus toxoid vaccine |
SIA to provide 3 doses of TT in two phases across 11 'Union Councils' in the district of Loralai, in Baluchistan, Pakistan |
Women, 15–45 yrs. |
National payer |
Not specified |
Incremental |
2001 |
$0.491 |
N/A |
Training, social mobilization, per diems, salaries (of health workers, vaccinators, and supervisors), rental of vehicles, fuel, ice for cold chain, monitoring and evaluation, and misc. |
[42] |
Yellow fever vaccine |
SIA in Abidjan and surrounding areas (Anyama, Bingerville and Songon) in Cote d'Ivoire |
(I) All unvaccinated children, 6 mnths to 10 yrs.; (II) Persons ≥10 yrs. who are either unvaccinated or whose yellow fever vaccination was >10 yrs. ago(iv) |
National payer |
Retrospective |
Average |
2001 |
$0.224 |
N/A |
Transport (inc. fuel and maintenance of rolling stock), administrative/office supplies, social mobilization, human resources, coordination, supervision, cold chain equipment |
[43] |
Yellow fever vaccine +MenA+C vaccine(v) |
Reactive immunization campaign in the Matam District, in the Northeast part of Senegal |
Children and adults, 1–25 yrs. |
National payer |
Prospective |
Incremental |
1997 |
$0.074 |
N/A |
Staff costs (per diems and travel costs), transport (inc. fuel, maintenance and repairs), cold chain equipment, social/community mobilization, vaccination cards and stationery, coordination and supervision |
[44] |
MenA+C vaccine(v) |
Reactive campaign in Réo and Kombissiri districts, Burkina Faso |
Children and adults, 2–30 yrs. |
National payer, partners, and communities(vi) |
Prospective |
Average |
2006 |
$0.507 |
N/A |
Transportation, personnel, IEC/social mobilization, supervision, surveillance, monitoring & evaluation, training, cold chain equipment and maintenance, waste management, and planning |
[45] |
MenA+C vaccine(v) |
Reactive campaign across Guinea in districts with weekly incidence rate (WIR) of menA of >5/100,000 |
Children and adults, >1 yr. |
National payer |
Prospective |
Incremental |
1993 |
$0.328 |
N/A |
Logistics, wages |
[46] |
MenA+C vaccine(v) |
Reactive campaign across Katsina State in Nigeria in districts with WIR of menA of >5/100,001 |
Children and adults, 6 mnths – 30 yrs. |
Not specified |
Not specified |
Incremental |
1996 |
$0.485 |
N/A |
Transport, personnel, administration |
[21] |
Cholera vaccine(vii) |
South Sudanese refugees in Ugandan refugee camps |
Children, 1–4 yrs. |
National payer |
Retrospective |
Average |
1997 |
$0.787 |
N/A |
Transport, vaccination cards, storage (free of charge), material for administration, material for data collection, local personnel salaries |
[22] | Cholera vaccine(vii) | Mass vaccination targeting residents in 13 communes of Hue city, Vietnam | All children and adults, ≥ 2yrs., excluding pregnant women | National payer | Retrospective | Average | 1998 | $0.142 | N/A | Personnel, training, review meeting, and social mobilization (Publicity/information campaign) |
(i)But excludes UNICEF staff costs, UNICEF and the Federal Ministry of Health’s overhead costs.
(ii)Excludes recurrent costs involved in the running of international organizations.
(iii)i.e. managers, supervisors, cold-chain technicians, drivers, vaccinators.
(iv)Subjects with acute progressive diseases and immune deficiency were excluded.
(v)Polysaccharide A + C meningococcal vaccine.
(vi)Household costs presented elsewhere.
(vii)Oral killed whole-cell/recombinant B-subunit (WC/rBS) cholera vaccine – Not part of existing ADC/E/E programs but included here to provide a more complete picture of literature on SIA operational costs.