Table 3.
2 nd level ICF | Factors | Qualitative studies | Quantitative studies | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Functions & structures |
|
|
|
||
b1 Mental functions |
|
|
|
||
b114 |
Orientation functions |
|
36
-
, 37
-
|
|
|
b126 |
Temperament and personality functions |
Adaptability |
34
+
, 39
+
|
|
|
Optimistic |
|
55 |
|||
Perseverance/persistence |
28
+
, 29
+
, 31
+
, 35
+
36
+
, 42+ |
46
+
, 57+ |
|||
Personal characteristics |
|
47 |
|||
Uncertain/insecure |
28
-
, 29
-
|
|
|||
b140 |
Attention functions |
|
30
-
, 34
-
, 36
-
|
|
|
b144 |
Memory functions |
|
31
-
, 34
+
, 36
-
37
-
, 43- |
56- |
|
Remembering instructions |
42 |
|
|||
Remembering names |
42 |
|
|||
b152 |
Emotional functions |
Amount of passion |
39 |
|
|
Anxiety |
28
-
, 37
-
, 40
-
|
|
|||
Aggressive feelings |
28 |
|
|||
Concern for patient safety |
|
56 |
|||
Confusion/anger |
29
-
, 30
-
, 32
-
, 37
-
, 42- |
|
|||
Depression |
37 |
|
|||
Discouragement |
32 |
|
|||
Emotional problems |
28 |
|
|||
Fear of being stigmatized |
40
-
, 42-, 43- |
|
|||
Fear of exposure |
37
-
, 43- |
|
|||
Fear of failure |
28
-
|
56- |
|||
Feelings of accomplishment |
43- |
49
+
|
|||
Feeling of being different |
28
-
, 37
-
, 43- |
|
|||
Feeling of inadequacy |
34
-
, 42- |
|
|||
Feeling of presenting a false impression (impostor phenomenon) |
37 |
|
|||
Frustration |
28
-
, 30
-
, 32
-
37
-
|
|
|||
Guilt/embarrassment |
34
-
, 37
-
|
55-, 56- |
|||
Inferiority feelings |
28
-
, 31
-
, 37
-
|
56- |
|||
Sense of strength |
29
+
, 31
+
, 35
+
|
|
|||
Shame |
34
-
, 37
-
, 43- |
|
|||
b156 |
Perception |
|
29
+
, 37
+
|
|
|
b160 |
Thought functions |
|
29
+
, 34
+
, 35
-
, 36
+
|
56+ |
|
b164 |
Higher-level cognitive functions |
Executive functions |
35 |
|
|
Holistic/visual thinking |
31
+
, 35
+
|
|
|||
Increased creativity |
29
+
, 36
+
, 37
+
|
|
|||
Information processing |
|
49
-
, 57- |
|||
Organization and planning |
29
-
, 31
+
, 36
+
, 37
-
, 39
-
|
49
+
, 56-, 57- |
|||
Thinking outside the box |
29 |
|
|||
b167 |
Mental functions of language |
Word retrieval |
37 |
|
|
b180 |
Experience of self and time functions |
Bothered by being different |
36 |
|
|
Depersonalize LD |
36 |
|
|||
Disability self-awareness |
30
+
, 35
+
, 36
+
|
|
|||
Labeling LD as a kind of self-mockery |
39 |
|
|||
Negative self-perceptions |
30
-
, 34
-
, 37
-
|
|
|||
Not seeing themselves as having a disability |
30
+
, 40
+
|
|
|||
Self-conscious |
40 |
|
|||
Activities (d1- d6) and participation (d7- d9) | |||||
d1 Learning and applying knowledge | |||||
d115 |
Listening |
|
36 |
|
|
d155 |
Acquiring skills |
Analytical skills |
36
+
|
57- |
|
Developing coping strategies |
40 |
|
|||
Developing different learning styles |
42 |
|
|||
Learning a new skill |
42°, 44+ |
|
|||
Learning operating instrument names |
42 |
|
|||
Practical skills |
31
+
, 35
+
|
|
|||
d160 |
Focusing attention |
|
31
+
, 37
+
|
|
|
d166 |
Reading |
|
28
-
, 29
-
, 30
-
, 31
-
, 35
-
, 36
-
, 37
-
, 40
-
, 42-, 43- |
45°, 54°, 55-, 56-, 57-, 60- |
|
d170 |
Writing (spelling) |
|
28
-
, 29
-
, 30
-
, 31
-
, 34
-
, 35
-
, 36
-
, 39
-
, 40
-
, 42-, 43- |
49
-
, 54-, 55-, 56-, 57-, 60- |
|
Writing reports to work |
33
-
, 41-, 42- |
|
|||
d172 |
Calculating |
|
36
+
, 42-, 43- |
56-, 60- |
|
d175 |
Solving problems |
|
31
+
, 34
+
, 36
+
, 37
+
|
57+ |
|
d2 General tasks and demands | |||||
d210 |
Undertaking a single task |
|
37 |
|
|
d220 |
Undertaking multiple tasks |
Correcting mistakes |
|
52 |
|
Gathering information |
36° |
56- |
|||
Giving lectures/presentations/training sessions |
31
+
, 35
-
, 42- |
|
|||
Meetings |
42- |
56- |
|||
Representing a group |
42 |
|
|||
d230 |
Carrying out daily routine |
|
28
±
, 36
±
, 37
±
, 40
±
, 42-, 43± |
|
|
d240 |
Handling stress and other responsibilities |
|
36 |
|
|
Handling responsibilities |
28 |
|
|||
d3 Communication |
|
|
|
||
d310 |
Communicating with – receiving – spoken messages |
|
30
-
, 36
±
|
|
|
d315 |
Communicating with – receiving nonverbal messages |
Receiving body gestures |
35 |
|
|
d325 |
Communicating with – receiving – written messages |
|
30
-
, 36
-
, 37
-
|
49
-
, 57- |
|
d330 |
Speaking |
|
28
-
, 31
+
, 35
+
, 36
±
|
56- |
|
Speaking in public |
|
56 |
|||
d335 |
Producing nonverbalmessages |
Using drawings |
31
+
, 35
+
|
|
|
d345 |
Writing messages |
Completing a literacy exercise |
40 |
|
|
Filling in application forms |
30
-
, 40
-
, 42- |
60- |
|||
Keeping records |
42+ |
56- |
|||
Note taking |
30
-
, 36
+
, 42- |
|
|||
Taking telephone messages |
42 |
|
|||
d355 |
Discussion |
Discussing (LD with employer/problems with colleagues) |
30
-
, 31
+
, 34°, 35
+
|
|
|
d 360 |
Using communication devices and techniques |
Dialing a phone |
36 |
|
|
Multitasking (on a computer) |
36 |
|
|||
Using computer software/skills |
28
+
, 35
+
, 36
+
, 40
+
|
57- |
|||
d6 Domestic life |
|
|
|
||
d660 |
Assisting others |
Helping students |
31
+
, 32
+
, 35
+
|
|
|
|
Motivate students |
31
+
, 32
+
, 35
+
|
|
||
|
Validate students feelings |
31
+
, 32
+
, 35
+
|
|
||
d7 Interpersonal interactions and relationships | |||||
d710 |
Basic interpersonal interactions |
|
32 |
|
|
Using social skills |
31
+
, 35
+
|
46
+
|
|||
d720 |
Complex interpersonal interactions |
Forming relationships |
28
-
, 36
-
|
|
|
d740 |
Formal relationships |
Relationships with clients |
41 |
|
|
d8 Major life areas | |||||
d845 |
Acquiring, keeping and terminating a job |
Ability to maintain the career |
29
-
, 40
-
|
56- |
|
Demotion or dismissal |
37
-
, 40
-
, 43- |
56- |
|||
Meeting their goals |
32
+
, 42+ |
|
|||
Occupation choice |
42- |
46°, 53-, 56-, 58-, 59- |
|||
Securing his current position |
29
-
, 34
+
, 40
-
|
46
-
, 49°, 57- |
|||
Seeking employment |
40 |
|
|||
Skills for performing the job |
43 |
|
|||
Survive within the workplace |
40 |
|
|||
Terminating a job |
34
-
, 43- |
|
|||
Working much harder |
28
-
, 31
-
, 35
-
, 36
-
|
|
|||
d850 |
Remunerative employment |
Achievement/accomplishment |
28
-
, 29
±
, 31
-
42±, 43- |
|
|
Continuous changing of employment |
40 |
|
|||
Employment roles |
40 |
|
|||
Employment in unskilled/semiskilled occupations |
28
-
, 40
-
|
50
-
, 60+ |
|||
Employment in white-collar/blue-collar jobs |
|
45°, 52
+
, 53+, 55+ |
|||
Enabled to excel |
36 |
|
|||
Having a job/being employed |
28
+
|
47
+
, 51
+
, 55+ |
|||
Having more jobs |
|
47 |
|||
Job history |
28 |
|
|||
Job at the level of their training or higher |
28
+
, 36
+
|
|
|||
Job performance |
33
+
, 34
+
, 43- |
|
|||
Limited employment opportunities |
43- |
47
-
, 55- |
|||
Part-time employment |
28
+
, 29
+
|
55- |
|||
Permanently employed |
|
55+, 60- |
|||
Quality of products and processes |
41 |
|
|||
Unemployed |
28
-
, 40
-
|
48
-
, 52
-
, 59- |
|||
Workforce abilities |
|
47 |
|||
Work-related environmental factors: terms of employment | |||||
|
Access to degree courses |
42- |
56+ |
||
Attendance |
33 |
|
|||
Change in job description/title |
34 |
|
|||
Current (annual) salary |
|
46°, 49
+
°, 51
-
, 52
-
, 59° |
|||
Extra study leave |
42 |
|
|||
Extra time |
34
+
|
56+, 57+ |
|||
Flexible schedule |
33
+
, 41+ |
|
|||
Incentives and bonuses |
34 |
|
|||
Income derived from employment |
|
59 |
|||
On-the-job training agreement |
31
+
, 33
+
|
|
|||
Promotion/Job advancement |
30
+
, 33
+
, 34
+
, 42+ |
51
-
|
|||
Tenure used as productivity signal |
30
+
|
47
+
|
|||
Tenure with current employer |
30
+
|
47
+
|
|||
Wage -gap (with non-LD) |
|
47
-
, 51°, 52
+
|
|||
Wage increase/decrease |
33
+
, 34
+
|
47
+
|
|||
Working from home |
41 |
|
|||
Working at off hours late in the day or night |
36
+
, 41+, 42- |
46
+
, 49
+
, 50
+
56+, 57+ |
|||
Work-related environmental factors: social relationships at work | |||||
e3 Support and relationships | |||||
e315/e320 |
Extended family/friends |
Support from family/friends |
28
+
, 29
+
, 32
+
, 33
+
, 34
+
, 35
+
, 39
+
|
55+ |
|
e325 |
Acquaintances, peers, colleagues, neighbors and community members |
Being loners/isolated in the job |
37 |
|
|
Control/check by others |
28
+
, 31
+
, 35
+
, 36
+
, 37
+
, 42+ |
56+ |
|||
Encouragement |
|
56 |
|||
Help from colleagues/co-worker assistance |
28
+
, 30
-
, 31
+
34
+
, 35
+
, 37
+
, 41+, 42+ |
46
+
, 49
+
, 56+ |
|||
Joint goal planning |
44 |
|
|||
Joint working |
35
+
, 44+ |
|
|||
Peer pressure |
36 |
|
|||
Performance feedback |
37 |
|
|||
Secretary dependent |
36 |
|
|||
Social relationships with co-workers (trust) |
31
+
, 35
+
, 37
-
|
56+, 57± |
|||
Support in the workplace |
29
+
, 30
-
, 34
+
, 35
+
, 42+ |
56+ |
|||
Workforce morale |
42 |
|
|||
e330 |
People in position of authority |
Employer assistance-support |
30
-
, 34
+
, 38
+
, 42- |
47
+
, 49
+
, 56+, 57+ |
|
Role of employer-supervisor |
30
+
, 31
+
, 37
+
|
51
-
, 57° |
|||
Support of rehabilitation staff |
33 |
|
|||
e4 Attitudes |
|
|
|
||
e425 |
Individual attitudes of acquaintances, peers, colleagues, neighbors and community members |
Appreciation of/consideration to mental disabilities |
41 |
|
|
Attitudinal barriers |
41-, 42- |
|
|||
Awareness/detection of the disability |
34
-
, 36°, 40
-
, 41+, 42- |
|
|||
Discrimination |
40
-
, 41-, 43- |
47
-
|
|||
Interest in, acceptance / understanding of dyslexia |
28
-
, 34
-
, 41-, 42-, 43- |
56-, 57- |
|||
Labeling people with LD as lazy, slow, dumb or stupid |
22
-
, 39
-
, 41-, 42- |
|
|||
LD makes me important |
34 |
|
|||
LD as a tool to address misconceptions about LD |
32
+
|
57+ |
|||
Reactions of co-workers |
28°, 31
-
32
+
, 34
±
, 35
-
, 36
-
, 39°, 40
-
, 41-, 42-, 43- |
56± |
|||
Stigmatization by colleagues |
40
-
, 42-, 43- |
|
|||
e430 |
Individual attitudes of people in position of authority |
Acceptance of dyslexia by employer |
34
+
, 36
+
, 43+ |
56- |
|
Detection/awareness of the disability |
34
-
, 36
-
, 40
-
, 41-, 42- |
47° |
|||
Employer attitudes and knowledge |
30
+
, 38
-
, 42- |
|
|||
High expectations of people with LD |
32
+
, 43- |
|
|||
Judgment of work on disability |
28 |
|
|||
Negative responses from employer |
31
-
, 34
-
, 40
-
|
|
|||
Stigmatization by employer |
40 |
|
|||
Work-related environmental factors: task content | |||||
|
Benefits of current position |
33 |
|
||
Challenging students to achieve their potential |
31
+
, 35
+
|
|
|||
Control over their work |
31
+
, 36
+
, |
|
|||
Demands involving reading or writing |
|
53-, 55-, 58- |
|||
Demands of the job |
33
-
, 37
-
|
46
+
|
|||
Finding a niche |
29
+
, 36
+
|
|
|||
Increase of independence |
36 |
|
|||
Job level |
28 |
|
|||
More responsibility |
31
+
, 30
+
, 33
+
, 34
+
|
|
|||
Much information in a constant stream |
|
56 |
|||
Multitasking is required |
|
56 |
|||
Prioritizing tasks |
|
46
+
, 49
+
, 57+ |
|||
Productivity demands |
33 |
|
|||
Self-regulation |
|
46
+
, 49
+
|
|||
Taking work home |
41+, 42- |
|
|||
Working under pressure |
42 |
|
|||
Workload, pressure, more stress |
29
-
, 34
-
, 41-, 42-, 43+ |
56- |
|||
To work by myself |
30
+
, 37
+
|
|
|||
Work-related environmental factors: working conditions | |||||
e125 |
Products and technology for communication |
Assistive technology (like a dictaphone, internet, navigation software, watch, microcassette) |
32
+
, 34
+
, 35
+
, 36
+
, 40
+
, 42+, 43+ |
46
+
, 57+ |
|
Clear signs |
42 |
|
|||
Computer spelling and grammar programs |
28
+
, 35
+
, 36
+
, 42+ |
56+ |
|||
Simple words and pictures |
42 |
|
|||
Technology interferes with work/Experiment with technology |
36 |
|
|||
Visual aids |
31 |
|
|||
Voice-mail |
36 |
|
|||
e135 |
Products and technology for employment |
Accommodations on the job |
29
-
, 30
-
, 32
+
, 34
+
, 36
+
, 38
-
, 40
-
, 42+, 43-, 44 |
46
+
, 49
-
, 57+° |
|
e1650 |
Financial assets |
Budget for an assistant |
28
+
, 34
+
|
|
|
Money |
40
-
, 41- |
|
|||
Other working conditions |
Accessibility of the office environment |
41 |
|
||
Changing/improving the work environment |
42 |
|
|||
Finding a quiet/personal work environment |
35
+
|
46
+
|
|||
Hearing the words spoken aloud |
36 |
|
|||
A mentor |
33
+
, 34
+
|
|
|||
Time |
31
-
, 34
+
, 35
-
, 37
-
, 41-, 42- |
|
|||
Using proofreaders |
35
+
, 36
+
, 43+ |
46
+
, 57+ |
|||
Other work-related environmental factors | |||||
|
Centrality of LD in his career |
39 |
|
||
Critical knowledge and experiences on LD of employers |
38 |
|
|||
Disabling barriers |
40 |
|
|||
Information about (the impact of) dyslexia for employers |
30
-
, 38
-
|
|
|||
Job shadows |
33 |
|
|||
Job visits |
33 |
|
|||
School-to-work program |
33 |
|
|||
Training sessions regarding disability |
41 |
|
|||
Vocational rehabilitation |
33 |
|
|||
Work-related injury risk |
|
50 |
|||
Other environmental factors | |||||
e550 |
Legal services, systems and policies |
Certifying disability |
41 |
|
|
Disability Discrimination Act |
41 |
|
|||
Diversity agenda |
41 |
|
|||
Equality issues |
41 |
|
|||
Knowledge of the ADA |
30 |
|
|||
Legislation on adults with LD |
34
+
, 41+ |
|
|||
e570 |
Social security services, systems and policies |
Income from government benefits/resources |
|
59 |
|
Personal factors |
|
|
|
||
--- |
General personal data: |
Age |
|
45°, 46°, 49°, 52°, 60° |
|
Socio-demographic factors | |||||
Gender |
|
45
+
, 46°, 47
-
48
-
, 49°, 50
+
, 52°. 54°, 60° |
|||
Language |
|
54 |
|||
Socio-economic status |
39
+
, 40
-
|
48
+
|
|||
Standard/level of education |
41° |
45°, 48
+
, 59+, 60+ |
|||
--- |
General ‘mental’ personal factors |
Aggravation |
30 |
|
|
Common sense |
|
56 |
|||
Confidence |
42+ |
56+ |
|||
Creative |
31
+
, 37
+
|
56+ |
|||
Demoralized |
40 |
|
|||
Desire to help others |
31
+
, 37
+
|
|
|||
Detail oriented |
36 |
|
|||
Diligent |
|
56 |
|||
Empathic |
31
+
|
56+, 57+ |
|||
Humorous |
35
+
|
56+ |
|||
Innovative |
31
+
, 37
+
|
|
|||
Learning/Coping strategies: |
28
+
, 29
+
, 31
+
, 37
+
, 40
+
, 41+, 42+ |
46
+
, 47
+
, 49
+
, 56+ |
|||
|
Adjusted to the disability |
43 |
|
||
Ask caller to speak slowly |
42 |
|
|||
Authoritative language |
39 |
|
|||
Avoid my weaknesses |
36 |
|
|||
Avoidance |
28
-
, 35
-
, 36
+
|
|
|||
Aware of limitations |
35 |
|
|||
Be aware of problem words |
42 |
|
|||
Bluffing |
39 |
|
|||
Camouflage |
28
-
, 40
-
|
|
|||
Compensatory skills |
36
+
, 39
+
, 43+ |
47
+
|
|||
Develop own shorthand |
42 |
|
|||
Disclosing weaknesses |
31 |
|
|||
Distancing himself from others |
29
-
, 39
-
|
|
|||
Establish themselves as intelligent |
40 |
|
|||
Excessive amount of energy in work |
28 |
|
|||
Exposing own difficulties |
31 |
|
|||
Get writings/forms checked |
35
+
, 42+ |
|
|||
Give colour coded feedback |
35 |
|
|||
Hiding the LD |
35
-
, 37
-
, 40
-
|
|
|||
Leave and come back later, when losing concentration |
42 |
|
|||
Make careful mental and concrete preparations |
35 |
|
|||
Make lists or leave notes for myself |
|
56 |
|||
Make people write things down what they have said |
35
+
, 36
+
|
|
|||
Mnemonics |
35 |
|
|||
Other practical solutions |
28 |
|
|||
Overcompensation |
28 |
|
|||
Paper and pencil in pocket |
42 |
|
|||
Pattern of overachieving |
29 |
|
|||
Physical activities to recall ideas |
35 |
|
|||
Read back messages to caller |
42 |
|
|||
Read novels to experience different types of writing |
42 |
|
|||
Repeat names many times |
42 |
|
|||
Repression |
28 |
|
|||
Tricks |
28 |
|
|||
Using prompts to recall topics |
35 |
|
|||
Use set phrases |
42 |
|
|||
Visualization techniques |
35 |
|
|||
Write things out in rough |
42 |
|
|||
Literacy level |
40
-
|
54+, 59+, 60+ |
|||
Openness |
28
±
, 30
-
, 31
+
, 42-, 43- |
|
|||
Patience |
36 |
|
|||
Personal problems |
28 |
|
|||
Pride |
29 |
|
|||
Satisfaction with life |
28 |
|
|||
Secretive |
43 |
|
|||
Sensitive to emotional experiences of others |
29
+
, 31
+
, 36
+
, 37
+
|
|
|||
Self-advocacy |
30
±
, 38
+
, 44+ |
|
|||
Self-control |
28 |
|
|||
Self-disclosure |
30
-
, 32
+
, 34
+
,35
+
, 37°, 38
-
, 39°, 40
-
, 43 |
46
-
, 49
0-, 56+, 57 |
|||
Self-efficacy |
35
+
|
46
+
, 49
+
|
|||
Self-empowerment |
39 |
|
|||
Self-esteem |
29
+
, 31
+
, 32
+
, 35
+
, 36
+
, 39
+
, 42+ |
48
+
|
|||
Self-promotion |
30 |
|
|||
Self-reliant |
36 |
|
|||
Self-sufficient |
36 |
|
|||
Social person |
36 |
|
|||
Stress avoidance |
28 |
|
|||
Stress-experience/being stressed |
28
-
, 29
-
, 34
-
, 35
-
, 36
-
, 37
-
, 42- |
|
|||
Stubborn |
|
57 |
|||
Tolerant |
|
56 |
|||
Visual |
31
+
, 35
+
|
|
|||
--- |
Health related personal factors |
Accepting the LD/dyslexia |
28 |
|
|
Experiences with LD/dyslexia |
29
-
, 37
-
|
|
|||
Impact of the LD/dyslexia |
28
-
, 36
-
, 37°, 40°, 41-, 42-, 43- |
46
-
, 49
0-, 55-, 56-. 57- |
|||
Locus of control |
|
48 |
|||
Management of the LD/dyslexia |
40 |
|
|||
--- | Work related personal factors | Collaborative/co-operative |
31 |
|
|
Commitment |
33 |
|
|||
Compliance |
38 |
|
|||
Determination |
31
+
, 35
+
, 36
+
, 42+ |
56+ |
|||
Focus |
33 |
|
|||
Force of will |
39 |
|
|||
Goal driven |
33 |
|
|||
Independence |
29
+
, 32
+
, 36
+
|
49
+
|
|||
Job/career satisfaction |
28
0+, 36
+
, 43+ |
46
+
, 49
+
, 51
-
|
|||
Prestige aspirations |
31
+
|
48
+
|
|||
Proactive |
31
+
|
|
|||
Productivity/worker characteristics |
|
47 |
|||
Successful |
29
+
, 31
+
, 32
+
, 36
+
, 41+ |
|
|||
Tenacity |
34 |
|
|||
Underchallenged |
29 |
|
|||
Work ethic | 29 |
The studies which are in bold are the studies that meet the minimum level of the quality criteria. (In each category the findings are in alphabetical order).