Skip to main content
. 2014 Jan 24;14:77. doi: 10.1186/1471-2458-14-77

Table 3.

The factors from all studies coded on the two-level classifications of ICF

2 nd level ICF Factors Qualitative studies Quantitative studies
Functions & structures
 
 
 
b1 Mental functions
 
 
 
b114
Orientation functions
 
36 - , 37 -
 
b126
Temperament and personality functions
Adaptability
34 + , 39 +
 
Optimistic
 
55
Perseverance/persistence
28 + , 29 + , 31 + , 35 + 36 + , 42+
46 + , 57+
Personal characteristics
 
47
Uncertain/insecure
28 - , 29 -
 
b140
Attention functions
 
30 - , 34 - , 36 -
 
b144
Memory functions
 
31 - , 34 + , 36 - 37 - , 43-
56-
Remembering instructions
42
 
Remembering names
42
 
b152
Emotional functions
Amount of passion
39
 
Anxiety
28 - , 37 - , 40 -
 
Aggressive feelings
28
 
Concern for patient safety
 
56
Confusion/anger
29 - , 30 - , 32 - , 37 - , 42-
 
Depression
37
 
Discouragement
32
 
Emotional problems
28
 
Fear of being stigmatized
40 - , 42-, 43-
 
Fear of exposure
37 - , 43-
 
Fear of failure
28 -
56-
Feelings of accomplishment
43-
49 +
Feeling of being different
28 - , 37 - , 43-
 
Feeling of inadequacy
34 - , 42-
 
Feeling of presenting a false impression (impostor phenomenon)
37
 
Frustration
28 - , 30 - , 32 - 37 -
 
Guilt/embarrassment
34 - , 37 -
55-, 56-
Inferiority feelings
28 - , 31 - , 37 -
56-
Sense of strength
29 + , 31 + , 35 +
 
Shame
34 - , 37 - , 43-
 
b156
Perception
 
29 + , 37 +
 
b160
Thought functions
 
29 + , 34 + , 35 - , 36 +
56+
b164
Higher-level cognitive functions
Executive functions
35
 
Holistic/visual thinking
31 + , 35 +
 
Increased creativity
29 + , 36 + , 37 +
 
Information processing
 
49 - , 57-
Organization and planning
29 - , 31 + , 36 + , 37 - , 39 -
49 + , 56-, 57-
Thinking outside the box
29
 
b167
Mental functions of language
Word retrieval
37
 
b180
Experience of self and time functions
Bothered by being different
36
 
Depersonalize LD
36
 
Disability self-awareness
30 + , 35 + , 36 +
 
Labeling LD as a kind of self-mockery
39
 
Negative self-perceptions
30 - , 34 - , 37 -
 
Not seeing themselves as having a disability
30 + , 40 +
 
Self-conscious
40
 
Activities (d1- d6) and participation (d7- d9)
d1 Learning and applying knowledge
d115
Listening
 
36
 
d155
Acquiring skills
Analytical skills
36 +
57-
Developing coping strategies
40
 
Developing different learning styles
42
 
Learning a new skill
42°, 44+
 
Learning operating instrument names
42
 
Practical skills
31 + , 35 +
 
d160
Focusing attention
 
31 + , 37 +
 
d166
Reading
 
28 - , 29 - , 30 - , 31 - , 35 - , 36 - , 37 - , 40 - , 42-, 43-
45°, 54°, 55-, 56-, 57-, 60-
d170
Writing (spelling)
 
28 - , 29 - , 30 - , 31 - , 34 - , 35 - , 36 - , 39 - , 40 - , 42-, 43-
49 - , 54-, 55-, 56-, 57-, 60-
Writing reports to work
33 - , 41-, 42-
 
d172
Calculating
 
36 + , 42-, 43-
56-, 60-
d175
Solving problems
 
31 + , 34 + , 36 + , 37 +
57+
d2 General tasks and demands
d210
Undertaking a single task
 
37
 
d220
Undertaking multiple tasks
Correcting mistakes
 
52
Gathering information
36°
56-
Giving lectures/presentations/training sessions
31 + , 35 - , 42-
 
Meetings
42-
56-
Representing a group
42
 
d230
Carrying out daily routine
 
28 ± , 36 ± , 37 ± , 40 ± , 42-, 43±
 
d240
Handling stress and other responsibilities
 
36
 
Handling responsibilities
28
 
d3 Communication
 
 
 
d310
Communicating with – receiving – spoken messages
 
30 - , 36 ±
 
d315
Communicating with – receiving nonverbal messages
Receiving body gestures
35
 
d325
Communicating with – receiving – written messages
 
30 - , 36 - , 37 -
49 - , 57-
d330
Speaking
 
28 - , 31 + , 35 + , 36 ±
56-
Speaking in public
 
56
d335
Producing nonverbalmessages
Using drawings
31 + , 35 +
 
d345
Writing messages
Completing a literacy exercise
40
 
Filling in application forms
30 - , 40 - , 42-
60-
Keeping records
42+
56-
Note taking
30 - , 36 + , 42-
 
Taking telephone messages
42
 
d355
Discussion
Discussing (LD with employer/problems with colleagues)
30 - , 31 + , 34°, 35 +
 
d 360
Using communication devices and techniques
Dialing a phone
36
 
Multitasking (on a computer)
36
 
Using computer software/skills
28 + , 35 + , 36 + , 40 +
57-
d6 Domestic life
 
 
 
d660
Assisting others
Helping students
31 + , 32 + , 35 +
 
 
Motivate students
31 + , 32 + , 35 +
 
 
Validate students feelings
31 + , 32 + , 35 +
 
d7 Interpersonal interactions and relationships
d710
Basic interpersonal interactions
 
32
 
Using social skills
31 + , 35 +
46 +
d720
Complex interpersonal interactions
Forming relationships
28 - , 36 -
 
d740
Formal relationships
Relationships with clients
41
 
d8 Major life areas
d845
Acquiring, keeping and terminating a job
Ability to maintain the career
29 - , 40 -
56-
Demotion or dismissal
37 - , 40 - , 43-
56-
Meeting their goals
32 + , 42+
 
Occupation choice
42-
46°, 53-, 56-, 58-, 59-
Securing his current position
29 - , 34 + , 40 -
46 - , 49°, 57-
Seeking employment
40
 
Skills for performing the job
43
 
Survive within the workplace
40
 
Terminating a job
34 - , 43-
 
Working much harder
28 - , 31 - , 35 - , 36 -
 
d850
Remunerative employment
Achievement/accomplishment
28 - , 29 ± , 31 - 42±, 43-
 
Continuous changing of employment
40
 
Employment roles
40
 
Employment in unskilled/semiskilled occupations
28 - , 40 -
50 - , 60+
Employment in white-collar/blue-collar jobs
 
45°, 52 + , 53+, 55+
Enabled to excel
36
 
Having a job/being employed
28 +
47 + , 51 + , 55+
Having more jobs
 
47
Job history
28
 
Job at the level of their training or higher
28 + , 36 +
 
Job performance
33 + , 34 + , 43-
 
Limited employment opportunities
43-
47 - , 55-
Part-time employment
28 + , 29 +
55-
Permanently employed
 
55+, 60-
Quality of products and processes
41
 
Unemployed
28 - , 40 -
48 - , 52 - , 59-
Workforce abilities
 
47
Work-related environmental factors: terms of employment
 
Access to degree courses
42-
56+
Attendance
33
 
Change in job description/title
34
 
Current (annual) salary
 
46°, 49 + °, 51 - , 52 - , 59°
Extra study leave
42
 
Extra time
34 +
56+, 57+
Flexible schedule
33 + , 41+
 
Incentives and bonuses
34
 
Income derived from employment
 
59
On-the-job training agreement
31 + , 33 +
 
Promotion/Job advancement
30 + , 33 + , 34 + , 42+
51 -
Tenure used as productivity signal
30 +
47 +
Tenure with current employer
30 +
47 +
Wage -gap (with non-LD)
 
47 - , 51°, 52 +
Wage increase/decrease
33 + , 34 +
47 +
Working from home
41
 
Working at off hours late in the day or night
36 + , 41+, 42-
46 + , 49 + , 50 + 56+, 57+
Work-related environmental factors: social relationships at work
e3 Support and relationships
e315/e320
Extended family/friends
Support from family/friends
28 + , 29 + , 32 + , 33 + , 34 + , 35 + , 39 +
55+
e325
Acquaintances, peers, colleagues, neighbors and community members
Being loners/isolated in the job
37
 
Control/check by others
28 + , 31 + , 35 + , 36 + , 37 + , 42+
56+
Encouragement
 
56
Help from colleagues/co-worker assistance
28 + , 30 - , 31 + 34 + , 35 + , 37 + , 41+, 42+
46 + , 49 + , 56+
Joint goal planning
44
 
Joint working
35 + , 44+
 
Peer pressure
36
 
Performance feedback
37
 
Secretary dependent
36
 
Social relationships with co-workers (trust)
31 + , 35 + , 37 -
56+, 57±
Support in the workplace
29 + , 30 - , 34 + , 35 + , 42+
56+
Workforce morale
42
 
e330
People in position of authority
Employer assistance-support
30 - , 34 + , 38 + , 42-
47 + , 49 + , 56+, 57+
Role of employer-supervisor
30 + , 31 + , 37 +
51 - , 57°
Support of rehabilitation staff
33
 
e4 Attitudes
 
 
 
e425
Individual attitudes of acquaintances, peers, colleagues, neighbors and community members
Appreciation of/consideration to mental disabilities
41
 
Attitudinal barriers
41-, 42-
 
Awareness/detection of the disability
34 - , 36°, 40 - , 41+, 42-
 
Discrimination
40 - , 41-, 43-
47 -
Interest in, acceptance / understanding of dyslexia
28 - , 34 - , 41-, 42-, 43-
56-, 57-
Labeling people with LD as lazy, slow, dumb or stupid
22 - , 39 - , 41-, 42-
 
LD makes me important
34
 
LD as a tool to address misconceptions about LD
32 +
57+
Reactions of co-workers
28°, 31 - 32 + , 34 ± , 35 - , 36 - , 39°, 40 - , 41-, 42-, 43-
56±
Stigmatization by colleagues
40 - , 42-, 43-
 
e430
Individual attitudes of people in position of authority
Acceptance of dyslexia by employer
34 + , 36 + , 43+
56-
Detection/awareness of the disability
34 - , 36 - , 40 - , 41-, 42-
47°
Employer attitudes and knowledge
30 + , 38 - , 42-
 
High expectations of people with LD
32 + , 43-
 
Judgment of work on disability
28
 
Negative responses from employer
31 - , 34 - , 40 -
 
Stigmatization by employer
40
 
Work-related environmental factors: task content
 
Benefits of current position
33
 
Challenging students to achieve their potential
31 + , 35 +
 
Control over their work
31 + , 36 + ,
 
Demands involving reading or writing
 
53-, 55-, 58-
Demands of the job
33 - , 37 -
46 +
Finding a niche
29 + , 36 +
 
Increase of independence
36
 
Job level
28
 
More responsibility
31 + , 30 + , 33 + , 34 +
 
Much information in a constant stream
 
56
Multitasking is required
 
56
Prioritizing tasks
 
46 + , 49 + , 57+
Productivity demands
33
 
Self-regulation
 
46 + , 49 +
Taking work home
41+, 42-
 
Working under pressure
42
 
Workload, pressure, more stress
29 - , 34 - , 41-, 42-, 43+
56-
To work by myself
30 + , 37 +
 
Work-related environmental factors: working conditions
e125
Products and technology for communication
Assistive technology (like a dictaphone, internet, navigation software, watch, microcassette)
32 + , 34 + , 35 + , 36 + , 40 + , 42+, 43+
46 + , 57+
Clear signs
42
 
Computer spelling and grammar programs
28 + , 35 + , 36 + , 42+
56+
Simple words and pictures
42
 
Technology interferes with work/Experiment with technology
36
 
Visual aids
31
 
Voice-mail
36
 
e135
Products and technology for employment
Accommodations on the job
29 - , 30 - , 32 + , 34 + , 36 + , 38 - , 40 - , 42+, 43-, 44
46 + , 49 - , 57+°
e1650
Financial assets
Budget for an assistant
28 + , 34 +
 
Money
40 - , 41-
 
Other working conditions
Accessibility of the office environment
41
 
Changing/improving the work environment
42
 
Finding a quiet/personal work environment
35 +
46 +
Hearing the words spoken aloud
36
 
A mentor
33 + , 34 +
 
Time
31 - , 34 + , 35 - , 37 - , 41-, 42-
 
Using proofreaders
35 + , 36 + , 43+
46 + , 57+
Other work-related environmental factors
 
Centrality of LD in his career
39
 
Critical knowledge and experiences on LD of employers
38
 
Disabling barriers
40
 
Information about (the impact of) dyslexia for employers
30 - , 38 -
 
Job shadows
33
 
Job visits
33
 
School-to-work program
33
 
Training sessions regarding disability
41
 
Vocational rehabilitation
33
 
Work-related injury risk
 
50
Other environmental factors
e550
Legal services, systems and policies
Certifying disability
41
 
Disability Discrimination Act
41
 
Diversity agenda
41
 
Equality issues
41
 
Knowledge of the ADA
30
 
Legislation on adults with LD
34 + , 41+
 
e570
Social security services, systems and policies
Income from government benefits/resources
 
59
Personal factors
 
 
 
---
General personal data:
Age
 
45°, 46°, 49°, 52°, 60°
Socio-demographic factors
Gender
 
45 + , 46°, 47 - 48 - , 49°, 50 + , 52°. 54°, 60°
Language
 
54
Socio-economic status
39 + , 40 -
48 +
Standard/level of education
41°
45°, 48 + , 59+, 60+
---
General ‘mental’ personal factors
Aggravation
30
 
Common sense
 
56
Confidence
42+
56+
Creative
31 + , 37 +
56+
Demoralized
40
 
Desire to help others
31 + , 37 +
 
Detail oriented
36
 
Diligent
 
56
Empathic
31 +
56+, 57+
Humorous
35 +
56+
Innovative
31 + , 37 +
 
Learning/Coping strategies:
28 + , 29 + , 31 + , 37 + , 40 + , 41+, 42+
46 + , 47 + , 49 + , 56+
 
Adjusted to the disability
43
 
Ask caller to speak slowly
42
 
Authoritative language
39
 
Avoid my weaknesses
36
 
Avoidance
28 - , 35 - , 36 +
 
Aware of limitations
35
 
Be aware of problem words
42
 
Bluffing
39
 
Camouflage
28 - , 40 -
 
Compensatory skills
36 + , 39 + , 43+
47 +
Develop own shorthand
42
 
Disclosing weaknesses
31
 
Distancing himself from others
29 - , 39 -
 
Establish themselves as intelligent
40
 
Excessive amount of energy in work
28
 
Exposing own difficulties
31
 
Get writings/forms checked
35 + , 42+
 
Give colour coded feedback
35
 
Hiding the LD
35 - , 37 - , 40 -
 
Leave and come back later, when losing concentration
42
 
Make careful mental and concrete preparations
35
 
Make lists or leave notes for myself
 
56
Make people write things down what they have said
35 + , 36 +
 
Mnemonics
35
 
Other practical solutions
28
 
Overcompensation
28
 
Paper and pencil in pocket
42
 
Pattern of overachieving
29
 
Physical activities to recall ideas
35
 
Read back messages to caller
42
 
Read novels to experience different types of writing
42
 
Repeat names many times
42
 
Repression
28
 
Tricks
28
 
Using prompts to recall topics
35
 
Use set phrases
42
 
Visualization techniques
35
 
Write things out in rough
42
 
Literacy level
40 -
54+, 59+, 60+
Openness
28 ± , 30 - , 31 + , 42-, 43-
 
Patience
36
 
Personal problems
28
 
Pride
29
 
Satisfaction with life
28
 
Secretive
43
 
Sensitive to emotional experiences of others
29 + , 31 + , 36 + , 37 +
 
Self-advocacy
30 ± , 38 + , 44+
 
Self-control
28
 
Self-disclosure
30 - , 32 + , 34 + ,35 + , 37°, 38 - , 39°, 40 - , 43
46 - , 49 0-, 56+, 57
Self-efficacy
35 +
46 + , 49 +
Self-empowerment
39
 
Self-esteem
29 + , 31 + , 32 + , 35 + , 36 + , 39 + , 42+
48 +
Self-promotion
30
 
Self-reliant
36
 
Self-sufficient
36
 
Social person
36
 
Stress avoidance
28
 
Stress-experience/being stressed
28 - , 29 - , 34 - , 35 - , 36 - , 37 - , 42-
 
Stubborn
 
57
Tolerant
 
56
Visual
31 + , 35 +
 
---
Health related personal factors
Accepting the LD/dyslexia
28
 
Experiences with LD/dyslexia
29 - , 37 -
 
Impact of the LD/dyslexia
28 - , 36 - , 37°, 40°, 41-, 42-, 43-
46 - , 49 0-, 55-, 56-. 57-
Locus of control
 
48
Management of the LD/dyslexia
40
 
--- Work related personal factors Collaborative/co-operative
31
 
Commitment
33
 
Compliance
38
 
Determination
31 + , 35 + , 36 + , 42+
56+
Focus
33
 
Force of will
39
 
Goal driven
33
 
Independence
29 + , 32 + , 36 +
49 +
Job/career satisfaction
28 0+, 36 + , 43+
46 + , 49 + , 51 -
Prestige aspirations
31 +
48 +
Proactive
31 +
 
Productivity/worker characteristics
 
47
Successful
29 + , 31 + , 32 + , 36 + , 41+
 
Tenacity
34
 
Underchallenged
29
 
Work ethic 29  

The studies which are in bold are the studies that meet the minimum level of the quality criteria. (In each category the findings are in alphabetical order).