Skip to main content
. 2014 Feb 11;9(2):e86281. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0086281

Table 6. Estimates of treatment effects on plant sizes throughout the growing season, as well as peak size and number of thawing degree days needed to reach peak size.

Species Treatment Effect ± sd t-value p-value df Peak size TDD peak
Alopecurus magellanicus Intercept (Normal) 84.4±11.4 112.9 334.0
Removed 14.1±13.3 1.06 0.291 104.5 322.4
Shallow 15.2±10.4 1.45 0.148 137.2 345.2
Medium 42.1±9.9 4.25 <0.001 168.4 362.8
Deep 19.1±10.0 1.91 0.058 173 127.0 334.9
Bistorta vivipara Intercept (Normal) 360.5±60.6 505.4 296.0
Removed 23.8±73.0 0.33 0.745 489.1 280.2
Shallow 11.3±63.7 0.18 0.859 471.6 271.9
Medium 238.3±63.2 3.77 <0.001 793.1 297.6
Deep 344.3±60.0 5.73 <0.001 295 705.1 370.1
Cassiope tetragona Intercept (Normal) 2.32±0.29 3.41 419.6
Removed −1.37±0.39 −3.53 <0.001 1.34 466.7
Shallow −2.13±0.31 −6.78 <0.001 0.16 0.0
Medium −1.89±0.32 −5.93 <0.001 0.18 295.1
Deep −0.84±0.29 −2.91 0.004 177 1.47 494.9
Dryas octopetala Intercept (Normal) 18.2±2.2 22.2 410.2
Removed 5.1±2.0 2.51 0.013 31.3 570.0
Shallow −0.8±1.7 −0.45 0.653 21.3 399.0
Medium 11.0±1.9 5.96 <0.001 38.5 542.0
Deep 6.9±1.9 3.69 <0.001 288 33.9 497.6
Luzula arcuata Intercept (Normal) 77.4±10.9 108.9 236.6
Removed 20.5±8.7 2.35 0.020 122.0 240.1
Shallow −23.8±7.1 −3.37 <0.001 71.0 248.5
Medium −7.9±7.6 −1.05 0.297 127.7 287.1
Deep 11.2±7.0 1.60 0.112 261 131.9 269.0
Pedicularis hirsuta Intercept (Normal) 29.6±2.2 34.9 526.6
Removed −4.5±1.8 −2.46 0.016 22.0 413.3
Shallow −12.4±1.5 −8.02 <0.001 22.6 520.8
Medium −5.7±1.9 −3.04 0.003 31.3 428.8
Deep −0.4±2.2 −0.17 0.867 112 47.0 570.0
Salix polaris Intercept (Normal) 12.1±0.7 15.2 281.3
Removed 0.3±0.7 0.51 0.611 14.1 283.0
Shallow 0.6±0.6 1.08 0.283 14.8 280.3
Medium −0.2±0.6 −0.40 0.693 13.9 329.4
Deep −1.3±0.6 −2.34 0.020 324 10.5 296.2
Stellaria crassipes Intercept (Normal) 6.9±1.4 10.9 515.7
Removed 3.1±1.9 1.60 0.112 11.5 570.0
Shallow 4.4±1.9 2.36 0.020 5.7 489.9
Medium −3.4±1.7 −1.98 0.050 7.2 570.0
Deep −1.8±2.0 −0.89 0.373 148 10.0 570.0

Effect values other than the intercept (here: Normal treatment) are deviations from the latter. Given are standard deviation (sd), t- and p-value and degrees of freedom (df) of the model. Modeled maximal plant sizes and TDD (thawing degree days, i.e. positive air temperature sums in °C) to reach the maximum size are based on the model shown in Table 3, and are shown as values for each treatment, rather than deviation from the Normal treatment. Normal = unmanipulated snow cover; Removed = snow removal on 1. May; Shallow = naturally early snowmelt; Medium = intermediately increased snow; Deep = maximally increased snow. Measures for plant species: average sum of leaf lengths (in mm) for Alopecurus magellanicus, Dryas octopetala, Luzula arcuata, Salix polaris; average sum of leaf areas (in mm2) for Bistorta vivipara; average annual shoot increment (in mm) for Cassiope tetragona; average plant sizes (in mm) for Pedicularis hirsuta, Stellaria crassipes.