Keltner[20]
|
Author’s judgment
|
Support of judgment
|
Allocation sequence (potential selection bias)
|
Unclear risk
|
Method not specified
|
Allocation concealment (potential selection bias)
|
Low risk
|
Allocation was performed independently by a person not associated with the project
|
Baseline differences in outcomes
|
High risk
|
Imbalanced for the marital status and not adjusted
|
Baseline differences in characteristics
|
Low risk
|
No significant difference see Table 1
|
Incomplete outcome data (potential attrition bias)
|
Low risk
|
No attrition
|
Knowledge of interventions (potential detection bias)
|
Low risk
|
Assessed blindly: assessors blinding: local professionals who would likely know some or all of the families participating were not involved in the assessments
|
Contamination
|
-
|
-
|
Selective outcome reporting
|
Low risk
|
No other outcomes mentioned
|
Other risks of bias
|
Low risk
|
|
Scafidi[22]
|
Author’s judgment
|
Support of judgment
|
Allocation sequence
|
Low risk
|
Random number table
|
Allocation concealment
|
Low risk
|
Randomised by researcher not associated with the project
|
Baseline differences in outcomes
|
Low risk
|
Imbalanced but adjusted
|
Baseline differences in characteristics
|
Low risk
|
Adjusted
|
Incomplete outcome data
|
Low risk
|
No drop out
|
Knowledge of interventions
|
Low risk
|
Assessors were blind to the group intervention
|
Contamination
|
-
|
-
|
Selective outcome reporting
|
Low risk
|
No other outcomes mentioned
|
Other risks of bias
|
Low risk
|
|
Barbosa[21]
|
Author’s judgment
|
Support of judgment
|
Allocation sequence
|
High risk
|
By clinic attendance day
|
Allocation concealment
|
Unclear risk
|
No information
|
Baseline differences in outcomes
|
Unclear risk
|
No information
|
Baseline differences in characteristics
|
High risk
|
No comparison made between the groups
|
Incomplete outcome data
|
Unclear
|
No information
|
Knowledge of interventions
|
Unclear
|
No information
|
Contamination
|
-
|
-
|
Selective outcome reporting
|
Low risk
|
Only reported items measured
|
Other risks of bias |
Low risk |
|