Skip to main content
. 2014 Feb 5;14:58. doi: 10.1186/1471-2393-14-58

Table 2.

Risk of bias of the included studies

 
Keltner[20]
Author’s judgment
Support of judgment
Allocation sequence (potential selection bias)
Unclear risk
Method not specified
Allocation concealment (potential selection bias)
Low risk
Allocation was performed independently by a person not associated with the project
Baseline differences in outcomes
High risk
Imbalanced for the marital status and not adjusted
Baseline differences in characteristics
Low risk
No significant difference see Table 1
Incomplete outcome data (potential attrition bias)
Low risk
No attrition
Knowledge of interventions (potential detection bias)
Low risk
Assessed blindly: assessors blinding: local professionals who would likely know some or all of the families participating were not involved in the assessments
Contamination
-
-
Selective outcome reporting
Low risk
No other outcomes mentioned
Other risks of bias
Low risk
 
Scafidi[22]
Author’s judgment
Support of judgment
Allocation sequence
Low risk
Random number table
Allocation concealment
Low risk
Randomised by researcher not associated with the project
Baseline differences in outcomes
Low risk
Imbalanced but adjusted
Baseline differences in characteristics
Low risk
Adjusted
Incomplete outcome data
Low risk
No drop out
Knowledge of interventions
Low risk
Assessors were blind to the group intervention
Contamination
-
-
Selective outcome reporting
Low risk
No other outcomes mentioned
Other risks of bias
Low risk
 
Barbosa[21]
Author’s judgment
Support of judgment
Allocation sequence
High risk
By clinic attendance day
Allocation concealment
Unclear risk
No information
Baseline differences in outcomes
Unclear risk
No information
Baseline differences in characteristics
High risk
No comparison made between the groups
Incomplete outcome data
Unclear
No information
Knowledge of interventions
Unclear
No information
Contamination
-
-
Selective outcome reporting
Low risk
Only reported items measured
Other risks of bias Low risk