Skip to main content
. 2014 Feb 13;348:g425. doi: 10.1136/bmj.g425

Table 1.

 Summary of key model inputs, data sources, and uncertainty and “what if” analyses

Input Sources for model variables Modelled with variability Uncertainty analysis “What if” analysis
Cycle hire:
 Usage D1 No No No
 Duration of cycle hire travel time in past year D1 Yes No No
 Age structure and sex split of population with % cycle hire travel time D1, D2, D3 No Yes, for age Yes
 % trips newly generated by cycle hire D2 No Yes No
 Modal shift among trips not newly generated D1, D2 No No Yes
Physical activity model:
 Counterfactual (baseline) active travel, and change resulting from cycle hire D1, D2, D4, D5 Yes Yes Yes
 Counterfactual (baseline) other physical activity D6 Yes Yes Yes
 MET intensity in different activities D5, D6, 4 13 Yes, for cycling No No
 Health impacts of physical activity, through specific diseases D7, 14 15 No Yes No
 Health impacts of physical activity, directly through all cause mortality D8, 16 17 No Yes No
 Smaller mortality reduction from physical activity at younger ages 17 No Yes No
Air pollution model:
 PM2.5 concentration along cycle hire and counterfactual routes D9, D10, 18 No Yes, for underground Yes
 Pollution scaling factors in different modes 13 19-21 Yes, through MET variability No No
 Health impacts of PM2.5 D721 22 No Yes No
Injuries model:
 Observed injury rate for cycle hire D1, D11 No No No
 Modelled injury rate for counterfactual modes D4, D12, 23 24 No Yes Yes
 Under-reporting of injuries in routine data 25 No Yes No
 Health burden of injuries D7, 26 No Yes No

D=datasets; MET=metabolic equivalents of task; PM2.5=air pollution particles of diameter ≤2.5 μm.

D1=operational registration plus data on cycle hire usage, July 2010-March 2012, provided by Transport for London, including trip level data for final 12 months (1 April 2011 to 31 March 2012).

D2=online survey of 2652 registered users July 2011, provided by Transport for London.

D3=intercept survey of 1034 casual users July 2011, provided by Transport for London.

D4=London travel demand survey, 56 671 adult London residents, 2005-09.27

D5=national travel survey, 10 949 adult London residents, 2005-09.28

D6=health survey for England, 2669 adult London residents, 2008.29

D7=UK burden of disease, 2010, provided by World Health Organization30; data then reweighted for size and demographic structure of population of cycle hire users.

D8=London specific life tables for 2008-10, provided by Office for National Statistics.

D9=Routino software (www.routino.org) used to identify routes on road and cycling network, derived from OpenStreetMap (CCBY-SA).

D10=London atmospheric emissions inventory 2008 concentration maps, for PM2.5.31

D11=police recorded road traffic crashes involving a cycle hire bicycle 2010-12 (STATS19), collated and provided by Transport for London.

D12=routinely collected police information on all road traffic crashes (STATS19) 2005-11.32