Table 1.
Characteristics of the included studies.
| Author/year/design/setting | Time lapse | Age | Gender | Number of patients | Resection | Anastomosis | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ORH1 | TLRH2 | LRH3 | ||||||
|
Stipa et al., 2000 [33] CCT4 Rome Italy |
1998 1999 |
ORHM5 63 ORHT6 69 |
NA7 | (i) 17 ORHT Incision started 1 cm above the umbilicus to the anterior axillary line (ii) 27 ORHM (60% xiphopubic, 40% xiphoumbilical) |
NA | NA | ||
|
| ||||||||
| Lindgren et al., 2001 [34] RCT8 Goteborg Sweden |
2000 | NA | NA | (i) 23 ORHM (ii) 17 ORHT Incision from the left hypochondrium rostral to the umbilicus to the right flank dividing the right half of the rectus muscle ± part of the left rectus |
NA | NA | ||
|
| ||||||||
| Brown Et Al., 2004 [35] Rct Sheffield UK |
Aug 2001 Aug 2002 |
ORHM 70 (30–90) ORHT 74 (42–86) |
ORHM F 6 (43%) ORHT F 8 (57%) |
(i) 14 ORHT Incision following the skin crease from the midline 1 cm above the umbilicus (ii) 14 ORHM |
NA | NA | ||
|
| ||||||||
| Lohsiriwat et al., 2007 [36] CCT Bangkok Thailand |
2004 2006 |
LRH 56.9 ± 13.5 ORH 65.2 ± 6.0 |
LRH F 53.8 ORH F 65.O |
20 ORHT Incision on the right side of abdomen about 1 cm above the umbilicus |
13 | Extracorporeally | Side-to-side stapled ileocolic anastomosis was performed extracorporeally | |
|
| ||||||||
| Tan et al., 2009 [37] CCT Singapore Singapore |
2005 2007 |
LRH: M 19 (51%) F 18 (49%) ORH: M22 (55%) F 18 (45%) |
LRH 68 (37–83) ORH 67 (42–87) |
(i) 18 (45%) Midline incision (ii) 22 (55%) Right transverse skin crease incision on the right flank |
(i) 29 Transverse (78%) (ii) 8 Vertical (22%) |
The intracorporeal ligature of vascular pedicle was performed with either laparoscopic linear staples or with LigaSure vessel sealing system. Resection of bowel was performed extracorporeally | End-to-end ileocolic anastomosis was performed extracorporeally with linear staples | |
|
| ||||||||
| Veenhof et al., 2010 [38] CCT Amsterdam Holland The Netherlands |
2005 2009 |
LRH 68 (61–79) ORHT 75 (67.78) |
LRH M 13 (52%) F 12 (48%) ORHT M 9 (32%) F 19 (68%) |
28 ORHT Incision on the right side of abdomen about 1 cm above the umbilicus |
25 | NA | NA | |
|
| ||||||||
| Tanis et al., 2012 [39] CCT Amsterdam The Netherlands |
2006 2009 |
LRH 75 (31–85) ORHM 74 (47–83) ORHT 73 (54–85) |
LRH 12 (40%) ORHM M 9 (41%) ORHT M 10 (43%) |
(i) 23 ORHT (ii) 22 ORHM |
30 | NA | Ileocolic anastomosis was performed extracorporeally | |
1Open right hemicolectomy.
2Totally laparoscopic right hemicolectomy.
3Laparoscopic-assisted right hemicolectomy.
4Clinical controlled trial.
5Open right hemicolectomy median incision.
6Open right hemicolectomy transverse incision.
7Not available.
8Randomized controlled trial.