Table 2. Case series published in the English literature since 2000 for renal arterial embolization performed in the setting of renal cell carcinoma, in order of year of publication, number of patients, indication for embolization, conclusions, and study limitations.
First author | Year of publication | Number of patients | Indication | Study conclusions | Study limitations |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Zielinski17 | 2000 | 118 | Preoperative | RAE with improved overall 5- and 10-y survival as compared with 116 case-matched controls (62 vs. 47, 35 vs. 23%) particularly for T2, T3, and node-positive disease | Single center Variability in time delay from embolization to surgery (Only 56% performed 1–3 d before surgery) Variability in embolization agents |
Onishi22 | 2001 | 24 | Palliation | RAE effective in palliation with 75% improvement in symptoms and increased overall survival (229 vs. 116 d) compared with similar controls | 7-mo overall survival of RAE poorer than 17.8 mo reported for cytoreductive nephrectomy, though cohort of this study had poorer performance status |
Munro21 | 2003 | 25 | Palliation | RAE effective in palliation with 70% improvement in symptoms | |
Maxwell19 | 2007 | 19 | Palliation | RAE effective for palliation with 18/19 symptom control | |
Schwartz15 | 2007 | 121 | 66 preoperative 15 AML 13 vascular lesions 8 palliation 19 other |
RAE well tolerated with minimal complications, and suggestion of improved intraoperative times and decreased blood loss in the perioperative setting | Outcomes study with no matched controls for comparison |
May16 | 2009 | 227 | Preoperative | RAE with no difference in overall survival and trend toward worsened cancer-specific survival as compared with oncologic matched controls | Poor control matching with controls taken from 1992 to 2006 as compared with a RAE historical group (1992–1997) Coils used as the sole embolic agent in 95% of cases |
Subramanian18 | 2009 | 135 | Preoperative advanced stage RCC with IVC involvement | RAE with no measurable benefit in reducing blood loss or perioperative complications, with increased perioperative mortality and trend toward increased transfusion requirement | Poor control matching with embolization group with increased ASA scores in 3–4 (97 vs. 90%), increased vascular tumor thrombus extent (66 vs. 48%) level III–IV, and use of vascular bypass (52 vs. 28%) |
Mukund20 | 2010 | 8 | Palliation | 88% effective at palliation of symptoms | Small series of case reports |
Abbreviations: AML, angiomyolipoma; IVC, inferior vena cava; RAE, renal artery embolization; RCC, renal cell carcinoma.