Table 1.
Question components | Systematic review | |
---|---|---|
Inclusion criteria | Exclusion criteria | |
Population | Any LTC as per DoH definition18 | Acute conditions, stress, bereavement etc |
Exposure/intervention | Any form of therapeutic writing including emotional disclosure/expressive writing, poetry, diaries, etc | Talking to a listener, counselling, psychotherapy, talking into a tape recorder, mobile phone or similar where this is the primary mode of delivering the intervention, expressive drama, dance, film-making. Evaluation of other people's writing |
Comparison | Non-writing, waiting list, inexpressive writing, attention controls and any control thought to be inactive | Any active or possibly active control including therapeutic writing |
Outcome | Any relevant clinical outcomes including disease-specific outcomes and generic outcomes such as: quality of life, health service use, psychological outcomes, behavioural outcomes, social functioning, adverse events, adherence to therapies and costs | Intermediate physiological outcomes such as salivary cortisol, immune parameters not routinely measured in the management of LTCs No reporting of numerical results for each group |
Study designs | Any comparative studies including RCTs, cohort or case–control studies. Economic evaluations | Single case reports, case series, studies where results for intervention and control groups are not presented separately |
DoH, Department of Health; LTC, long-term medical condition; RCTs, randomised controlled trials.