TABLE 3—
Examples of Shared Barriers to Health Research Participation as Observed in the Studies Reviewed From a Search on PubMed and Web of Science From January 2000 to December 2011
Racial/Ethnic Group Observed
Examples |
|||||
Barriers | Articles, No. (%) | African American | Asian American | Latino | Pacific Islander |
Mistrust | 34 (77.3) | Perceive research will benefit Whites or the research institution and not people of color76 | Concerns related to signing the informed consent77 | Believe medical experimentation occurs when accessing health care67 | Negative feelings about the purpose and intent of research41 |
Competing demands | 20 (45.4) | Inconvenience62; cost of participation34 | Lack of time78 and financial resources79 | Time conflicts and lack of childcare67 | |
Unintended outcomes | 14 (31.8) | Concerns about future long- and short-term side effects80 | Uncertainty of risks, side effects, and effectiveness of clinical trials81 | Fear of vaccine-induced HIV infection82 | |
Lack of access to information | 14 (31.8) | Misconceptions about research83 | Limited knowledge about clinical trials84; lack of translated materials, including key words or terms; feeling intimidated by English78 | Unavailable health information in Spanish and lack of access to Spanish-speaking staff67; low perceived risk of diseasea,85,86 | Information about accessing research87; language barrier between hospital staff, researchers, and patients40 |
Stigma | 12 (27.3) | Related to genetic or mental illness research88 | Related to judgment from husband or family for participation in health study79 | Related to HIV-positive status89 | |
Health insurance coverage | 3 (6.8) | Have basic health care or no specific health care needs90; fear of discrimination88 | Lack of information about insurance coverage for clinical trials77 | ||
Legal status in United States | 2 (4.5) | Concerned immigration status will be affected among immigrants79 | Fear of deportation among immigrants67 |
Low perceived risk of disease is a shared barrier for African Americans and Latinos.