Skip to main content
. 2014 Feb 26;9(2):e89739. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0089739

Table 12. Cladistic interpretation of shared characters of Ocepeia with ungulates and paenungulates (ordered analysis, Fig. 21).

Characters Description Convergence with Remarks
28–1 (RI = 88) Lower molars with lingual cusps larger than labial cusps Protungulatum, Paenungulata
34–1 (RI = 88) Hypolophid present (Perissodactyla, Teilhardimys, Paenungulata)
63–1 (RI = 50) Anterior coronoid (retromolar) fossa present Some Paenungulata: Hyracoidea, Proboscidea, Embrithopoda Not Sirenia, Desmostylia, Minchenella, Phenacolophus, Anthracobunia
98–1 (RI = 16) Mesostyle present Phenacodonta, some Paenungulata: Hyracoidea, Proboscidea, Desmostylia, Embrithopoda Not Sirenia and advanced Proboscidea (reversals)
101–1 and 101–2 (RI = 33) Centrocrista dilambdodont and linked to the mesostyle Phenacodonta, Paenungulata Not Minchenella; centrocrista secondarily lost in Sirenia, Desmostylia; convergence with Hyracoidea and Embrithopoda at state 2; convergence with Phenacodonta and Paenungulata at state 1
161–1 (RI = 83) Periotic amastoidy Paenungulata
126–1 (RI = 71) Nasal cavity wide and high Orycteropus, Tethytheria Not Hyracoidea (primitive state?)
145–1 (RI = 60) Zygomatic arch high dorso-ventrally with ventral process at maxillary suture Tethytheria Not Hyracoidea and Desmostylia (primitive state?)
136–1(RI = 50) Orbit bordered ventrally partly by a short process of the maxillary which extends between the lacrimal and jugal Some Paenungulata: Hyracoidea, Proboscidea, Embrithopoda Not Sirenia, Desmostylia, Anthracobunia
7–1 (RI = 50) I3 vestigial Proboscidea (Eritherium) I3 becoming lost in proboscideans
67–1 (RI = 0) I2 enlarged Proboscidea
162–1 (RI = 50) Pars mastoidea larger than pars cochlearis Proboscidea
25–1 (RI = 92), 88–1 (RI = 50) M1–3 bunodont with low trigonid “Ungulate” plesiomorphy?
62–1 (RI = 40) Angular process broad and rounded posteriorly projecting “Ungulate” plesiomorphy?
111–1 (RI = 33) M1<M2 “Ungulate” plesiomorphy?

RI: Retention Index.