Skip to main content
. 2013 Dec 9;2(1):13–19. doi: 10.15171/ijhpm.2014.04

Table 1. Summary of included studies .

Study/Author(s) Study design Year of study Settings Summary
Health Reform Foundation in Nigeria, 2007 Health review 1996–2007 Nigeria THE remained <5% by 2005
Appropriation Bill, 2013 Policy briefs 2012–2013 Nigeria Marginal increase in appropriation to health at 5.6%
World Bank, 2000 World Bank reports 1990–1998 Nigeria Expenditure on Health as a percentage (%) of GDP; at <1%
Nigeria Health Expenditure, 2013 Panel discussion reports 1995–2010 Nigeria PvtHE remained at 62% of THE
Novignon et al. 2012 Panel data analysis 1995–2010 Sub-Saharan Africa Increased health indices following increased private and public health system financing
SURE-P, 2013 Panel discussion on government funding 2013 Nigeria Increased primary and secondary facility care
World Bank, 2013 Review of GDP growth rates 2004–2012 Nigeria Increased economic prospects with a GDP rate of 6.6%
Central Bank of Nigeria, 2005 Annual reports and statement of accounts 2001–2003 Nigeria Accelerated growth in government funding of health system
Uzochukwu BSC, 2012 Panel discussions: a review of the Nigerian situation 2012 Nigeria Policy reforms to strengthen the private involvement
La Forgia and Harding, 2009 A review of PPPs in São Paulo, Brazil 2009 Brazil Efficiency in health system performance
Vicente and Castillejo, 2012 A review of the Brazilian experience in modernizing hospitals 2011–2012 Brazil Efficiency in health system performance
Purohit BC, 2005 Cross-sectional study 2005 India Efficiency in health system performance
La Forgia et al. 2005 Case study 2005 Guatemala Efficiency in primary health system performance
Rao et al. 2011 Supplement article 2009–2010 Ethiopia Decreased incidence of HIV and other related diseases
Meessen et al. 2011 Review article on PBF 2005–2008 Rwanda Efficiency in health system performance
Obansa SA, 2013 Review paper of health financing 1998–2007 Nigeria Proposes health financing reforms
Adinma and Adinnma, 2010 Review paper - Nigeria Strengthening CBHF
Carrin et al. 2005 Data review 1997–2001 Developing countries Strengthening CBHF
McIntyre et al. 2010 Systematic review - Developing countries Strengthening CBHF
ILO/STEP Policy briefs - Developing countries Strengthening micro insurance schemes through research

SURE-P= Subsidy Reinvestment and Empowerment program, CBHF= Community-Based Health Financing, PBF= Performance-Based Financing, ILO/STEP= International Labour Organization/Skills Training and Employment Placement