Table 1. Characteristic of the included studies.
Study | Years | Country | Study type | Study design | Case number | Controls number | Neonate | Birth weight | Imaging confirm | Risk of bias |
Benders 2007 [20] | 1990–2005 | US | retrospective | case-control | 31 | 93 | preterm | Cases:1599±633 Controls:1607±720 | MRI | different detecting method, only preterm neonates |
Chabrier 2010 [21] | 2003–2006 | France | prospective | cohort study | 100 | 100 | both | NR | CT/MRI | different detecting method, no description of those lost to follow up |
Darmency-Stamboul 2012 [22] | 2000–2007 | France | retrospective | case-control | 32 | 96 | term | NR | CT/MRI | different detecting method, only term neonates |
Estan 1997 [8] | 1987–1993 | UK | retrospective | case-control | 12 | 24 | term | Cases:3496(2541–4460) Controls:3673 (2748–4707) | CT | different detecting method, only term neonates |
Harteman 2012 [14] | 2000–2010 | Utrecht | retrospective | case-control | 52 | 156 | term | Cases:3420(2145–5230) Controls:3520(2155–4925) | MRI | different detecting method, only term neonates |
Lee 2005 [6] | 1997–2002 | US | retrospective | nested case-control | 37 | 111 | both | Cases:3127±852 Controls:3203±923 | CT/MRI | different detecting method |
Wu 2004 [9] | 1991–1998 | US | retrospective | nested case-control | 38 | 218 | term | NR | CT/MRI | different detecting method, only term neonates |
Kirton 2011 [23] | 2003–2007 | IPSS | prospective | case-control | 248 | population | both | NR | CT/MRI | different detecting method |
NR: not reported. IPSS: Europe, Canada, US, South America, Asia, Australia; NR: not reported.