Table 1. Studies using categorical measures of disturbances in reality testing (DRT) in offspring of parents with bipolar disorder (O-BD).
Study | Measure | N | Age | Comparison group(s) | Type of study | Summary of findings | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Akdemir and Gökler 2008 (88) | K-SADS-PL | 69 | 6–17 years | O-BD (n = 36) O-Well (n = 33) |
Cross-sectional | 2.8% (1/36) of O-BD had a psychotic disorder compared to 0% of O-Well, but this difference was not statistically significant | |
Akiskalet al. 1985(92) | Washington University/Feighner Criteria similar to DSM-III | 136 | 6–24 years | O-BD (n = 68) O-Well (n = 68) |
Cross-sectional | 16.2% (11/68) of O-BD patients showed ‘bizarre behavior of psychotic proportions’ (including psychotic mania and psychotic depression) and 11.8% (8/68) presented with acute versus intermittent affective onset with psychosis compared to 0% of O-Well | |
Did not report tests of significant differences | |||||||
Cullenet al. 2011 (71)a | SCID-II | 167 | 4, 7, 11, 15, and 22 years of age at Times 1–5 | O-BD (n = 42) O-MDD (n = 73) O-Well (n = 52) |
Longitudinal | There were no significant differences between offspring risk groups for cluster A personality disorders | |
Duffy et al. 2007 (65) | K-SADS-PL | 188 | 8–25 years | O-BD of LR parents (n = 67) O-BD of LNR parents (n = 60) O-Well (n = 61) |
Prospective over 0–9 years | 8.3% (5/60) of O-BD-LNR parents had significantly more pre-psychotic conditions such as cluster A trait disorders compared to 1.5% (1/67) of O-BD-LR and 0% of O-Well; and 1.7% (1/60) of O-BD-LNR had schizoaffective disorder or psychosis-NOS compared to 0% of O-BD-LR and 0% of O-Well (not significant) | |
Erlenmeyer-Kimling et al. 1995(86) | SADS-L RDC | 188 | ≥18 years | O-affective (O-Aff; n = 41 O-BD or O-MDD O-SZ (n = 54) O-Well (n = 93) |
Cross-sectional | 11.1% (2/18) of O-BD developed psychosis, and in both cases, the parents had BD with psychosis |
|
Did not report psychosis in comparison groups | |||||||
No significant group differences between O-Aff and O-Well on cluster A personality disorders | |||||||
Erlenmeyer-Kimling et al. 1997(89) | SADS-L RDC | 287 | ≥18 years | O-Aff (n = 67; did not specify BD versus MDD) O-SZ (n = 84) O-Well (n = 136) |
Cross-sectional | 9.0% (9/67) of O-Aff had schizoaffective disorder, SZ type compared to 1.2% (1/84) of O-SZ and 0% of O-Well; this was only significantly different compared to O-Well, but they reported that O-Aff unipolar versus BD distinction did not significantly affect these results | |
Grigoroui-Serbănescu et al. 1989(87) | K-SADS-E | 144 | 10–17 years | O-BD (n = 72) O-Well (n = 72) |
Cross-sectional | 12.5% (9/72) of O-BD had four different personality disorders, one of which was cluster A schizotypal personality disorder, compared to 2.8% (2/72) of O-Well; this difference was reported to be significant | |
Kashaniet al. 1985(60) | DICA DICA-P | 50 | 7–17 years | O-BD (n = 9) O-MDD (n = 41) |
Cross-sectional | 0% of O-BD had schizoid personality disorder compared to 7.3% (3/41) of O-MDD | |
Did not report tests of significant differences | |||||||
Klimes-Dougan et al., in press (17)a | CBCL | 192 | 4, 7, 11, 15, and 22 years of age at Times 1–5 | O-BD (n = 48) O-MDD (n = 84) O-Well (n = 60) |
Longitudinal | 14.6% (7/48) of O-BD had significantly more clinical levels (T ≥ 70) of thought problems at two or more time points, compared to 7.1% (6/84) of O-MDD and 0% of O-Well | |
Maziade et al. 2008(61) | K-SADS SCID | 54 | 7–22 years | O-BD (n = 26) O-SZ (n = 28) |
Cross-sectional | 0% of O-BD had diagnoses of psychotic disorders (e.g., SZ) or cluster A personality disorders | |
Did not report tests of significant differences | |||||||
Nurnberger et al. 2012(85)a | DIGS WASH-U-KSADS | 232 | 12–21 years | O-BD (n = 141) O-Well (n = 91) |
Cross-sectional | 3.5% (5/141) of O-BD had a psychosis-type disorder (schizoaffective disorder) and 5.7% (8/141) of O-BD had any psychotic symptom, compared to 0% of O-Well, but these differences were not significant | |
Schubert and McNeil 2003(91) | SCID | 166 | 22 years | O-BD (n = 16) O-Other high risk (n = 59) O-Well(n = 91) |
Cross-sectional | 0% of O-BD had psychosis and 6.3% (1/16) offspring had a cluster A disorder (did not distinguish whether this was an O-BD or an O-MDD) | |
Did not report tests of significance differences | |||||||
Weintraub 1987(90) | SADS SCID | 544 | ‘School-age’ | O-BD(n = 134) O-SZ (n = 80) O-MDD(n = 154) O-Well(n = 176) |
Prospective over 3 years | 1.5% (2/134) of O-BD had SZ when followed up at age 18 compared to 2/5% (2/80) of O-SZ, 10% (1/80) of O-MDD, and 0% of O-Well | |
Did not report tests of significant differences |
CBCL = Child Behavior Checklist; DICA = Diagnostic Interview for Children and Adolescents (P = Parent version); DIGS = Diagnostic Interview for Genetic Studies; K-SADS = The Kiddie Schedule for Affective Disorders and Schizophrenia (PL = Present and Lifetime version; WASH-U = Washington University version; E = Epidemiological version); NOS = not otherwise specified; O-Aff = offspring of a parent with an affective disorder (MDD or BD); O-BD-LNR = offspring of a parent with a nonpositive response to lithium; O-BD-LR = offspring of a parent with BD with a positive response to lithium; O-BD = offspring of a parent with bipolar disorder (BD); O-MDD = offspring of a parent with major depressive disorder (MDD); O-Other = offspring of a parent with a psychiatric disorder other than bipolar disorder; O-SZ = offspring of a parent with schizophrenia; O-Well = offspring of psychiatrically well parents; RDC = Research Diagnostic Criteria; SADS = Schedule for Affective Disorders and Schizophrenia (L = Lifetime version); SCID = Structured Clinical Interview for the DSM-IV.
Also reviewed in Table 2.