Table 2.
Design Methods |
I |
II |
III |
IV |
||||||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
FAM 2 | CC 3 | UN 4 | UI 5 | FAM | CC | UN | UI | FAM | CC | UN | UI | FAM | CC | UN | UI | |
RR=1.5 | ||||||||||||||||
Checkerboard | .005 | .003 | .005 | .017 | .008 | .003 | .007 | .026 | .006 | .012 | .023 | .047 | .012 | .003 | .009 | .037 |
Diagonal | .002 | .003 | .006 | .013 | .004 | .001 | .003 | .013 | .003 | .008 | .012 | .027 | .004 | .001 | .005 | .016 |
Upper corner |
.000 | .001 | .004 | .008 | .001 | .001 | .003 | .008 | .001 | .006 | .009 | .015 | .003 | .002 | .005 | .016 |
RR=2.0 | ||||||||||||||||
Checkerboard | .036 | .023 | .119 | .324 | .079 | .025 | .122 | .405 | .080 | .249 | .457 | .719 | .221 | .028 | .217 | .693 |
Diagonal | .019 | .024 | .092 | .210 | .034 | .019 | .074 | .261 | .037 | .161 | .286 | .477 | .127 | .026 | .145 | .486 |
Upper corner |
.006 | .016 | .065 | .120 | .016 | .015 | .052 | .152 | .022 | .133 | .248 | .376 | .049 | .013 | .083 | .274 |
RR=2.5 | ||||||||||||||||
Checkerboard1 | .203 | .174 | .613 | .899 | .389 | .182 | .602 | .949 | .410 | .826 | .956 | .994 | .787 | .183 | .783 | .994 |
Diagonal | .082 | .121 | .431 | .702 | .227 | .124 | .404 | .736 | .268 | .724 | .899 | .974 | .505 | .119 | .569 | .816 |
Upper corner |
.043 | .101 | .357 | .553 | .084 | .091 | .259 | .500 | .125 | .528 | .693 | .797 | .315 | .093 | .453 | .779 |
RR=3.0 | ||||||||||||||||
Checkerboard | .460 | .489 | .932 | .995 | .764 | .484 | .933 | .999 | .790 | .986 | 1.00 | 1.00 | .973 | .491 | .987 | 1.00 |
Diagonal | .256 | .375 | .837 | .970 | .653 | .398 | .862 | .991 | .573 | .917 | .960 | .980 | .739 | .308 | .820 | .962 |
Upper corner | .140 | .323 | .742 | .863 | .360 | .275 | .655 | .849 | .312 | .672 | .739 | .801 | .624 | .262 | .770 | .909 |
Mean power | .104 | .138 | .350 | .473 | .218 | .135 | .331 | .491 | .219 | .435 | .524 | .601 | .363 | .127 | .404 | .582 |
Notes:
Power = the proportion of true models significant at the given significance level in all simulations. Each power in this table is the mean of 25 scenarios, each of which was sampled on allele frequency between 0.05~0.95 and then replicated 500 times.
FAM for family-based method
CC for case-control method
UN for unrelated individuals (unbalanced case-control)
UI for unified method