Table 2.
Above and Below Average Coalitions by Presence of Context Themes.
Themes | Coalition Classifications by Objective Achievement Status
|
|||
---|---|---|---|---|
Above-Average Overall Achievement
|
Below-Average Overall Achievement
|
|||
Above-Average Structural Achievement (n = 3) | Below-Average Structural Achievement (n = 4) | Above-Average Structural Achievement (n = 3) | Below-Average Structural Achievement (n = 2) | |
Demographics and economics | ||||
To incentivize membership and address gaps due to funding losses, coalitions created to address members’ organizational needs | X | X | X | |
History | ||||
Members exhibited preference for preventive approaches that they believed worked in the past | X | X | ||
A history of work within the HIV/AIDS prevention and service field was a barrier to the development of structurally focused objectives | X | X | X | |
Collaboration | ||||
Staff incited members to work toward easily attainable SCOs where there was a history of mistrust among member or skepticism of coalitions | X | |||
Coalitions partnered with local coalitions to address other social issues related to HIV/AIDS | X | X | X | |
Norms/beliefs | ||||
Low awareness of prevention needs among heterosexual youth dictated focus on informational SCOs | X | |||
Religious norms dictated a focus on faith-based communities | X | X | ||
Coalition members and staff valued using evidence-based approaches and wanted to be a model C2P coalition | X | |||
Coalitions sought to align SCOs with other local prevention priorities | X | X | ||
Politics | ||||
Conservative local political agenda dissuaded policy-focused SCOs | X | X | ||
HIV/AIDs and/or LGBT political support in local government dictated policy-focused SCOs | X | X | ||
Coalitions made policies relevant to other groups relevant to target population, ensured policy implementation, or addressed unintended consequences of policies | X | X |
Note. Themes were evident in all sites for the categories under which an “X” appears. SCO = structural change objective; C2P = Connect to Protect project; LGBT = lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender.