Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2015 Jan 30.
Published in final edited form as: Psychiatry Res. 2013 Oct 22;221(1):6–12. doi: 10.1016/j.pscychresns.2013.10.002

Table 4.

Summary of brain volume meta-analyses in schizophrenia involving progression of illness or medication exposure

Study goal Author (year)a Sample sizeb Patient status Contrast Finding
Illness progression Woods (2005) 982 FES and Chronic HC vs. SZ WB volume reduced
Steen (2006) 1424 FES HC vs. FES WB volume reduced and ventricular volume is increased
Ellison-Wright (2008) 1556 FES and Chronic HC vs. SZ Bilateral reductions in caudate GM present in FES but not chronic SZ
Glahn (2008) 1195 FES and Chronic HC vs. SZ Increased GM density in striatal regions
Fornito (2009) 1646 FES and Chronic HC vs. SZ Reduced GM volume and concentration in frontal, temporal, thalamic and striatal regions
Bora (2011) 1999 Chronic and FES HC vs. SZ Chronic illness associated with more severe GM abnormalities
Chan (2011) 466 FES HC vs. FES Lower GM volume
808 Chronic Chronic vs. FES More extensive GM volume reductions than FES group
Olabi (2011) 928 Chronic and FES HC vs. SZ SZ show significantly greater reductions in WB volume and WB GM volume over time
De Peri (2012) 45 studies FES FES vs. HC Significant overall reduction in WB total GM
Haijma (2012) 8327 Chronic and FES HC vs. SZ Larger GM reductions were associated with longer duration of illness
Vita (2012) 813 Chronic and FES HC vs. SZ FES have more significant pattern of progressive loss of WB GM volume than Chronic SZ. GM volume modulated by percentage of patients taking atypical APDs
Medication exposure Navari (2009) 33 Studies NN and NT NT vs. HC or NN Antipsychotics, specifically typical, cause increased volume of structures within the basal ganglia in the NT group
8327 Medicated HC vs. medicated Total brain volume of grey matter structures were significantly decreased
Leung (2011) 162 NN-FES HC vs. NN-FES SZ showed GM deficits in subcortical regions including the striatum
336 NT-FES NN-FES vs. NT-FES NT SZ showed GM deficits in caudate, cingulate, and inferior TL
Haijma (2013) 771 NN NN vs. HC and NT NN had more pronounced volume reductions in the caudate nucleus and thalamus than HC or NT
Ebdrup (2013) 13 studies Medicated Baseline vs. after medication No studies found that specific FGAs induce basal ganglia volume increases. SGA therapy associated with volumetric increases and decreases in basal ganglia.

Abbreviations: APD, antipsychotic; FES, first episode schizophrenia; FGA, first generation antipsychotic; GM, grey matter; HC, healthy controls; NN, neuroleptic naïve; NT, neuroleptic treated; SGA, second generation antipsychotic; STG, superior temporal gyrus; SZ, schizophrenia; TL, temporal lobe; WB, whole brain;

a

Articles are listed in the references section

b

Some of the articles only reported their total number of studies and not sample size.