Table 1.
Model | Type of injury | Strengths | Weaknesses | Species |
---|---|---|---|---|
CCI | Mainly focal | Highly reproducible | Need for craniotomy | Ferret50, mouse56, rat49, swine57, monkey58 |
Weight drop | ||||
Feeney | Mainly focal | Injury mechanism close to human TBI | Need for craniotomy; high mortality rate | Rat59 |
Shohami | Mainly focal | Easy operation, with immediate neurological severity scoring at 1h | Not highly reproducible | Rat60, mouse29 |
Marmarou | Mainly diffuse | Injury mechanism close to human TBI; well characterized | Not highly reproducible, high mortality without ventilation | Rat51, mouse61 |
Maryland model | Mainly diffuse | Injury mechanism close to human TBI | Needs further characterization | Rat62 |
FPI | ||||
Middle | Mixed | Highly reproducible with fine-tuning | Need for craniotomy, high mortality | Cat63, rabbit64, rat65, dog and sheep66, swine67 |
Lateral | Mixed | Highly reproducible with fine-tuning | Need for caniotomy, high mortality | Rat68, mouse69, swine70 |
Blast | Mainly diffuse | Injury mechanism close to military TBI | Need standardization | Rat52, mouse71, swine72 |
Repeated mild | Mainly diffuse | Injury mechanism close to sports TBI | Need further characterization | Rat73, mouse74, swine43 |
PBBI | Mainly focal | Injury mechanism close to human TBI | Need standardization | Cat75, rat76 |
CCI, controlled cortical impact; FPI, fluid percussion injury; PBBI, penetrating ballistic-like brain injury; TBI, traumatic brain injury. The Table is modified, with permission, from REF77. [77] © 2010 BioMed Central.