Table 2.
Description of Stargardt's Disease | Criteria for diagnosis | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Stargardt1 1909 | 1- A disease of probable autosomal recessive inheritance with age of onset in the 1st or 2nd decade. 2- Initial loss of vision before definite retinal changes are seen. 3- The eventual appearance of both an atrophic macular degeneration and prominent yellowish flecks in the macular and often posterior polar areas as well. The area of degeneration becomes larger with time and prominent flecks disappear. 4- Essentially normal peripheral visual fields and night vision throughout the patient's life. 5- A rather mild loss of color vision even with fairly severe visual loss. | ||||
| |||||
Stargardt17 1913 |
Conditions designated as Stargardt's disease
|
||||
Vitelliruptive macular degeneration | X-chromosome-linked juvenile retinoschisis | Cone degenerations | Fundus flavimaculatus | Age of onset (1st and 22nd decade) Absence of peripheral retinal changes | |
| |||||
Franceschetti3 1962 | The same clinical picture reported by Stargardt (1909) is designated as Fundus flavimaculatus | Electroretinography dark adaptation | |||
| |||||
Krill and Deutman9 1972 |
Stargardt's disease as a part of Fundus flavimaculatus
|
Eyeground changes Complete retinal function | |||
Group I | Group II | Group III | |||
Pure form without atrophy, central visual loss due to invasion of the fovea with one of the typical flecks | Atrophy, macular degeneration followed by flecks (frequent) or flecks preceding macular degeneration (rare). No loss of peripheral retinal function | (rare) Progressive deterioration of peripheral retinal function (4th-5th decade), Macular atrophy | |||
Subgroup A (frequent) No diffuse cone abnormality (clinical picture reported by Stargardt 1909) | Subgroup B (rare) Diffuse severe cone disease on the ERG such as described in cone degenerations | ||||
| |||||
Fishman7 1976 | Stage I | Stage II | Stage III | Stage IV | The extent of fundus fleck-like lesions and their degree of resorption The extent of choroidal atrophy |
Central RPE and possibly choriocapillaris disease, often associated with a discrete ring of perimacular flecks | Macular atrophy with flecks often extending to the equator. Atrophy of choriocapallaris and RPE within the macula. | Extensive fleck resorption within the posterior pole and marked RPE atrophy. | Diffusely resorbed flecks, extensive choriocapillaris atrophy | ||
| |||||
Gass18 1987 | Group I | Group II | Group III | Group IV | Macula appearance |
Vermillion fundi and hidden choroidal fluorescence | Atrophic maculopathy with or without flecks | Atrophic maculopathy with late signs and symptoms of retinitis pigmentosa | Flecks not associated with macular atrophy | ||
| |||||
Noble and Carr13 1979 | Group I | Group II | Group III | Group IV | Macula appearance |
Macular degeneration without flecks | Macular degeneration with flecks | Macular degeneration with diffuse flecks | Diffuse flecks without macular degeneration | ||
| |||||
Aaberg14 1986 | Stage I | Stage II | Stage III | Stage IV | The degree of damage to the retina |
Purely central macular degeneration with or without perifoveal flecks | Central macular degeneration and pericentral flecks extending outside the posterior fundus | Centroperipheral retinal pigmentary degeneration with an intact peripheral visual field but pigment migration, depigmentation and normal retinal vessel size | Centroperipheral retinal pigmentary degeneration with peripheral visual field defects and "bone trabeculae" pigmentation with attenuated retinal vessels | ||
| |||||
Lois et al8 2001 | Group I | Group II | Group III | Electrophysiological attributes | |
Normal rod and cone-mediated ERGs | Relative loss of generalized cone function | Both abnormal rod and cone ERGs |
The term “group” does not allow the progression of a patient from one category to another while the term ”stage” is defined as a period or distinct phase in the course of a disease or any biologic process.