Skip to main content
. 2014 Mar;21(3):417–426. doi: 10.1128/CVI.00818-13

TABLE 3.

Humoral and cellular immunity against common pathogensa

Pathogen Cellular antigen Group No. of individuals with positive responses/total no. of individuals for:
P for IgG vs CMI CMI
P for:
No. of individuals with responsive cells/total no. of individuals for:
P for CD4+ vs CD8+
IgG CMI CO vs HE-SPR CO vs HE-SUM HE-SPR vs HE-SUM CD4+ cells CD8+ cells
AdV-5 AdV-5 penton CO 9/10 9/11 NSb NS NS 6/11 6/10 NS
HE-SPR 11/11 11/11 7/11 9/11 NS
HE-SUM 11/11 10/10 9/10 6/10 NS
CMV CMV pp65 CO 4/11 10/11 0.024 NS NS NS 8/10 6/10 NS
HE-SPR 9/11 11/11 NS 10/11 9/11 NS
HE-SUM 9/11 10/10 NS 9/10 9/10 NS
Tetanus TT CO 10/11 6/11 NS 0.036 0.036 NS 6/11 3/11 NS
HE-SPR 11/11 11/11 NS 8/11 5/11 NS
HE-SUM 11/11 10/10 NS 10/10 5/10 0.033
VZV VZV gE CO 11/11 8/11 NS NS NS NS 6/11 3/10 NS
HE-SPR 11/11 9/11 NS 9/11 3/11 0.016
HE-SUM 11/11 9/10 NS 9/10 4/10 0.058
VZV VZV IE62 CO 11/11 11/11 NS NS NS NS 10/11 7/11 NS
HE-SPR 11/11 11/11 NS 9/11 9/11 NS
HE-SUM 11/11 10/10 NS 10/10 9/10 NS
VZV VZV IE63 CO 11/11 6/11 0.036 0.036 NS NS 5/11 5/11 NS
HE-SPR 11/11 11/11 NS 8/11 9/11 NS
HE-SUM 11/11 9/10 NS 8/10 6/10 NS
a

Shown is memory against pathogens using either humoral (IgG) or cell-mediated immunity (CMI) (IFN-γ- or/and IL-2-producing T cells) as proxy. Fisher's exact test was used to compare immunity as assessed by IgG or CMI (against an antigen) for three sampling groups (P values of <0.10 are shown). CMI is compared among the three groups (P values of <0.10 are shown). For each antigen, the presence of CD4+ and CD8+ IFN-γ or/and IL-2 responses are assessed and compared with each other per antigen and per group (P values of <0.10 are shown).

b

NS, nonsignificant.