Table 1.
First author |
Location (city, country) |
Study design | Study population |
Sample size |
Quality assessment |
Control/ comparison group |
Intervention group |
Setting of location of test uptake (clinical or nonclinical) |
STI tested | Function of uptake |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Chacko [22] | Baltimore, USA | Quasi-experimental interventiona | Teenagers treated at a STI clinic | 519 | 7 | Request for a test of cure | CG + incentive of entrance into $50 lottery | Clinical | Gonorrhea | Post-infection test of cure |
Currie [27]b | Australia Capital Territory, Australia | Quasi-experimental intervention | Sexually active university students | 3652 | 8 | Screening offered at campus activities | $10 incentive for on-campus screening and result retrieval via text message | Non-clinical, on-campus screening | Chlamydia | Screening test |
Geringer [23] | Philadelphia, USA | Quasi-experimental intervention | General population | 708 | 7 | Testing and result retrieval at homeless shelters and STI centers | CG + $5 incentive for test result retrieval | Clinical and nonclinical Non-clinical, homeless shelters/ soup kitchens | Syphilis | Screening test |
Haukoos [25] | Los Angeles, USA | Quasi-experimental intervention | ED patients with a high risk of HIV | 372 | 7 | Referral for VCT 1 week after ED visit | CG + $25 incentive for fulfillment of VCT referral | Clinical | HIV | Screening test |
Malotte [24] | Prince George’s County and Los Angeles, USA | Randomized controlled trial | Patients treated at a STI clinic | 423 | 8 | Request for 3 month retesting | CG + $25 incentive for retesting | Clinical | Gonorrhea, chlamydia | Post-infection repeat test |
Nglazi [28] | Cape Town, South Africa | Quasi-experimental intervention | Men in community | 8708 | 7 | Use of a mobile VCT service | CG + appointment and $10.30 food voucher | Non-clinical, mobile VCT service | HIV | Screening test |
Thornton [26] | Malawi | Randomized controlled trial | Individuals previously tested for STI | 2812 | 7 | Request for result retrieval at temporary centers | CG + $1.01 incentive for result retrievalc | Non-clinical, temporary VCT centers within neighbors | HIV | Screening test |
CG Control group, VCT voluntary counseling and testing
Quasi-experimental study designs intend to estimate the causal impact of an intervention, but without random assignment
Study contained a third non-comparable study group
Inventive levels were varied at random between 0 and 3 USD