Skip to main content
. 2014 Mar 27;9(3):e92754. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0092754

Table 3. Additional yield with regards to TB diagnosis and rifampicin resistance detection of Xpert compared to fluorescence smear microscopy.

Risk group Xpert tests done Additional TB diagnostic yield Additional diagnosis of Rif-R
N % increase NNT N NNT
Presumptive or confirmed HIV (smear/Xpert in parallel) n = 319
smear(+) 27 - - - 2 14
smear(−) 292 11 41% (38/27) 27 0 -
Presumptive MDR-TB (smear/Xpert in parallel) n = 1.507
smear(+) 94 - - - 6 16
smear(−) 1.414 45 48% (139/94) 32 0 -
Smear(-) with persisting symptoms (Xpert as add-on) n = 125/7.933 smear(-)
smear(+) 542 - - - - -
smear(−) 7.933 - - - - -
2nd round smear(−) 125 5 1% (547/542) 26 0 -

Smear(+): smear-positive; smear(−): smear-negative; HIV: human immuno-deficiency virus; NNT =  number needed to test; Rif-R: rifampicin resistance; MDR-TB:multidrug-resistant tuberculosis.