Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2014 Aug 1.
Published in final edited form as: J Phys Act Health. 2012 Oct 10;10(6):833–849. doi: 10.1123/jpah.10.6.833

Table 1.

Round 1 (Open Format) Cognitive Discrepancies in Recall of Physical Activities

Child ID,
grade,
sex, and
protocol* 		Physical Education (PE) Recess Distance PE
scheduled
in TP† 		Recess
scheduled
in TP
Discrepancy between Phases 1 and 2? Discrepancy between Phase 3 and the previous two phases? Discrepancy between Phases 1 and 2? Discrepancy between Phase 3 and the previous two phases?
#1
5th-grade girl; PDM protocol		 Yes No -----------Did not report recess------------ “Long time” to the gym Yes Yes
#2
3rd-grade boy; SDA protocol		 Yes No Yes No No transition activity reported Yes Yes
#3
3rd-grade girl; PDM protocol		 Yes No Yes No “Like far from our class and one half hallway to the PE room” Yes Yes
#4
5th-grade girl; SDA protocol		 Yes No -----------Did not report recess--------- “Like a mile” to PE Yes No
#5
5th-grade boy; PDM protocol		 ----------Did not report PE---------- -----------Did not report recess-------- When asked about distance to class where activity occurred, child included time that teacher used to discipline class No Yes
#6
3rd-grade girl; SDA protocol		 Yes No Yes Yes “Not very far to the playground” Yes Yes
#7
3rd-grade boy; PDM protocol		 Yes No Yes No “I don’t remember” how far it was to PE Yes Yes
#8
5th-grade boy; SDA protocol		 No No No Yes “Not that long” to PE Yes No
#9
3rd-grade boy; PDM protocol		 No No -----------Did not report recess--------- “…about a mile” to PE Yes Yes
#10
5th-grade girl; PDM protocol		 ------------Did not report PE--------- -----------Did not report recess--------- No transition activity reported No Yes
#11
5th-grade boy; SDA protocol		 No Yes -----------Did not report recess--------- “At least 3 hallways away” to PE Yes No
#12
3rd-grade girl; SDA protocol		 Yes No Yes No “Three to two minutes to PE” No Yes
*

The PDM protocol is for recalls about the previous day obtained during a morning interview. The SDA protocol is for recalls about the same day obtained during an afternoon interview.

†

The TP is the target period covered in the recall. For example, the PDM protocol targets the previous day, while the SDA protocol targets that same day.