Table 2.
Round 2 Cognitive Discrepancies in Recall of Physical Activities when Using Chronological Protocol
| Child ID, grade, sex, and protocol* |
Discrepancy between Phases 1 and 2? |
Was physical education (PE) reported? |
Was recess reported? |
Duration of Activity | PE scheduled in TP† |
Recess scheduled in TP |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
#1 5th-grade girl, PDM protocol |
No | No | No | “ Five minutes” | No | Yes |
|
#2 3rd-grade girl; SDA protocol |
No | Yes | No | “Three to four minutes” For Peer Review | Yes | Yes |
|
#3 3rd-grade boy; PDM protocol |
No | Yes | No | “Four to ten minutes” | Yes | Yes |
|
#4 5th-grade boy; SDA protocol |
No | Yes | No | “Three minutes a session for 21 minutes total” | Yes | No |
|
#5 5th-grade girl; PDM protocol |
No | Yes | No | “About 30 minutes” | Yes | Yes |
|
#6 3rd-grade boy; SDA protocol |
No | Yes | Yes | “Probably about 5 minutes” | Yes | Yes |
|
#7 3rd-grade girl; PDM protocol |
No | Yes | Yes | “It was, I only did one round so it took 1 minute” | Yes | Yes |
|
#8 5th-grade boy; SDA protocol |
Yes | Yes | No | “Actually I did it for a minute and some, some change.” | Yes | No |
|
#9 5th-grade boy; PDM protocol |
No | No | No | “3 minutes” | No | Yes |
|
#10 3rd-grade girl; PDM protocol |
No | No | Yes | “20 minutes” | No | Yes |
|
#11 3rd-grade boy; SDA protocol |
No | No | Yes | “Less than 2 seconds.” | No | Yes |
|
#12 5th-grade girl; SDA protocol |
No | Yes | No | “40 minutes” | Yes | No |
The PDM protocol is for recalls about the previous day obtained during a morning interview. The SDA protocol is for recalls about the same day obtained during an afternoon interview.
The TP is the target period covered in the recall. For example, the PDM protocol targets the previous day, while the SDA protocol targets that same day.