Table 1. A Summary of Studies Approaching DBS Lead Location and Outcome.
Author | n | Target | Objective | Findings |
Walter U, et. al 2011 | 34 | GPi, STN, Vim | To determine if transcranial B-mode sonography (TCS) is a more reliable method than MRI for locating postoperative DBS leads | TCS was not as sensitive in the antero-posterior direction and may not be as accurate as MRI or CT or MR-CT fusion [40]. |
Schlaier JR, et. al 2012 | 22 | STN | To determine if the use of MER in addition to anatomical targeting would improve clinical outcomes | Intra-operative testing leads physicians to a more favorable final stimulation site than anatomic targeting alone [41]. |
Lalys F, et.al 2012 | 30 | STN | To identify optimum sites for STN DBS by studying symptomatic motor improvement along with neuropsychological side effects | Suggested a more complete DBS modeling system including lead location, stimulation parameters, and clinical ratings |
Reported good motor improvement from leads located in the STN postero-superior region [42] | ||||
Paek SH, et. al 2008 | 53 | STN | To correlate surgical outcome with STN lead position | Reported improvements in all parkinsonian symptoms in all regions of the STN [43] |
Connolly PJ, et. al 2012 | 50 | STN | To identify the active contacts and their postoperative location within the STN | Contacts 1 or 2 located in the dorsolateral STN region were active in 90% of patients who underwent DBS one-year prior. |
Stimulating at contact 1 or 2 can decrease initial programming time in the clinic [44] | ||||
Thani NB, et. al 2011 | 8 | STN, GPi | To compare measuring lead locations on post-op CT images co-registered to intraoperative MRI versus using an MRI-directed guide tube technique | Concluded that the use of the guided tube technique is accurate in documenting the DBS lead location |
Co-registration of CT images to preoperative MRIs was also considered acceptable [38] | ||||
Shahlaie K, Larson PS, Starr PA 2011 | 15 | STN | To study measuring lead location on intraoperative CT (iCT) fused with pre-op MRI in comparison to postoperative MRIs | Lead tip measurements were statistically indistinguishable. iCT can reduce the need for postoperative MRI and avoid the possible complications involved with it [45]. |
York MK, et. al 2009 | 18 | STN | To correlate lead tip locations, surgery trajectories, and location of active contact with mental status | Declines in mental status score were found in lead locations in the frontal quadrant of both hemispheres. |
Declines in verbal learning were associated with leads that were superiorly located in the left hemisphere but were closer to the STN [46] | ||||
Gorgulho AA, et. al 2009 | 18 | STN | To determine the coordinates of the location most likely associated with facial contraction during macrostimulation | Mean x, y, and z coordinates associated with facial contraction were found to be in close proximity to the internal capsule [47]. |
Pilitsis JG, et. al 2008 | 27 | Vim | To assess if suboptimal lead location leads to loss of benefit from stimulation in patients with Vim DBS | No significant difference in lead location of those that experienced failure |
Variations in the final lead locations from targets could lead to eventual loss of stimulation efficacy | ||||
Patients with more laterally placed leads experienced worse outcomes [48] | ||||
McClelland S 3rd, et. al 2005 | 26 | STN | To measure variations in final lead location from target locations and how these variations impacted clinical efficacy | DBS electrodes placed within a 6 mm diameter cylinder in the predicted center of the STN were associated with similar clinical efficacy [49]. |
Hamid NA, et. al 2005 | 27 | STN | To define the roles of MRI and intraoperative electrophysiological recording in targeting optimum stimulation sites | Because of anatomical variations, fixed pre-determined coordinate targets cannot be applied to all DBS cases [50]. |
Starr PA, et. al 2006 | 23 | GPi | To identify electrode locations with optimal benefits in patients with dystonia | Mean lead tip and active electrode coordinates did not differ between the group with the best outcomes and the group with the worst outcomes. |
Electrodes with good outcome were near the intercommissural plane [51]. |
Legend: STN- subthalamic nucleus, GPi- globus pallidus internus, VIM- ventralis intermedius nucleus, MER- microelectrode location.