Skip to main content
. 2014 Apr 4;9(4):e93927. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0093927

Table 1. Summary of study conditions (E =  experimenter, L =  learner, T =  teacher).

No. Name Brief description
1 No feedback Like baseline condition (2) but L does not cry out
2 Voice feedback Baseline condition with 1 T in separate room from L, with 1 E present
3 Proximity Like baseline condition but with T in same room as L, seated behind him
4 Touch Like baseline condition but with T holding L's hand to the shock plate
5 Coronary trouble Like baseline but L mentions heart trouble at beginning of the experiment and protests about it later
6 Different actors Identical to condition 5 but with a different actors playing Learner and Experimenter
7 Group pressure to disobey Like baseline condition but with 3 Ts: two (confederates) defy the E, who urges the participant T to continue shocks
8 Learner's proviso Like baseline condition but at study outset L insists that he will only agree to take part if he can leave when he wants
9 Group pressure to obey Like condition 7 but the 2 confederate Ts pressure the participant T to obey the E's directions
10 Conflicting instructions Like baseline condition but E urges T to stop the shocks and L urges him to continue (obedience means not going to 450V)
11 Group choice Like condition 7 but Ts can determine shock level (lowest of their 3 bids): confederate Ts go first and always increase
12 Role reversal Like baseline condition but E and L swap roles (obedience means not going to 450V)
13 Non-trigger position Like condition 7 but participant T reads word pairs while one of the confederate Ts administers shocks
14 Carte blanche Like baseline condition but T decides the level of shocks on his own, without E's directions
15 Good/bad experimenter Like baseline condition but there are 2 Es who give conflicting directions: one to stop, one to continue
16 Experimenter becomes learner Like baseline condition but with 2 Es, one of whom volunteers to serve as L when original L is said to be unavailable
17 Teacher in charge Like baseline condition but with 2 Ts, one of whom (a confederate) is given authority to choose shock levels when E is called away
18 No experimenter Like baseline condition but E is called away and tells T to continue the experiment on his own, leaving E's phone number
19 Authority from afar Like condition 18 but E leaves pre-recorded instructions for T to follow
20 Women Like baseline condition but all Ts are female
21 Expert judgment Psychiatrists and laypeople read the baseline study protocol and estimate level of obedience (not a true empirical condition)
22 Peer authority Like condition 17 but confederate T suggests shock levels without being given authority to chose them and E leaves them to T's discretion
23 Bridgeport Like condition 5 but study conducted in dingy Bridgeport office rather than at Yale
24 Intimate relationships Like baseline condition but the L is a friend or relative of the T