Table 3. Methodological quality scores of CT studies with an overall quality score of ≥60%.
First author | Year | Topic | Study design | Measure | Statistics | Score | ||||||||||||
A | B | C | D | E | F | G | H | I | J | K | L | M | N | O | ||||
Ras | 1997 | sagittal position maxilla | o | o | . | . | . | o | 75% | |||||||||
Van der Meij | 2001 | bone graft quantity | o | o | . | . | o | o | 69% | |||||||||
Kawakami | 2003 | bone graft height, density | o | o | o | . | . | o | 69% | |||||||||
Van der Meij | 2003 | bone graft | o | o | . | . | o | 77% | ||||||||||
Kita | 2004 | need bone graft | o | o | . | . | o | 77% | ||||||||||
Schliephake | 2006 | maxillary arch width | o | o | . | . | o | o | o | 62% | ||||||||
Kim | 2008 | bone graft size, volume | o | o | . | . | o | 77% | ||||||||||
Suri | 2008 | midface, maxilla | o | o | o | . | . | . | o | 66% | ||||||||
Alonso | 2010 | bone graft size, volume | o | o | o | o | 73% | |||||||||||
Saijo | 2010 | ossification pal suture | o | o | . | . | o | . | . | . | 70% | |||||||
Lee | 2011 | pterygomaxillary region | o | o | o | . | o | . | o | 62% | ||||||||
Li | 2011 | maxilla | o | o | . | . | . | o | 75% | |||||||||
Tulunoglu | 2011 | cephalometry 2d vs 3D | o | o | o | . | . | . | . | o | 63% | |||||||
Choi | 2012 | ossification pal suture | o | o | . | . | o | . | o | 67% | ||||||||
Seike | 2012 | bone graft size, density | o | . | o | . | . | o | . | . | o | 60% | ||||||
Ye | 2012 | palatal shelf elevation | o | o | . | . | o | o | 69% |
= Fulfilled satisfactorily the methodological criteria;
o = Did not fulfill the methodological criteria;
. = Not applicable.