Skip to main content
. 2014 Apr 7;9(4):e93442. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0093442

Table 6. Methodological quality scores of stereophotogrammetry studies with an overall quality score of ≥60%.

First author Year Topic Study design Measure Statistics Score
A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O
Ras 1994 facial asymmetry Inline graphic Inline graphic o Inline graphic o o . Inline graphic . Inline graphic . Inline graphic Inline graphic Inline graphic o 67%
Al-Omari 2003 facial deformity scoring Inline graphic Inline graphic o Inline graphic . o . Inline graphic . Inline graphic . Inline graphic . Inline graphic Inline graphic 80%
Devlin 2007 nasal symmetry Inline graphic o o Inline graphic . o . Inline graphic . Inline graphic . Inline graphic . Inline graphic o 60%
Bugaighis 2010 facial shape Inline graphic Inline graphic Inline graphic Inline graphic Inline graphic Inline graphic . Inline graphic . Inline graphic . Inline graphic Inline graphic Inline graphic o 92%
Hoefert 2010 soft tissue changes face Inline graphic o o Inline graphic Inline graphic Inline graphic . Inline graphic . o Inline graphic Inline graphic o Inline graphic Inline graphic 69%
Hoefert 2010 soft tissue changes face Inline graphic Inline graphic o Inline graphic Inline graphic o . Inline graphic . Inline graphic Inline graphic O . . . 70%
Tanikawa 2010 Lips Inline graphic Inline graphic o Inline graphic . o . Inline graphic . Inline graphic . Inline graphic o Inline graphic o 64%
Van Loon 2010 Nose Inline graphic Inline graphic o Inline graphic o o . Inline graphic . Inline graphic . Inline graphic Inline graphic Inline graphic Inline graphic 75%
Clark 2011 Lips Inline graphic Inline graphic o Inline graphic Inline graphic o . Inline graphic Inline graphic o Inline graphic Inline graphic Inline graphic Inline graphic o 71%
Kau 2011 maxilla/lip after bone graft Inline graphic o o Inline graphic o Inline graphic . Inline graphic Inline graphic o . Inline graphic Inline graphic o Inline graphic 62%
Sander 2011 Nose Inline graphic Inline graphic o Inline graphic Inline graphic Inline graphic . Inline graphic o Inline graphic Inline graphic Inline graphic Inline graphic Inline graphic o 79%
Zreaqat 2012 lips, eyes, nose, chin with controls Inline graphic Inline graphic o Inline graphic Inline graphic o . Inline graphic . Inline graphic . Inline graphic Inline graphic Inline graphic Inline graphic 77%
Millar 2013 facial asymmetry and scars Inline graphic Inline graphic Inline graphic o Inline graphic o . Inline graphic . o . Inline graphic Inline graphic Inline graphic o 67%

Inline graphic = Fulfilled satisfactorily the methodological criteria;

o = Did not fulfill the methodological criteria;

. = Not applicable.