Table 4.
Ref. | Study design | No. of patients | Survival (P value) | Disease free survival (P value) | Recurrence (P value) | Loco-regional recurrence (P value) |
Moertel et al[44], 1984 | RCT surgery alone (S) vs surgery + chemoradiotherapy (SCRT) | S: 39 | At 5 yr | At 5 yr | - | S vs SCRT |
SCRT: 23 | S < SCRT | S < SCRT | (NS) | |||
(0.05) | (0.02) | |||||
Allum et al[45], 1989 BSCG | RCT surgery alone (S) vs surgery + chemoradiotherapy (SCRT) vs surgery + chemotherapy (SCT) | S: 145 | At 5 yr | - | - | S vs SCRT (NS) |
SCRT: 153 | S vs SCRT | S vs SCT (NS) | ||||
SCT: 138 | vs CT (NS) | |||||
Hallissey et al[46], 1994 BSCG | RCT surgery alone (S) vs surgery + chemoradiotherapy (SCRT) vs surgery + chemotherapy (SCT) | S: 145 | At 5 yr | - | - | - |
SCRT: 153 | S vs SCRT | |||||
SCT: 138 | vs CT (NS) | |||||
Macdonald et al[42], 2001INT-0116 | RCT surgery alone (S) vs surgery + chemoradiotherapy (SCRT) | S: 275 | At 3 yr | At 3 yr | At 3 yr | At 3 yr |
SCRT: 281 | S < SCRT | S < SCRT | S > SCRT | S > SCRT | ||
(0.005) | (0.001) | (0.001) | (0.0001) | |||
Dikken et al[49], 2010 | Retrospective surgery alone (S) vs surgery + chemoradiotherapy (SCRT) | S: 694 | At 24 mo S vs SCRT (NS) | At 24 mo | - | At 24 mo |
SCRT: 91 | S vs SCRT (NS) | S > SCRT (0.0015) | ||||
Kim et al[51], 2005 | Observational surgery alone (S) vs surgery + chemoradiotherapy (SCRT) | S: 446 | At 5 yr | At 5 yr | - | At 5 yr |
SCRT: 544 | S < SCRT | S < SCRT | S > SCRT | |||
(0.01) | (0.01) | (0.005) | ||||
Smalley et al[53], 2012 | RCT surgery alone (S) vs surgery + chemoradiotherapy (SCRT) | S: 227 | At 10 yr | At 10 yr | At 10 yr | Ar 10 yr |
INT-0116 | SCRT: 282 | S < SCRT | S < SCRT | S > SCRT | S > SCRT | |
(0.0046) | (0.001) | (0.006) | (0.0001) | |||
Fiorica et al[54], 2007 | Meta-analysis surgery alone (S) vs surgery + chemoradiotherapy (SCRT) | S: 424 | At 5 yr | - | - | - |
SCRT: 444 | S < SCRt | |||||
(0.00001) | ||||||
Lee et al[55], 2011 | RCT surgery + chemoradiotherapy (SCRT) vs surgery + chemotherapy (SC) | SCRT: 230 | - | At 3 yr | SCRT vs SC (NS) | SCRT vs SC (NS) |
SC: 228 | SCRT vs SC (NS) |
RCT: Randomized controlled trial; NS: Not significant.