Table 5.
Comparison of clinical reports evaluating cardiac innervation in PD using 18F-FDA
| Reference | Number of Patients | Mean PD age (age range) | PD H&Y stage (disease duration yrs) | Methods to evaluate cardiac DYA | PD patient DYA descripttion | Homogenous cardiac perfusion Y/N (radiotracer) | LV regions analyzed | % of LV global uptake reduction | Region of maximal reduction (% of loss) | Significant loss of plasma catechol-amines Y/N | Comments | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
|
||||||||||||||
| PD | MSA | PSP | Control | |||||||||||
| 18F-FDA | ||||||||||||||
| Goldstein et al., 1997 | 2 | 9 with SNF 4 w/o SNF | - | 22 | No age defined | Stage and disease duration not defined | NE spillover, plasma DHPG, LDOPA, DOPAC | n=2 of 2 PD with SNF (No detectable NE spillover) | - | Septal and free wall | Undetect-able levels | - | No detectable increments | PD FDA uptake reduced compared to MSA. |
| Goldstein et al., 2000 | 29 | 24 | - | 33 | 70 (No range defined) | Average H&Y 2.4 (disease duration not defined) | OH evaluation after standing, ECG (BP and HR for RR interval), plasma NE spillover, plasma DHPG and LDOPA, valsalva | n=9 of 29 PD with SNF (decreased NE spillover), n=20 of 29 without SNF (12 of 20 had abnormal valsalva) | - | Septal wall (free wall not easily identified). Apex and free wall analyzed by visual inspection. | 70%b | Apex or free wall (no % provided; n=5 of 20 PD without SNF) | Y (DHPG/ LDOPA in 9 of 29) | All PD have reduced septal FDA compared to MSA. Septal FDA lower in PD with SNF compared to PD without SNF. Of 20 PD without SNF, 4 had normal FDA. |
| Li et al., 2002 | 9 | - | - | - | 60 (No range defined) | H&Y 1-3; average 2.2, (disease duration not defined) | Plasma NE and Epi and valsalva only conducted at T=1. | 2 timepoints (T1, T2) 1-4 yrs apart. Abnormal valsalva and no OH at T1 or T2. | - | Septal and lateral walls and apex | 23%a,D | Lateral (31%a,D loss) | N | T1, 2 of 9 had normal FDA and 7 of 9 had decreased FDA confined to lateral wall or apex. T2, all 9 PD have reduced FDA. |
| Singleton et al., 2004 | 2 (triplication of α-syn) | - | - | 1 | 5th decade of life | Stage not defined (1-10) | OH evaluation after standing, plasma NE and Epi, valsalva | n=2 of 2 have abnormal valsalva, n=1 of 2 OH | Y (13N-NH3) | Septal wall | 81.6%b | - | N | Patients with triplication of α-synuclein have similar FDA uptake as iPD. |
| Tipre et al., 2005 | 26 | - | - | 12 | No mean defined (30-70) | Stage and disease duration not defined | No additional cardiac DYA evaluations | n=26 of 26 PD with OH | Y (13N-NH3) | Septal wall | No global results provided | - | - | FDA uptake significantly reduced in septal wall of PD and PAF compared to controls. |
| Goldstein et al., 2007a | 1 | - | - | - | 56 | T1=not yet diagnosed with PD; T2=Stage not defined | Plasma NE and Epi, valsalva | 2 timepoints (T1, T2) 4 yrs apart. Abnormal valsalva and exercise and orthostatic intolerance. | - | Septal wall | 85%c | - | N | Severely decreased global FDA uptake at both T1 and T2. |
| Goldstein et al., 2007b | 1 (LRRK2 T2356I mutation) | - | - | - | 63 | No stage defined (10) | OH evaluation after standing, plasma NE and DHPG, valsalva | Abnormal valsalva but no OH | Y (13N-NH3) | Septal wall | Undetectable levels | - | Y (DHPG was low during OH evaluation; normal NE) | Brain FDA PET showed decreased uptake in the striatum and nigra. |
Listed percentages describe loss of 18F-FDA uptake compared to controls (unless otherwise noted) and reported originally in the reference (a) or calculated based on data (b numbers or c graph) from the publication. Dcompared across timepoints. 13N-NH3, [13N]-ammonium; 18F-FDA, [18F]-dopamine; AF, autonomic failure; BF, baroreflex failure; BP, blood pressure; DHPG, Dihydroxyphenylglycine; DOPAC, dihydroxyphenylacetic acid; DYA, dysautonomia; Epi, epinephrine; H&Y, Hoehn & Yahr; iPD, idiopathic PD; LDOPA, L-3,4-dihydroxyphenylalanine; LRRK2, leucine rich repeating kinase 2; LV, left ventricle; MSA, multiple systems atrophy; NE, norepinephrine; OH, orthostatic hypotension; PAF, pure autonomic failure; PD, Parkinson’s disease; PSP, progressive supranuclear palsy; SNF, sympathetic neurocirculatory failure.