Table 1.

Results from the original paper [1] and from the re-analyses.

experiment and figure in original paper	male type	female marking method	explanatory variables	overdispersion factor	p-value originally reported	re-analysis estimate	re-analysis s.e.	re-analysis z-value	re-analysis p-value
direct novelty figure 1a	wild-type	eye colour	familiarity (novel)	2.45	<0.001	0.6481	0.3643	1.78	0.075
			eye colour (white)		<0.001	2.7899	0.3643	7.66	<0.001
direct novelty figure 1a	wild-type	paint	familiarity (novel)	2.5	<0.001	0.7854	0.2315	3.39	<0.001
			paint status (painted)		<0.001	0.4587	0.2315	1.98	0.048
direct novelty figure 1a	wild-type	females not marked (decapitated)	familiarity (novel)	10.34	<0.001	1.5075	0.4903	3.07	0.002
phenotypic novelty figure 1c	wild-type	paint colour	familiarity (novel)	2.37	<0.001	0.9972	0.4257	2.34	0.019
			paint colour (yellow)		0.073	−0.5631	0.4257	−1.32	0.186
phenotypic novelty figure 1c	Orco mutant	paint colour	familiarity (novel)	1.69	0.873	−0.0060	0.3289	−0.02	0.986
			paint colour (yellow)		0.294	−0.3191	0.3289	−0.97	0.332
phenotypic novelty figure 1c	wild-type	females not marked (decapitated)	familiarity (novel)	5.90	<0.001	1.0736	0.2185	4.91	<0.001
phenotypic novelty figure 1c	Orco mutant	females not marked (decapitated)	familiarity (novel)	2.92	<0.001	0.6170	0.2120	2.91	0.004