Table 3.

Patients with meniscal pathology at the time of ACL reconstruction.

Author	Year	Articular cartilage status at reconstruction	Meniscal status at reconstruction
Deehan	2000	All normal	All normal or with at least 2/3 of meniscus present
Drogset	2002	Normal = 56% Articular cartilage pathology = 44%	Normal = 31% Meniscal pathology present = 69%
Hart	2005	All normal	Normal = 48% Partial meniscectomy = 52%
Hanypsiak	2008	Normal = 54% Articular cartilage pathology = 46%	Normal = 45% Meniscal pathology present = 55%
Ibrahim	2005	Normal = 84% Articular cartilage pathology = 16%	Normal = 73% Meniscal pathology present = 27%
Keays	2007	NR	Normal = 40% Partial meniscectomy = 60%
Lebel	2008	Normal = 76% Articular cartilage pathology = 24%	Normal = 46% Meniscal pathology present = 54%
Liden	2007	Normal = 89% Articular cartilage pathology = 11%	Normal = 27% Meniscal pathology present = 73%
Matumoto	2006	Normal = 86% Articular cartilage pathology = 14%	Normal = 25% Meniscal pathology present = 75%
O’Neill	2001	NR	NR
Panni	2001	NR	NR
Roe	2005	All normal	Normal = 84% Meniscal pathology present = 16%
Ruiz	2002	NR	NR
Sajovic	2006	NR	Normal = 55% Meniscal pathology present = 45%
Shelbourne	2009	Normal = 78% Articular cartilage pathology = 22%	Normal = 57% Meniscal pathology present = 43%
Spindler	2005	Normal = 78% Articular cartilage pathology = 22%	NR
Wu	2002	Normal = 55% Articular cartilage pathology = 45%	Normal = 39% Meniscal Pathology Present = 61%
Zaffagnini	2006	All normal	All normal

NR, not reported.