Table 3. Patients and tumors descriptions.
Authors | Mean age years | Gender [M/F] | ASA >2 n [%] | Child-Pugh A-B-C n [%] | Cirrhosis n [%] | Mean size of the tumor cm [range] | Location of the tumor | Number of tumours | Type of resection n | Associated resections | Surgical margin mm [range] |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Truant S et al. (11) | 60.6±10.2 | 31/5 | 11 [30.6] | A: 32 | 2.9±1.2 | Ant.segments | 1.1±0.3 | Minor | 4 LC | 9.5±2.8 | |
Dagher I et al.* (12) | 65 [24-84] | 112/51 | 45 [27.6] | A: 111 B: 8 C: 1 |
120 [73.6] | 3.6 [1-20] | All segments | NR | Minor: 147; major: 16 |
40 LC 14 other 12 RFA |
12 [0-58] |
Tranchart H et al. (13) | 63.7±13.1 | 27/15 | 12 [28.5] | A: 30 B: 1 |
31 [73.8] | NR | NR | NR | Minor: 37; major: 5 |
NR | 10.4±8.0 |
Sarpel U et al. (14) | 63.8±10.3 | 15/9 | NR | NR | 9 [45] | 4.2±2.1 | NR | NR | NR | NR | NR |
Belli G et al. (15) | 63±6.8 | 38/27 | 13 [20] | A: 58 [89] B: 7 |
65 [100] | 3.8±1.4 | All segments | Single: 53; multiple: 12 |
Minor: 6; major: 59 |
NR | <10: 9 >10: 56 |
Casaccia M et al. (16) | 66 [47-76] | 12/8 | NR | A: 17 B: 3 |
20 [100] | 3.1 [0.9-5] | All.segments | >1 | Minor: 19; major: 1 |
5 LC 3 other |
15 [0-40] |
Aldrighetti L et al. (17) | 65±10 | 11/5 | 2 [12.9] | A: 9 | 9 [56] | 4±2.2 | Ant.segments + VII | NR | Minor: 16 | 5 LC | 11±7.4 |
Soubrane O et al.* (18) | 63 [30-90] | 260/91 | 91 [31.4] | A: 275 B: 8 C: 1 |
NR | 3.5 [0.5-17] | All segments | Single: 302; multiple: 49 |
Minor: 315; major: 36 |
NR | 10 [0-78] |
Santanbrogio R et al. (19) | 61.4±8.3 | 13/9 | NR | A: 17 B: 5 |
22 [100] | 2.7±1.2 | Ant.segments | NR | Minor: 22 | 3 RFA 1 alchoolic ablation |
11.1±7.4 |
Cherqui D et al. (20) | 63±9 | 22/5 | NR | A: 20 | 20 [74] | 3.3 [2-5] | Ant.segments + VIII | 1 | Minor: 26; major: 1 |
NR | 11 [1-47] |
Vibert E et al. (21) | NR | NR | NR | A: 7 B: 1 |
8 [50] | 6.5 [0.8-18] | NR | Single: 15; multiple: 1 |
NR | NR | 10 [1-50] |
*, Multicentre experience; Ant. segments, II, III, IVb, V, VI; LC, laparoscopic cholecystectomy; RFA, radiofrequency ablation; NR, no reported.