Skip to main content
. 2014 Mar 7;8:13–19. doi: 10.2174/1874120701408010013

Table 4.

Advantages and disadvantages of ANN-wavelet, wavelet transform, adaptive filter, ANN, subtraction and HPF methods for our gold in this study.

  Advantages Disadvantages
ANN-wavelet Fast with a very good result (high SNR and low RE (Table 1), smooth coherence (Fig. 6) and PSD (Fig. 5)) Needs multiple input (based on ECG)
Wavelet transform Needs single input, simple and fast Remains noise in the output because of inconvenient thresholding (low SNR and high RE (Table 1))
Adaptive filter Adaptation in removing ECG noise (fair SNR (Table 1)) Needs multiple input, time consuming, heavy computations with high RE (Table 1) and uneven coherence (Fig. 6)
ANN Fast with an acceptable result ( high SNR and relatively low RE (Table 1)) Needs multiple input, remains noise in low frequencies (uneven coherence in low frequencies (Fig. 6))
Subtraction Acceptable result (high SNR, relatively low RE (Table 1)) Needs multiple input, time consuming, heavy computations and uneven coherence in low frequencies (Fig. 6)
High-pass filter Needs single input, very simple method Removes useful information (low SNR, high RE and low CC (Table 1), uneven coherence (Fig. 6))