Table 4.
Advantages and disadvantages of ANN-wavelet, wavelet transform, adaptive filter, ANN, subtraction and HPF methods for our gold in this study.
Advantages | Disadvantages | |
---|---|---|
ANN-wavelet | Fast with a very good result (high SNR and low RE (Table 1), smooth coherence (Fig. 6) and PSD (Fig. 5)) | Needs multiple input (based on ECG) |
Wavelet transform | Needs single input, simple and fast | Remains noise in the output because of inconvenient thresholding (low SNR and high RE (Table 1)) |
Adaptive filter | Adaptation in removing ECG noise (fair SNR (Table 1)) | Needs multiple input, time consuming, heavy computations with high RE (Table 1) and uneven coherence (Fig. 6) |
ANN | Fast with an acceptable result ( high SNR and relatively low RE (Table 1)) | Needs multiple input, remains noise in low frequencies (uneven coherence in low frequencies (Fig. 6)) |
Subtraction | Acceptable result (high SNR, relatively low RE (Table 1)) | Needs multiple input, time consuming, heavy computations and uneven coherence in low frequencies (Fig. 6) |
High-pass filter | Needs single input, very simple method | Removes useful information (low SNR, high RE and low CC (Table 1), uneven coherence (Fig. 6)) |