Table 10.
Sensitivity, specificity, and exact 95% CI for each SUVR type/pathology SoT combination in retrospective vs. prospective studies for all 4 studies combined
|
Cerebellum REF |
Pons REF |
||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Pathology SoT | Ipsilateral | Contralateral | Composite | Ipsilateral | Contralateral | Composite |
4G8
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Retrospective |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Sensitivity (95% CI) |
1.0000 (0.3976, 1.0000) |
1.0000 (0.3976, 1.0000) |
0.5000 (0.0676, 0.9324) |
1.0000 (0.3976, 1.0000) |
0.7500 (0.1941, 0.9937) |
0.7500 (0.1941, 0.9937) |
Specificity (95% CI) |
0.6000 (0.3605, 0.8088) |
0.7500 (0.5090, 0.9134) |
0.9000 (0.6830, 0.9877) |
0.4762 (0.2571, 0.7022) |
0.6667 ()0.4303, 0.8541 |
0.6667 (0.4303, 0.8541) |
Sum (sensitivity + specificity) |
1.6000 |
1.7500 |
1.4000 |
1.4762 |
1.4167 |
1.4167 |
Prospective |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Sensitivity (95% CI) |
1.0000 (0.4782, 1.0000) |
1.0000 (0.4782, 1.0000) |
0.8000 (0.2836, 0.9949) |
1.0000 (0.4782, 1.0000) |
1.0000 (0.4782, 1.0000) |
1.0000 (0.4782, 1.0000) |
Specificity (95% CI) |
0.6471 (0.3833, 0.8579) |
0.5882 (0.3292, 0.8156) |
0.8235 (0.5657, 0.9620) |
0.5294 (0.2781, 0.7702) |
0.6471 (0.3833, 0.8579) |
0.5882 (0.3292, 0.8156) |
Sum (sensitivity + specificity) |
1.6471 |
1.5882 |
1.6235 |
1.5294 |
1.6471 |
1.5882 |
Bielschowsky
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Retrospective |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Sensitivity (95% CI) |
1.0000 (0.4782, 1.0000) |
1.0000 (0.4782, 1.0000) |
1.0000 (0.4782, 1.0000) |
1.0000 (0.4782, 1.0000) |
1.0000 (0.4782, 1.0000) |
1.0000 (0.4782, 1.0000) |
Specificity (95% CI) |
0.8750 (0.6165, 0.9845) |
0.8750 (0.6165, 0.9845) |
0.9375 (0.6977, 0.9984) |
0.7647 (0.5010, 0.9319) |
0.8824 (0.6356, 0.9854) |
0.8824 (0.6356, 0.9854) |
Sum (sensitivity + specificity) |
1.8750 |
1.8750 |
1.9375 |
1.7647 |
1.8824 |
1.8824 |
Prospective |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Sensitivity (95% CI) |
1.0000 (0.2924, 1.0000) |
1.0000 (0.2924, 1.0000) |
1.0000 (0.2924, 1.0000) |
1.0000 (0.2924, 1.0000) |
1.0000 (0.2924, 1.0000) |
1.0000 (0.2924, 1.0000) |
Specificity (95% CI) |
0.9091 (0.5872, 0.9977) |
0.9091 (0.5872, 0.9977) |
0.9091 (0.5872, 0.9977) |
0.9091 (0.5872, 0.9977) |
1.0000 (0.7151, 1.000) |
0.8182 (0.4822, 0.9772) |
Sum (sensitivity + specificity) |
1.9091 |
1.9091 |
1.9091 |
1.9091 |
2.0000 |
1.8182 |
Thioflavin S
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Retrospective |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Sensitivity (95% CI) |
0.8571 (0.4213, 0.9964) |
0.8571 (0.4213, 0.9964) |
1.0000 (0.5904, 1.0000) |
0.8571 (0.4213, 0.9964) |
0.8571 (0.4213, 0.9964) |
0.8571 (0.4213, 0.9964) |
Specificity (95% CI) |
1.0000 (0.8235, 1.0000) |
0.9474 (0.7397, 0.9987) |
0.8947 (0.6686, 0.9870) |
0.7000 (0.4572, 0.8811) |
0.9000 (0.6830, 0.9877) |
0.9000 (0.6830, 0.9877) |
Sum (sensitivity + specificity) |
1.8571 |
1.8045 |
1.8947 |
1.5571 |
1.7571 |
1.7571 |
Prospective |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Sensitivity (95% CI) |
0.5000 (0.0126, 0.9874) |
1.0000 (0.1581, 1.0000) |
1.0000 (0.1581, 1.0000) |
1.0000 (0.1581, 1.0000) |
1.0000 (0.1581, 1.0000) |
1.0000 (0.1581, 1.0000) |
Specificity (95% CI) |
0.9231 (0.6397, 0.9981) |
0.8462 (0.5455, 0.9808) |
0.7692 (0.4619, 0.9496) |
0.8462 (0.5455, 0.9808) |
0.9231 (0.6397, 0.9981) |
0.7692 (0.4619, 0.9496) |
Sum (sensitivity + specificity) |
1.4231 |
1.8462 |
1.7692 |
1.8462 |
1.9231 |
1.7692 |
Overall pathology
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Retrospective |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Sensitivity (95% CI) |
1.0000 (0.5407, 1.0000) |
1.0000 (0.5407, 1.0000) |
1.0000 (0.5407, 1.0000) |
1.0000 (0.5407, 1.0000) |
1.0000 (0.5407, 1.0000) |
1.0000 (0.5407, 1.0000) |
Specificity (95% CI) |
1.0000 (0.8316, 1.000) |
0.9500 (0.7513, 9987) |
1.0000 (0.8316, 1.0000) |
0.8095 (0.5809, 0.9455) |
0.8571 (0.6366, 0.9695) |
1.0000 (0.8389, 1.000) |
Sum (sensitivity + specificity) |
2.0000 |
1.9500 |
2.0000 |
1.8095 |
1.8571 |
2.0000 |
Prospective |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Sensitivity (95% CI) |
0.8750 (0.4735, 0.9968) |
1.0000 (0.6306, 1.0000) |
1.0000 (0.6306, 1.0000) |
0.8750 (0.4735, 0.9968) |
1.0000 (0.6306, 1.0000) |
0.8750 (0.4735, 0.9968) |
Specificity (95% CI) |
1.0000 (0.7684, 1.000) |
1.0000 (0.7684, 1.0000) |
1.0000 (0.7684, 1.0000) |
0.9286 (0.6613, 0.9982) |
0.9286 (0.6613, 0.9982) |
1.0000 (0.7684, 1.0000) |
Sum (sensitivity + specificity) | 1.8750 | 2.0000 | 2.0000 | 1.8036 | 1.9286 | 1.8750 |
REF = PET imaging brain reference region; SoT = standard of truth, SUVR = standard uptake value ratio. Refer to [32] for a discussion of agreement between readers.