Table 5.
Number | Studies | Methods | Participants | Interventions | Outcomes | Results |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Pradeep et al. [64] | 6-week triple-blinded RCT | 149 completing out of 160 | Group A: 5% potassium nitrate toothpaste -Group B: 5% calcium sodium phosphosilicate toothpaste -Group C: 3.85% amine fluoride toothpaste -Group D: placebo toothpaste (negative control; no information was provided as to the constituents of control) |
Pre-op and post-op evaporative (controlled air stimulus) and thermal stimuli (10 mL of ice cold water) used |
5% CSPS > 3.85% amine fluoride > KNO3 > placebo |
| ||||||
2 | Pradeep and Sharma [65] |
6-week triple-blinded RCT | 110 completing out of 120 | Group A: 5% calcium sodium phosphosilicate (Novamin) toothpaste -Group B: 5% potassium nitrate toothpaste (positive control) -Group C: same formulation as toothpaste A; however, no active ingredient (negative control) |
Pre-op and post-op evaporative (controlled air stimulus) and thermal stimuli (10 mL of ice cold water) used |
5% CPS > KNO3 > placebo |
| ||||||
3 | Litkowski and Greenspan [66] |
8-week double-blind randomized placebo controlled pilot study | 66 No mention of dropouts |
Group A: placebo control toothpaste (negative control; no information was provided as to the constituents of control) -Group B: 2.5% Novamin toothpaste -Group C: 7.5% Novamin toothpaste |
Pre-op and post-op tactile (Yeaple probe calibrated at 40 g force) and an evaporative stimulus (one-second air blast) | 7.5% CSPS > 2.5% CSPS > placebo |