Skip to main content
. 2014 May 1;9(5):e96407. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0096407

Table 1. Characteristics of the included SRs (n = 701).

Appropriate PRISMA citation Citation of PRISMA without complementary citation of other relevant guideline Total p-value
No. % No. % No. %
Medical Field
Public Health 44 10 59 22 103 15 <0.001*
Psychiatry/Neurology 28 6 35 13 63 9
Oncology 47 11 41 16 88 13
Other 55 13 33 13 88 13
Obstetrics 30 7 14 5 44 6
General Medicine 85 19 36 14 121 17
General Surgery 30 7 10 4 40 6
Cardiovascular 74 17 19 7 93 13
Orthopedics/Physiotherapy 28 6 10 4 38 5
Dentistry 17 4 6 2 23 3
Number of authors
1–3 114 26 63 24 117 25 0.34*
4–5 152 35 82 31 234 33
≥6 172 39 118 45 290 41
Methodologist Involvement
No 264 60 190 72 454 65 0.001*
Yes 174 40 73 28 247 35
Cited PRISMA article
BMJ 113 26 76 29 189 27 0.79
JCE 61 14 27 10 88 13
PLoS Med 159 36 100 38 259 37
IJS 18 4 9 3 27 4
Ann Intern Med 83 19 50 19 133 19
Phys Ther 4 1 1 0 5 1
Reason for citing PRISMA
Reporting 402 92 220 84 622 89 <0.01
Flow diagram 23 5 17 6 40 6
Illustrative 3 1 6 2 9 1
Quality assessment 1 0 6 2 7 1
Search strategy 9 2 14 5 23 3
Type of SR
Interventional 356 81 4 2 360 51 <0.001
Epidemiological 48 11 236 90 284 41
Diagnostic 34 8 23 9 57 8
Meta-analysis
No 126 29 116 44 242 35 <0.001*
Yes 312 71 147 56 459 65
Total 438 100 263 100 701 100

*Pearson chi2, Fisher’s exact test.