Skip to main content
. 2014 May 6;9(5):e88490. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0088490

Table 1. Main characteristics of all studies included in the meta-analysis.

First author/year Country Ethnicity Cancer type SC XPG Asp1104His (Case/control) XPF Arg415Gln (Case/control) HWE
Smith [8] 2003 USA Caucasian Breast HB NA NA NA 217/236 29/32 7/0 Yes
Kumar [9] 2003 Filand Caucasian Breast HB 108/182 96/107 16/19 NA NA NA Yes
Jeon [10] 2003 Korea Asian Lung HB 58/90 164/132 88/89 NA NA NA No
Sanyal [11] 2004 Swede Caucasian Bladder NA 182/173 109/91 8/20 NA NA NA Yes
Blankenburg [12] 2005 German Caucasian Melanoma HB 184/232 100/124 9/18 NA NA NA Yes
Weiss [13] 2005 USA Mixed Endometrial PB 215/250 134/148 22/22 316/369 54/49 1/2 Yes
Shen [14] 2005 China Asian Lung PB 26/25 52/46 38/38 NA NA NA Yes
Bigler [15] 2005 USA Mixed Colorectal PB 440/353 243/226 36/37 NA NA NA Yes
Sakiyama [16] 2005 Japan Asian Lung HB 300/228 500/333 202/124 NA NA NA Yes
Cui [17] 2006 USA Mixed Lung PB 244/468 212/356 41/78 NA NA NA Yes
Cui [17] 2006 USA Mixed Multiple PB 214/474 194/357 35/80 NA NA NA Yes
Zienolddiny [18] 2006 Norway Caucasian Lung HB NA NA NA 195/178 26/21 3/1 Yes
Millikan [19] 2006 USA Caucasian Melanoma PB 731/1513 389/780 73/115 1026/2073 173/360 9/12 Yes
Mechanic [20] 2006 USA Caucasian Breast PB 771/661 409/412 69/60 1049/980 185/150 12/3 Yes
Mechanic [20] 2006 USA African Breast PB 231/231 387/320 139/123 738/642 18/31 1/0 Yes
Huang [21] 2006 USA Mixed Colorectal PB 407/403 243/265 29/29 624/623 78/86 1/7 Yes
García-Closas [22] 2006 Spain Caucasian Bladder HB 629/607 434/445 78/84 885/824 203/182 14/19 Yes
Moreno [23] 2006 Spain Caucasian Colorectal HB NA NA NA 282/257 71/61 7/5 Yes
Shen [24] 2006 USA Mixed NHL PB 260/352 170/169 34/29 NA NA NA Yes
Shen [25] 2006 USA Mixed Breast FB 83/82 63/62 8/7 NA NA NA Yes
Wen [26] 2006 China Asian HNC PB 55/129 81/296 39/100 NA NA NA No
Li [27] 2006 USA Caucasian Melanoma HB 373/370 206/206 23/27 NA NA NA Yes
Wu [28] 2006 USA Caucasian Bladder HB 364/371 225/211 26/18 NA NA NA Yes
Sugimura [29] 2006 Japan Asian HNC HB 20/52 59/112 43/77 NA NA NA Yes
Thirumaran [30] 2006 Multiple Caucasian Skin HB 325/330 172/173 32/30 NA NA NA Yes
Hill [31] 2006 Multiple Mixed NHL PB 599/521 425/331 77/71 NA NA NA Yes
Crew [32] 2007 USA Mixed Breast PB 562/571 371/409 66/71 859/888 156/167 3/10 Yes
Jorgensen [33] 2007 USA Caucasian Breast PB 159/165 93/95 12/15 221/231 37/43 1/1 Yes
Romanowicz [34] 2007 Poland Caucasian Breast NA NA NA NA 31/21 40/48 29/37 Yes
Povey [35] 2007 UK Caucasian Melanoma PB 314/252 169/162 24/27 NA NA NA Yes
Wang [36] 2007 USA Mixed Skin HB 146/200 89/119 11/10 NA NA NA Yes
Shen [37] 2007 Australia Caucasian NHL PB 340/294 170/163 30/27 NA NA NA Yes
McWilliams [38] 2008 USA Mixed Pancreatic HB NA NA NA 411/481 59/111 0/4 Yes
Hooker [39] 2008 USA African Prostate HB 74/100 119/141 61/60 NA NA NA Yes
Smith [40] 2008 USA Caucasian Breast HB 195/256 113/124 12/28 278/358 39/47 7/1 Yes
Smith [40] 2008 USA African Breast HB 13/18 32/37 7/20 51/73 2/2 0/0 Yes
Chang [41] 2008 USA Hispanic Lung HB 60/138 44/127 9/34 97/267 16/31 0/1 Yes
Chang [41] 2008 USA African Lung HB 68/93 119/138 68/49 NA NA NA Yes
Rajaraman [42] 2008 USA Caucasian Breast PB 482/674 288/352 49/53 714/922 124/147 Yes
Frei˘din [43] 2008 Russia Caucasian Multiple HB 38/92 12/36 2/12 NA NA NA No
Hung [44] 2008 Multiple Mixed Lung NA 1852/2485 1155/1510 209/286 2201/2208 306/390 13/21 No for Asp1104His
He [45] 2008 China Asian Cervical HB 35/53 94/80 71/67 NA NA NA No
Pardini [46] 2008 Czech Caucasian Colorectal HB 334/356 177/153 21/23 NA NA NA Yes
Joshi [47] 2009 USA Caucasian Colorectal FB 183/213 125/148 265/313 40/47 NA
El-Zein [48] 2009 USA Mixed NHL HB 104/127 78/80 16/12 NA NA NA Yes
Wen [49] 2009 China Asian Bladder HB 15/45 57/233 NA NA NA NA
Narter [50] 2009 Turkey Caucasian Bladder NA 25/18 28/19 3/3 NA NA NA Yes
Abbasi [51] 2009 German Caucasian HNC PB 137/380 103/230 8/37 203/554 44/90 1/3 Yes
Hussain [52] 2009 China Asian Gastric PB 38/90 104/180 39/91 NA NA NA Yes
McKean-Cowdin [53] 2009 USA Caucasian Glioma PB 499/989 348/657 157/311 NA NA NA No
Pan [54] 2009 USA Caucasian esophageal HB 222/287 145/155 15/15 NA NA NA Yes
Han [55] 2009 USA Caucasian Breast PB 142/285 80/167 17/20 200/401 38/69 0/2 Yes
Liu [56] 2009 USA Caucasian Glioma PB 353/351 20/13 NA NA NA NA
Agalliu [57] 2010 USA Caucasian Prostate PB NA NA NA 1025/1012 183/202 13/5 Yes
Agalliu [57] 2010 USA African Prostate PB NA NA NA 136/78 8/3 0/0 Yes
Rajaraman [58] 2010 USA Caucasian Glioma HB 206/286 123/156 13/26 280/405 56/62 1/4 Yes
Ming-Shiean [59] 2010 China Asian Breast HB 134/159 191/243 76/129 NA NA NA Yes
Li [60] 2010 China Asian Liver HB 174/151 233/265 93/91 NA NA NA Yes
Canbay [61] 2010 Turkey Caucasian Gastric NA 25/148 12/83 3/16 NA NA NA Yes
Figl [62] 2010 Multiple Caucasian Melanoma HB 703/725 409/465 74/84 NA NA NA Yes
Rouissi [63] 2011 Tunis African Bladder HB 95/87 70/86 28/20 NA NA NA Yes
Liu [64] 2011 China Asian Colorectal HB 233/329 603/537 192/219 NA NA NA Yes
Canbay [65] 2011 Turkey Caucasian Colorectal NA 43/148 34/83 2/16 NA NA NA Yes
Gonçalves [66] 2011 Braze Caucasian Melanoma HB 105/109 77/74 10/25 NA NA NA Yes
Ibarrola-Villava [67] 2011 Spain Caucasian Melanoma HB 412/242 222/140 50/24 560/316 117/87 7/3 Yes
Doherty [68] 2011 USA Mixed Endometrial PB 418/408 254/248 42/47 593/620 107/89 3/5 Yes
Biason [69] 2011 Italy Caucasian Osteosarcoma HB 75/141 39/94 16/15 NA NA NA Yes
Krupa [70] 2011 Poland Caucasian HNC HB NA NA NA 221/224 26/29 6/0 Yes
Yu [71] 2011 USA Caucasian HNC HB NA NA NA 837/829 195/209 8/8 Yes
Ma [72] 2012 USA Caucasian HNC HB 648/654 359/350 52/62 NA NA NA Yes
Gil [73] 2012 Poland Caucasian Colorectal HB 86/64 35/31 11/5 119/83 14/15 0/0 Yes
Berhane [74] 2012 India Asian Prostate HB 58/128 72/146 20/26 NA NA NA Yes
Paszkowska-Szczur [75] 2013 Poland Caucasian Melanoma PB 412/869 200/404 28/85 NA NA NA Yes
Wen [80] 2013 China Asian Bladder HB 40/172 46/62 26/44 NA NA NA No
Wang [81] 2013 China Asian Glioma HB NA NA NA 265/609 59/36 6/7 No
Santos [82] 2013 Portugal Caucasian HNC HB 51/106 50/85 4/21 77/168 23/38 2/4 No
Cheng [83] 2013 China Asian Glioma HB NA NA NA 149/182 41/43 17/11 Yes

HNC head and neck cancer, PB population-based study, HB hospital-based study.