Table 2.
Summary of neuroprotective strategies for global cerebral ischemia associated with cardiac arrest
| Therapy | Proposed mechanism | Study subject | Blind | Placebo control | Rando-mized | Delivery route | Effect (positive, negative, neutral) | Outcomes evaluated |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Category of Mechanisms I: Modulating neuronal cell death | ||||||||
| MK-80115 |
NMDA antagonist |
Dogs |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
Intravenous |
Negative |
Survival16, neurological function15,16; neurohistopathology15,16 |
| GPI 300016 | ||||||||
| Lamotrigine21 |
Inhibition of glutamate release |
Rats |
Not mentioned |
Yes |
Yes |
Intravenous |
Positive |
Neurohistopathology |
| Xenon26, 30--32 |
NMDA antagonist |
Pigs26, 30–32 |
Yes26, 30–32 |
Yes26, 30–32 |
Yes26, 30–32 |
Inhale26, 30–32 |
Early intervention (10 minutes post-ROSC) Neutral26 |
Neurologic function26, 30–32; neurohistopathology26,30,31 |
| Human (2 ongoing clinical trials: NCT00879892, NCT01262729) |
Late intervention (1 h post-ROSC) Positive30–32 |
|||||||
| Argon33,34 |
Anti-apoptosis |
Rats |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
Inhale |
Positive |
Neurologic function; neurohistopathology; |
| Ischemic post-conditioning 42,43 |
Anti-apoptosis |
Pigs |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
Intravenous |
Positive |
Survival43; neurological function42,43; neurohistopathology43; Left ventricular ejection function42,43 |
| Caspase 3 inhibitor zDEVD-FMK45 |
Anti-apoptosis |
Rats |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
Intracerebro-ventricular |
Neutral |
Neurologic function; neurohistopathology |
| Sodium bicarbonate48,50–52 |
Buffering of metabolic acidosis |
Dogs48 |
Yes48,52 |
Yes48 |
Yes48,52 |
Intravenous |
Positive for long cardiac arrest (15 minutes) and neurtral for short cardiac arrest (5 minutes)48,52 |
Return of spontaneous circulation48, 50–52; survival48,50–52; neurological function48,50–52 |
| Humans (retrospective50,51; perspective52; ongoing clinical trial: NCT01377337) |
No50,51 |
No50–52 |
No50,51 |
|||||
| Positive at low dose (1 mEq/kg) and negative at high dose (>1 mEq/kg)50 |
Mean arterial pressure and coronary perfusion pressure48 |
|||||||
| Positive at high usage (dose not specified)51 |
Neurohistopathology48 |
|||||||
| Carbicarb49 |
Buffering of metabolic acidosis |
Rats |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
Intravenous |
Positive at low dose (3 ml/kg); Negative at high dose (6 ml/kg) |
Mean arterial pressure; survival; neurological function; neurohistopathology |
| Fluoxetine55 |
Anti-inflammatory |
Mice |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
Intravenous |
Neutral at low dose (10 mg/kg); Positive at high dose (5 mg/kg) |
Neurologic function; neurohistopathology |
| Matrix metalloproteinase-9 inhibitor56 |
Anti-inflammatory |
Rats |
Not mentioned |
Yes |
Yes |
Intraperiton-eal |
Positive |
Brain water content; neurohistopathology |
|
Category of Mechanisms II: Influencing oxygen free-radicals | ||||||||
| Hyperoixa (100%) ventilation57--62 |
Increased oxidative stress |
Dogs57–60 |
Not men-tioned57, 59–62 |
No |
Yes |
Inhale |
Negative57–61 |
Neurological function57–61; neurohistopathology58–61; plasma biomarkers of neuronal damage62 |
| Pigs61 |
Yes58 |
Neutral when co-treated with hypothermia and Negative when not co-treated with hypothermia 62 |
||||||
| Human62 | ||||||||
| Methylene blue65–67 |
Attenuation of oxidative and inflammatory injury |
Pigs |
Not mentioned |
Yes |
Yes |
Intravenous |
positive |
Survival65; inflammatory markers65; neurohistopathology 66; genomics67 |
| Inhaled nitric oxide68,69 |
Inhibition of reactive oxygen species |
Mice |
Not mentioned |
Yes |
yes |
Genotype68 |
positive |
Survival68,69; neurological function68,69; neurohistopathology68,69; LVEF68,69; brain edema69; diffusion weighted imaing69 |
| Inhale69 | ||||||||
| Nitrite70,71 |
Reversible inhibition of mitochondrial complex I with reduced free radical production70 |
Rats70 |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
Intravenous |
Positive |
Survival; neurological function; neurohistopathology |
| Improved mitochondrial function and S-nitrosylation for pro-survival71 | ||||||||
| Mice71 | ||||||||
| N-acetylcysteine75 |
Free-radical scavenger |
dogs |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
Intravenous |
Neutral |
Neurologic function |
|
Category of Mechanisms III: Improving cerebral hemodynamics | ||||||||
| Intrathoracic pressure during CPR76–79 |
Improved organ perfusion |
Pigs76,77 |
Not men-tioned76,77 |
Yes |
Yes |
Intrathoracic pressure regulator76 |
Positive76–79 |
Survival76–79; neurological function76–79; brain and heart blood flow76 |
| Humans78,79 |
No78 |
Active compression-decompression device + impedance threshold device77–79 |
Neutral for neurologic recovery78 |
|||||
| Yes79 | ||||||||
| Sodium nitroprusside + active compression/decompression + impedance threshold device80–82 |
Improved organ perfusion |
Pigs |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
Intravenous |
Positive |
Survival and neurological function80; return of spontaneous circulation and carotid blood flow81,82; cerebral perfusion pressure and coronary perfusion pressure81 |
| Hypertonic saline hydroxyethyl starch83 | Improve perfusion, decrease intracranial pressure, decrease brain edema | Rats | Yes | Yes | Yes | Intravenous | Positive for cerebral blood flow during early reperfuion; neutral at late time point (7-day post-resuscitation) | Survival; cerebral blood flow; neurological function; neurohistopathology |
Superscript numbers indicate the citation number of studies reviewed.