Table 5.
Summary of available data on the incidence of adenomas in the ARS in mucosectomized, handsewn IPAA and stapled IPAA in patients surgically treated for FAP.
Incidence of Adenoma in the ARS in mucosectomized, Handsewn IPAA and Stapled IPAA in Patients operated for FAP | ||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Author | Follow-up-yrs | Number of patients followed-up in the study | Number of patients developed neoplastic transformation | IPAA with mucosectomy that developed neoplastic transformation | IRA Stapled that developed neoplastic transformation | P-value |
Van Duijvendijk et al, 199973 | Median 5.5, range1–1.7) | 126 | 13 | Handsewn with mucosectom: 6 (of 13) (46%)) vs. Double-stapled without mucosectomy: 7 of 13) (54%)) |
N/A | 0.01 |
Remzietal. 200124 | 5.8 vs. 3.6 | 119 | 44 (58%) | 9 (of 42) (21%)) in the pouch and 6 of 42 had it in mucosectomized ARS | 21 (of 76) (28%)) in ARS and 8 (11%) had adenomas in the pouch body mucosa | N/A |
Moussata et al.53 | IPAA (4.76±3.3) IRA(16.4±8.5) |
44 | 24 (55%) | 0.0001 | ||
Friederich et al. 200893 | 6.8 (range 0.4–20.3) | 212 | 74 (35%) | 29% | 64% | 0.0004 |
Von Roon et al, 200774 and 201125 | 5 (range 0.1–24.75) and 10.3 (median) | (91 and 49 =)140 | 24 (26%) and 52 (37%) | 11 (19%) Handswen vs. stapled anastomosis (19 vs. 38%) and 22.6% | 13 (38)% and 51.1% | 0.047 and 0.001 |
Pommaret et al, 201382 | Median 15 | 139 | 85 (65%) | 73 of 118 (62%) patients had adenomas in pouch mucosa, 57 (48.3%) had advanced adenomas in 15 patients (12.7%). Transformation of IRA to IPAA was done for 36 patients). In 8 cases (16.3%) to treat rectal cancer | 12 of 13 (92.3%) had rectal adenomas, including one patient with advanced rectal rectal adenoma, treated by endoscopic mucosal resection | 0.0001 |
Wasmuth et al, 201349 | 20 (range, 10–49) | 61 | 18(30%) | Mucosectomized: 4 (of 39) (10%)) vs. None-mucosectomized: 14 (of 22) (64%)) |
N/A | The estimated rates was 17% vs. 75%. 0.0001 |
Boostrom et al.65 | Median 26 (range, 4–16) | 117 | 39 (33%) | Handsewn with mucosectomy (31) (26%) vs. Stapled without mucosectomy (8) (7%) | N/A | N/A |