Skip to main content
. 2014 May 7;10:727–756. doi: 10.2147/NDT.S58405

Table S2.

A list of N=50 studies on the association between rTMS and depression assessed in full-length and reasons for exclusion from the current meta-analysis

Author, year Included/reason for exclusion
Aguirre et al,41 2011 Included (additional data provided by authors)
Avery et al,42 2007 No new data (data from Avery et al,29 2006)
Baeken et al,43 2010 Cross-over design, only one session
Bakim et al,44 2012 Included
Bares et al,45 2009 No sham (rTMS and placebo medication versus sham and venlafaxine)
Blumberger et al,46 2012 Included
Brakemeier et al,47 2007 No sham
Brakemeier et al,48 2008 No sham
Chen et al,49 2013 Included
Cohen et al,50 2009 No sham
Dell’Osso et al,51 2009 No sham
Fitzgerald et al,52 2012 Included
Furtado et al,53 2012 No sham
Galletly et al,54 2012 No sham
George et al,55 2010 Included
Hadley et al,56 2011 No sham
He et al,57 2011 Included (additional data provided by authors)
Herbsman et al,58 2009 No new data (data from Avery et al,29 2006)
Hernández-Ribas et al,59 2013 Included
Herwig et al,60 2010 No new data (data from Herwig et al,35 2007)
Höppner et al,61 2010 No new data (data from Herwig et al,35 2007)
Hoy et al,62 2012 No sham
Huang et al,63 2008 No sham
Huang et al,64 2012 Included
Jacob et al,65 2008 Inadequate data reported (SD values missing on Figure 1)
Kozel et al,66 2011 No new data (data from O’Reardon et al,37 2007)
Kreuzer et al,67 2012 rTMS after sleep deprivation
Lingeswaran et al,68 2011 Included
Lisanby et al,69 2009 No new data (data from O’Reardon et al,37 2007)
Myczkowski et al,70 2012 Depression secondary to birth (postpartum depression)
Nongpiur et al,71 2011 No sham (primed all conditions with right 1 Hz stimulation)
Paillère Martinot et al,72 2010 Included (additional data provided by authors)
Pallanti et al,73 2010 Included (week 3 data extrapolated from Figure 1)
Peng et al,74 2012 Included
Ray et al,75 2011 Included
Rosenquist et al,76 2013 No new data (data from O’Reardon et al,37 2007)
Schrijvers et al,77 2012 No sham (one single sham session followed by active treatment)
Schutter et al,78 2009 DLPFC not stimulated (parietal cortex stimulated)
Schutter et al,79 2010 No new data (data from Schutter et al,78 2009)
Simpson et al,80 2009 No new data (data from O’Reardon et al,37 2007)
Spampinato et al,81 2013 Included
Speer et al,82 2009 Inadequate data reported (baseline scores/group missing)
Speer et al,83 2013 Included
Tamas et al,84 2007 Inadequate data reported (HAMD scores missing)
Triggs et al,85 2010 Included
Trojak et al,86 2011 Case study
Ullrich et al,87 2012 No sham (sham was the active left-slow stimulation of the DLPFC)
Zarkowski et al,88 2009 No sham
Zheng et al,89 2010 No new data (same cases as in Zheng et al,90 2010)
Zheng et al,90 2010 Included

Note: A total of N=18/50 studies were included in the final meta-analysis.

Abbreviations: DLPFC, dorsolateral prefrontal cortex; HAMD, Hamilton Depression Rating Scale; rTMS, repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation; SD, standard deviation;