Table S2.
A list of N=50 studies on the association between rTMS and depression assessed in full-length and reasons for exclusion from the current meta-analysis
| Author, year | Included/reason for exclusion |
|---|---|
| Aguirre et al,41 2011 | Included (additional data provided by authors) |
| Avery et al,42 2007 | No new data (data from Avery et al,29 2006) |
| Baeken et al,43 2010 | Cross-over design, only one session |
| Bakim et al,44 2012 | Included |
| Bares et al,45 2009 | No sham (rTMS and placebo medication versus sham and venlafaxine) |
| Blumberger et al,46 2012 | Included |
| Brakemeier et al,47 2007 | No sham |
| Brakemeier et al,48 2008 | No sham |
| Chen et al,49 2013 | Included |
| Cohen et al,50 2009 | No sham |
| Dell’Osso et al,51 2009 | No sham |
| Fitzgerald et al,52 2012 | Included |
| Furtado et al,53 2012 | No sham |
| Galletly et al,54 2012 | No sham |
| George et al,55 2010 | Included |
| Hadley et al,56 2011 | No sham |
| He et al,57 2011 | Included (additional data provided by authors) |
| Herbsman et al,58 2009 | No new data (data from Avery et al,29 2006) |
| Hernández-Ribas et al,59 2013 | Included |
| Herwig et al,60 2010 | No new data (data from Herwig et al,35 2007) |
| Höppner et al,61 2010 | No new data (data from Herwig et al,35 2007) |
| Hoy et al,62 2012 | No sham |
| Huang et al,63 2008 | No sham |
| Huang et al,64 2012 | Included |
| Jacob et al,65 2008 | Inadequate data reported (SD values missing on Figure 1) |
| Kozel et al,66 2011 | No new data (data from O’Reardon et al,37 2007) |
| Kreuzer et al,67 2012 | rTMS after sleep deprivation |
| Lingeswaran et al,68 2011 | Included |
| Lisanby et al,69 2009 | No new data (data from O’Reardon et al,37 2007) |
| Myczkowski et al,70 2012 | Depression secondary to birth (postpartum depression) |
| Nongpiur et al,71 2011 | No sham (primed all conditions with right 1 Hz stimulation) |
| Paillère Martinot et al,72 2010 | Included (additional data provided by authors) |
| Pallanti et al,73 2010 | Included (week 3 data extrapolated from Figure 1) |
| Peng et al,74 2012 | Included |
| Ray et al,75 2011 | Included |
| Rosenquist et al,76 2013 | No new data (data from O’Reardon et al,37 2007) |
| Schrijvers et al,77 2012 | No sham (one single sham session followed by active treatment) |
| Schutter et al,78 2009 | DLPFC not stimulated (parietal cortex stimulated) |
| Schutter et al,79 2010 | No new data (data from Schutter et al,78 2009) |
| Simpson et al,80 2009 | No new data (data from O’Reardon et al,37 2007) |
| Spampinato et al,81 2013 | Included |
| Speer et al,82 2009 | Inadequate data reported (baseline scores/group missing) |
| Speer et al,83 2013 | Included |
| Tamas et al,84 2007 | Inadequate data reported (HAMD scores missing) |
| Triggs et al,85 2010 | Included |
| Trojak et al,86 2011 | Case study |
| Ullrich et al,87 2012 | No sham (sham was the active left-slow stimulation of the DLPFC) |
| Zarkowski et al,88 2009 | No sham |
| Zheng et al,89 2010 | No new data (same cases as in Zheng et al,90 2010) |
| Zheng et al,90 2010 | Included |
Note: A total of N=18/50 studies were included in the final meta-analysis.
Abbreviations: DLPFC, dorsolateral prefrontal cortex; HAMD, Hamilton Depression Rating Scale; rTMS, repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation; SD, standard deviation;