Table 3. Conclusions on drugs to treat depression including depressive symptomsa in PD.
Efficacy | Safety | Practice implications | |
---|---|---|---|
Dopamine agonists | |||
Pramipexole | Efficacious | Acceptable risk without specialized monitoring | Clinically useful |
Pergolide | Insufficient evidence | Acceptable risk with specialized monitoring | Not useful |
TCA | |||
Nortriptyline | Likely efficacious | Acceptable risk without specialized monitoring | Possibly useful |
Desipramine | Likely efficacious | Acceptable risk without specialized monitoring | Possibly useful |
Amitriptyline | Insufficient evidence | Acceptable risk without specialized monitoring | Investigationalb |
SSRIs | |||
Citalopram | Insufficient evidence | Acceptable risk without specialized monitoring | Investigationalb |
Sertraline | Insufficient evidence | Acceptable risk without specialized monitoring | Investigationalb |
Paroxetine | Insufficient evidence | Acceptable risk without specialized monitoring | Investigationalb |
Fluoxetine | Insufficient evidence | Acceptable risk without specialized monitoring | Investigationalb |
MAO-Inhibitors | |||
Moclobemide | Insufficient evidence | Insufficient evidencec | Investigationald |
Selegeline | Insufficient evidence | Acceptable risk without specialized monitoring | Investigational |
Newer antidepressants | |||
Atomoxetine | Insufficient evidence | Acceptable risk without specialized monitoring | Investigational |
Nefazodone | Insufficient evidence | Unacceptable risk | Not useful |
Alternative therapies | |||
Ω-3 fatty acids | Insufficient evidence | Acceptable risk without specialized monitoring | Investigational |
Nonpharmacological interventions | |||
rTMS | Insufficient evidence | Acceptable risk without specialized monitoring | Investigational |
ECT | Insufficient evidence | Insufficient evidence | Investigational |
Treatments with new conclusions have gray backgrounds and italicized text, and those with no changes have white backgrounds.
The clinical trials reviewed for the treatment of depression used varying inclusion criteria to define depression.
While the EBM review in 2002 (Goetz et al.5) referred to evidence for antidepressant efficacy in non-PD major depression as a criterion for the practical implications for clinical use also in PD, the current recommendations are based solely on evidence available from RCTs performed in PD depression.
Combined treatment with either TCAs or SSRIs carries an unacceptable risk.
Combined treatment with either TCAs or SSRIs is unacceptable.
PD, Parkinson's disease; TCA, tricyclic antidepressant; SSRI, selective serotonin reuptake inhibitor; rTMS, repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation; ECT, electroconvulsive therapy; EBM, evidence-based medicine; RCT, randomized controlled trial; MAO-I, MAO-Inhibitors.