Table 1.
Estimates for non-calibrated parameters
Variable | Input parameter estimate | Range for sensitivity analysis | Source a |
---|---|---|---|
Screening test performance | |||
Carcinoembryonic Antigen test (CEA)
| |||
Sensitivity |
.64 |
.49 - .79 |
[41] |
Specificity |
.90 |
.75 – 1.00 |
[41] |
Chest X ray
| |||
Sensitivity |
.76 |
.61 - .91 |
[39,42,43] |
Specificity |
.95 |
.80 – 1.00 |
[43] |
CT – Hepatic metastases
| |||
Sensitivity |
.83 |
.68 - .98 |
[44-47] |
Specificity |
.93 |
.78 – 1.00 |
[44,47] |
CT – Other abdominal metastases
| |||
Sensitivity |
.46 |
.31 - .61 |
[44] |
Specificity |
.98 |
.83 – 1.00 |
[44] |
Hepatic ultrasound
| |||
Sensitivity |
.62 |
.47 - .77 |
[47-49] |
Specificity |
.85 |
.70 – 1.00 |
[47-49] |
Colonoscopy
| |||
Sensitivity |
.95 |
.80 – 1.00 |
[23,50] |
Specificity |
1.00 |
.85 – 1.00 |
[23,50] |
Clinical interview/examination
b
| |||
Sensitivity |
.42 |
.27 - .57 |
[5] |
Specificity |
.95 |
.70 – 1.00 |
[5] |
Life expectancy | |||
After initial surgery, given no recurrence |
20.7 years |
--c |
[51] |
After recurrence with curative salvage |
21 months |
15 – 27 |
[52]d |
After diagnosis of unresectable recurrence | 8 months | 4 – 12 | [53]e |
aWhen multiple sources are given, the parameter used in the model was estimated based on a sample-size-weighted mean.
bIn the absence of laboratory or other diagnostic findings suggesting recurrence.
cSince the time horizon for the model was 5 years, varying this parameter over all but the most extreme low bounds would have no effect on results.
dEstimate based on incomplete reporting of survival among subjects undergoing curative salvage surgery in the Pietra study.
eBased on reported survival of 13 months following recurrence of colon cancer during the era of 1986–1992, and assumption that 1/3 of those relapsing will undergo curative salvage surgery with survival of 21 months as described above. The result is that those recurring but not undergoing curative salvage surgery would be expected to survive approximately 8 months after diagnosis of recurrence.