Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2014 May 15.
Published in final edited form as: Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2013 Oct 23;10:CD001055. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD001055.pub4

Table 2. Cluster-randomised trial adjustment details.

ICC Trial
ID
Timing Timing
code
Outcome
description
Outcome
code
Mean cluster
size
No. of
clusters
Sample
size
Ceased
smoking %
Continued
smoking %
Ceased
smoking n
Continued
smoking n
ICC Between
cluster var
IF(int) IF(comp) Effective sample size,
denominator
Effective sample size,
continue
Effective sample size,
ceased
mi mc ci cc ni nc i% c% i% c% i c i c ri rc s^2c ni nc i c OR i c OR RR
0.003
Campbell 2006 2nd or subsequent visit 0 1 71.0 62.5 11 11 781 688 10.5 6.4 89.5 93.6 82 44 699 644 0.003 0.003 1.21 1.18 645 581 578 544 0.583 68 37 1.72 1.641
Hajek 2001 Birth 0 1 5.9 6.7 92 86 545 575 22.0 20.0 78.0 80.0 120 115 425.1 460 0.003 0.003 1.01 1.017 537.1 565.4 419 452.3 0.886 118 113 1.13 1.1
Haug 1994 0 1 2 2 125 62 252 98 18.25 8.16 81.75 91.84 46 8 206 90 0.003 0.003 1.00 1.00 251 98 205 90 0.398 46 8 2.51 2.237
Kendrick 1995 36/40 gest 0 1 27.8 36.8 32 32 888 1177 5.9 6.1 94.1 93.9 52 72 835.6 1105 0.003 0.003 1.08 1.11 822 1063 774 998 1.036 48 65 0.97 0.967
Lawrence 2003 30 wk gest 0 1 17 8 23 41 324 289 5.6 1.73 94.44 98.27 18 5 306 284 0.003 0.003 1.05 1.02 309 283 292 278 0.299 17 5 3.34 3.211
Lillington 1995 late preg 0 1 39.5 73.0 2 2 79 146 43.04 24.66 56.96 75.34 34 36 45 110 0.003 0.003 1.12 1.22 71 120 40 90 0.433 30 30 2.31 1.745
McLeod 2004 36/40 gest 0 1 6.273 4.615 11 13 69 60 20.3 13.3 79.71 86.67 14 8 55 52 1.096 1.100 63 55 50 47 0.604 13 7 1.65
McLeod 2004 36/40 gest 0 1 9 7.5 12 8 108 60 17.6 10.0 82.41 90 19 6 89 54 1.075 1.100 100 55 83 49 0.52 18 5 1.92
McLeod 2004 36/40 gest 0 1 7.696 5.714 23 21 177 120 18.6 11.7 81.36 88.33 33 14 144 106 * 1.10 163 109 133 96 0.577 30 13 1.73
Messimer 1989 32-36 weeks' gest 0 1 10.91 10.36 5.5 5.5 60 57 25.0 14.0 75 85.96 15 8 45 49 0.003 0.003 1.03 1.03 58 55 44 48 0.49 15 8 2.04 1.781
Moore 2002 24-28/40 gest 0 1 10.59 11.83 64 64 678 757 16.7 19.0 83.33 80.98 113 144 565 613 0.031 0.031 1.30 1.34 523 567 435 459 1.175 87 108 0.85 0.876
Pbert 2004 36/40 gest 0 1 63.67 100.5 3 2 191 201 20.0 11.0 80.0 89.0 38 22 152.8 178.9 0.003 0.003 1.19 1.30 161 155 129 138 0.493 32 17 2.03 1.822
0.05
Campbell 2006 2nd or subsequent visit 0 1 71.0 62.5 11 11 781 688 10.5 6.4 89.5 93.6 82 44 699 644 0.050 0.050 4.50 4.08 174 169 155 158 0.583 18 11 1.72 1.641
Hajek 2001 Birth 0 1 5.9 6.7 92 86 545 575 22.0 20.0 78.0 80.0 120 115 425.1 460 0.050 0.050 1.25 1.284 437.3 447.7 341 358.2 0.886 96 90 1.13 1.1
Haug 1994 0 1 2 2 125 62 252 98 18.25 8.16 81.75 91.84 46 8 206 90 0.050 0.050 1.05 1.03 240 95 196 87 0.398 44 8 2.51 2.237
Kendrick 1995 36/40 gest 0 1 27.8 36.8 32 32 888 1177 5.9 6.1 94.1 93.9 52 72 835.6 1105 0.003 0.003 1.08 1.11 822 1063 774 998 1.036 48 65 0.97 0.967
Lawrence 2003 30 wk gest 0 1 17 8 23 41 324 289 5.6 1.73 94.44 98.27 18 5 306 284 0.003 0.003 1.05 1.02 309 283 292 278 0.299 17 5 3.34 3.211
Lillington 1995 late preg 0 1 39.5 73.0 2 2 79 146 43.04 24.66 56.96 75.34 34 36 45 110 0.050 0.050 2.93 4.60 27 32 15 24 0.433 12 8 2.31 1.745
McLeod 2004 36/40 gest 0 1 6.273 4.615 11 13 69 60 20.3 13.3 79.71 86.67 14 8 55 52 1.096 1.100 63 55 50 47 0.604 13 7 1.65
McLeod 2004 36/40 gest 0 1 9 7.5 12 8 108 60 17.6 10.0 82.41 90 19 6 89 54 1.075 1.100 100 55 83 49 0.52 18 5 1.92
McLeod 2004 36/40 gest 0 1 7.696 5.714 23 21 177 120 18.6 11.7 81.36 88.33 33 14 144 106 * 1.10 163 109 133 96 0.577 30 13 1.73
Messimer 1989 32-36 weeks' gest 0 1 10.91 10.36 5.5 5.5 60 57 25.0 14.0 75 85.96 15 8 45 49 0.050 0.050 1.50 1.47 40 39 30 33 0.49 10 5 2.04 1.781
Moore 2002 24-28/40 gest 0 1 11 12 64 64 678 757 16.7 19.0 83.33 80.98 113 144 565 613 0.031 0.031 1.30 1.34 523 567 435 459 1.175 87 108 0.85 0.876
36/40 gest 0 1 64 101 3 2 191 201 20.0 11.0 80.0 89.0 38 22 152.8 178.9 0.050 0.050 4.13 5.98 46 34 37 30 0.493 9 4 2.03 1.822
0.1
Campbell 2006 2nd or subsequent visit 0 1 71 63 11 11 781 688 10.5 6.4 89.5 93.6 82 44 699 644 0.100 0.100 8.00 7.15 98 96 87 90 0.583 10 6 1.72 1.641
Hajek 2001 Birth 0 1 6 7 92 86 545 575 22.0 20.0 78.0 80.0 120 115 425.1 460 0.100 0.100 1.49 1.569 365.2 366.6 285 293.3 0.886 80 73 1.13 1.1
Haug 1994 0 1 2 2 125 62 252 98 18.25 8.16 81.75 91.84 46 8 206 90 0.100 0.100 1.10 1.06 229 93 187 85 0.398 42 8 2.51 2.237
Kendrick 1995 36/40 gest 0 1 28 37 32 32 888 1177 5.9 6.1 94.1 93.9 52 72 835.6 1105 0.003 0.003 1.08 1.11 822 1063 774 998 1.036 48 65 0.97 0.967
Lawrence 2003 30 wk gest 0 1 17 8 23 41 324 289 5.6 1.73 94.44 98.27 18 5 306 284 0.003 0.003 1.05 1.02 309 283 292 278 0.299 17 5 3.34 3.211
Lillington 1995 late preg 0 1 39.5 73.0 2 2 79 146 43.04 24.66 56.96 75.34 34 36 45 110 0.100 0.100 4.85 8.20 16 18 9 13 0.433 7 4 2.31 1.745
McLeod 2004 36/40 gest 0 1 6.273 4.615 11 13 69 60 20.3 13.3 79.71 86.67 14 8 55 52 1.096 1.100 63 55 50 47 0.604 13 7 1.65
McLeod 2004 36/40 gest 0 1 9 7.5 12 8 108 60 17.6 10.0 82.41 90 19 6 89 54 1.075 1.100 100 55 83 49 0.52 18 5 1.92
McLeod 2004 36/40 gest 0 1 7.696 5.714 23 21 177 120 18.6 11.7 81.36 88.33 33 14 144 106 * 1.10 163 109 133 96 0.577 30 13 1.73
Messimer 1989 32-36 weeks' gest 0 1 10.91 10.36 5.5 5.5 60 57 25.0 14.0 75 85.96 15 8 45 49 0.100 0.100 1.99 1.94 30 29 23 25 0.49 8 4 2.04 1.781
Moore 2002 24-28/40 gest 0 1 11 12 64 64 678 757 16.7 19.0 83.33 80.98 113 144 565 613 0.031 0.031 1.30 1.34 523 567 435 459 1.175 87 108 0.85 0.876
Pbert 2004 36/40 gest 0 1 64 101 3 2 191 201 20.0 11.0 80.0 89.0 38 22 152.8 178.9 0.100 0.100 7.27 10.95 26 18 21 16 0.493 5 2 2.03 1.822
0.2
Campbell 2006 2nd or subsequent visit 0 1 71 63 11 11 781 688 10.5 6.4 89.5 93.6 82 44 699 644 0.200 0.200 15.00 13.31 52 52 47 48 0.583 5 3 1.72 1.641
Hajek 2001 Birth 0 1 6 7 92 86 545 575 22.0 20.0 78.0 80.0 120 115 425.1 460 0.200 0.200 1.98 2.137 275 269 214 215 0.886 60 54 1.13 1.1
Haug 1994 0 1 2 2 125 62 252 98 18.25 8.16 81.75 91.84 46 8 206 90 0.200 0.200 1.20 1.12 210 88 172 81 0.398 38 7 2.51 2.237
Kendrick 1995 36/40 gest 0 1 28 37 32 32 888 1177 5.9 6.1 94.1 93.9 52 72 835.6 1105 0.003 0.003 1.08 1.11 822 1063 774 998 1.036 48 65 0.97 0.967
Lawrence 2003 30 wk gest 0 1 17 8 23 41 324 289 5.6 1.73 94.44 98.27 18 5 306 284 0.003 0.003 1.05 1.02 309 283 292 278 0.299 17 5 3.34 3.211
Lillington 1995 late preg 0 1 39.5 73.0 2 2 79 146 43.04 24.66 56.96 75.34 34 36 45 110 0.200 0.200 8.70 15.40 9 9 5 7 0.433 4 2 2.31 1.745
McLeod 2004 36/40 gest 0 1 6.273 4.615 11 13 69 60 20.3 13.3 79.71 86.67 14 8 55 52 1.096 1.100 63 55 50 47 0.604 13 7 1.65
McLeod 2004 36/40 gest 0 1 9 7.5 12 8 108 60 17.6 10.0 82.41 90 19 6 89 54 1.075 1.100 100 55 83 49 0.52 18 5 1.92
McLeod 2004 36/40 gest 0 1 7.696 5.714 23 21 177 120 18.6 11.7 81.36 88.33 33 14 144 106 * 1.10 163 109 133 96 0.577 30 13 1.73
Messimer 1989 32-36 weeks' gest 0 1 10.91 10.36 5.5 5.5 60 57 25.0 14.0 75 85.96 15 8 45 49 0.200 0.200 2.98 2.87 20 20 15 17 0.49 5 3 2.04 1.781
Moore 2002 24-28/40 gest 0 1 11 12 64 64 678 757 16.7 19.0 83.33 80.98 113 144 565 613 0.031 0.031 1.30 1.34 523 567 435 459 1.175 87 108 0.85 0.876
Pbert 2004 36/40 gest 0 1 64 101 3 2 191 201 20.0 11.0 80.0 89.0 38 22 152.8 178.9 0.200 0.200 13.53 20.90 14 10 11 9 0.493 3 1 2.03 1.822
Key: Outcome Data given Sensitivity
analysis
From formula in Merlo * wt'd ave of IF in 2 intv arms
ADDITIONAL OUTCOMES found 21/11/08
Eades 2012 late preg 0 continued smoking for spontaneous quitters in late pregnancy 2 24 8 14 6
Hajek 2001 late preg 0 2 1.2 1.6 92 86 114 135 22.0 20.0 64.9 53.3 40 63 74 72 0.003 0.003 1.00 1.002 113.9 134.8 74 71.88 1.619 40 63 0.62 0.752
Lillington 1995 late preg 0 2 38 127.0 2 2 76 254 5.263 10.63 94.74 89.37 4 27 72 227 0.003 0.003 1.11 1.38 68 184 65 165 2.141 4 20 0.47 0.495
Pbert 2004 late preg 0 2 27 39 3 2 81 77 70.4 77.9 29.6 22.1 57 60 24 17 0.003 0.003 1.08 1.11 75 69 22 15 1.486 53 54 0.67 0.903
Polanska 2004 late preg 0 2 5.6 7.4 10 5 56 37 100 100 0 0 56 37 0 0 0.003 0.003 1.01 1.02 55 36 0 0 ##### 55 36 #DIV/0! 1
Haug 1994 0-5 mo pp 1 maintained cessation at 0-5 mo pp 1 2 2 125 62 252 98 18.25 8.16 81.75 91.84 46 8 206 90 0.003 0.003 1.00 1.00 251 98 205 90 0.398 46 8 2.51 2.237
Lawrence 2003 10 days pp 1 10 days pp 1 17 8 23 41 324 289 8.0 3.5 92.0 96.5 26 10 298 279 0.003 0.003 1.05 1.02 309 283 284 273 0.411 25 10 2.43
Lillington 1995 0-5 mo pp 1 maintained cessation at 0-5 mo pp 1 39.5 73.0 2 2 79 146 25.32 11.64 74.68 88.36 20 17 59 129 0.003 0.003 1.12 1.22 71 120 53 106 0.389 18 14 2.57 2.174
McLeod 2004 4/12pp 1 1 8 6 23 21 177 120 15.8 10.8 84.2 89.2 28 13 149 107 0.003 0.003 1.02 1.01 174 118 146 106 0.647 27 13 1.55
Messimer 1989 0-5 mo pp 1 1 10.91 10.36 5.5 5.5 60 57 8.3 10.5 91.67 89.47 5 6 55 51 0.003 0.003 1.03 1.03 58 55 53 50 1.294 5 6 0.77 0.792
Pbert 2004 0-5 mo pp 1 1 64 101 3 2 191 201 4.2 3.0 95.8 97.0 8 6 183 195 0.003 0.003 1.19 1.30 161 155 154 150 0.704 7 5 1.42 1.403
Polanska 2004 0-5 mo pp 1 1 14.9 28.8 10 5 149 144 44.3 16.7 55.7 83.3 66 24 82.99 120 0.003 0.003 1.04 1.08 143 133 80 111 0.252 63 22 3.97 2.653
Hajek 2001 6 mo pp 2 maintained cessation at 6-11 mo pp 1 4.7 5.1 92 86 431 440 22.0 20.0 97.0 97.0 13 13 418 427 0.003 0.003 1.01 1.012 426.3 434.6 413 421.8 0.979 13 13 1.02 1.021
Haug 1994 6-11 mo pp 2 1 2 2 125 62 252 98 18.25 8.16 84.52 88.78 39 11 213 87 0.003 0.003 1.00 1.00 251 98 212 87 0.691 39 11 1.45 1.379
Pbert 2004 6-11 mo pp 2 1 64 101 3 2 191 201 4.7 2.5 95.3 97.5 9 5 182 196 0.003 0.003 1.19 1.30 161 155 153 151 0.516 8 4 1.94 1.894
Haug 1994 12-17 mo pp 3 maintained cessation at 12-17 mo pp 1 2 2 125 62 252 98 18.25 8.16 85.32 92.86 37 7 215 91 0.003 0.003 1.00 1.00 251 98 214 91 0.447 37 7 2.24 2.056
Polanska 2004 12-17 mo pp 3 1 20.5 36.2 10 5 205 181 31.7 12.7 68.29 87.29 65 23 140 158 0.003 0.003 1.06 1.11 194 164 132 143 0.314 61 21 3.19 2.495
Lawrence 2003 18 mo pp 4 18 mo pp 1 17 8 23 41 324 289 4.6 2.4 95.4 97.6 15 7 309 282 0.003 0.003 1.05 1.02 309 283 295 276 0.511 14 7 1.96
0.05
Eades 2012 late preg 0 continued smoking for spontaneous quitters in late pregnancy 2 24 8 14 6
Hajek 2001 late preg 0 2 1.2 1.6 92 86 114 135 22.0 20.0 64.9 53.3 40 63 74 72 0.050 0.050 1.01 1.028 112.7 131.3 73 70.01 1.619 40 61 0.62 0.752
Lillington 1995 late preg 0 2 38 127.0 2 2 76 254 5.263 10.63 94.74 89.37 4 27 72 227 0.050 0.050 2.85 7.30 27 35 25 31 2.141 1 4 0.47 0.495
Pbert 2004 late preg 0 2 27 39 3 2 81 77 70.4 77.9 29.6 22.1 57 60 24 17 0.050 0.050 2.30 2.88 35 27 10 6 1.486 25 21 0.67 0.903
Polanska 2004 late preg 0 2 5.6 7.4 10 5 56 37 100 100 0 0 56 37 0 0 0.050 0.050 1.23 1.32 46 28 0 0 ##### 46 28 #DIV/0! 1
Haug 1994 0-5 mo pp 1 maintained cessation at 0-5 mo pp 1 2 2 125 62 252 98 18.25 8.16 81.75 91.84 46 8 206 90 0.050 0.050 1.05 1.03 240 95 196 87 0.398 44 8 2.51 2.237
Lawrence 2003 10 days pp 1 10 days pp 1 17 8 23 41 324 289 8.0 3.5 92.0 96.5 26 10 298 279 0.003 0.003 1.05 1.02 309 283 284 273 0.411 25 10 2.43
Lillington 1995 0-5 mo pp 1 maintained cessation at 0-5 mo pp 1 39.5 73.0 2 2 79 146 25.32 11.64 74.68 88.36 20 17 59 129 0.050 0.050 2.93 4.60 27 32 20 28 0.389 7 4 2.57 2.174
McLeod 2004 4/12pp 1 1 8 6 23 21 177 120 15.8 10.8 84.2 89.2 28 13 149 107 0.050 0.050 1.33 1.24 133 97 112 87 0.647 21 11 1.55
Messimer 1989 0-5 mo pp 1 1 10.91 10.36 5.5 5.5 60 57 8.3 10.5 91.67 89.47 5 6 55 51 0.050 0.050 1.50 1.47 40 39 37 35 1.294 3 4 0.77 0.792
Pbert 2004 0-5 mo pp 1 1 64 101 3 2 191 201 4.2 3.0 95.8 97.0 8 6 183 195 0.050 0.050 4.13 5.98 46 34 44 33 0.704 2 1 1.42 1.403
Polanska 2004 0-5 mo pp 1 1 15 29 10 5 149 144 44.3 16.7 55.7 83.3 66 24 82.99 120 0.050 0.050 1.70 2.39 88 60 49 50 0.252 39 10 3.97 2.653
Hajek 2001 6 mo pp 2 maintained cessation at 6-11 mo pp 1 4.7 5.1 92 86 431 440 22.0 20.0 97.0 97.0 13 13 418 427 0.050 0.050 1.18 1.206 363.9 364.9 353 354.1 0.979 11 11 1.02 1.021
Haug 1994 6-11 mo pp 2 1 2 2 125 62 252 98 18.25 8.16 84.52 88.78 39 11 213 87 0.050 0.050 1.05 1.03 240 95 203 85 0.691 37 11 1.45 1.379
Pbert 2004 6-11 mo pp 2 1 64 101 3 2 191 201 4.7 2.5 95.3 97.5 9 5 182 196 0.050 0.050 4.13 5.98 46 34 44 33 0.516 2 1 1.94 1.894
Haug 1994 12-17 mo pp 3 maintained cessation at 12-17 mo pp 1 2 2 125 62 252 98 18.25 8.16 85.32 92.86 37 7 215 91 0.050 0.050 1.05 1.03 240 95 205 88 0.447 35 7 2.24 2.056
Polanska 2004 12-17 mo pp 3 1 20.5 36.2 10 5 205 181 31.7 12.7 68.29 87.29 65 23 140 158 0.050 0.050 1.98 2.76 104 66 71 57 0.314 33 8 3.19 2.495
Lawrence 2003 18 mo pp 4 18 mo pp 1 17 8 23 41 324 289 4.6 2.4 95.4 97.6 15 7 309 282 0.003 0.003 1.05 1.02 309 283 295 276 0.511 14 7 1.96
0.1
Eades 2012 late preg 0 continued smoking for spontaneous quitters in late pregnancy 2 24 8 14 6
Hajek 2001 late preg 0 2 1.2 1.6 92 86 114 135 22.0 20.0 64.9 53.3 40 63 74 72 0.100 0.100 1.02 1.057 111.3 127.7 72 68.12 1.619 39 60 0.62 0.752
Lillington 1995 late preg 0 2 38 127.0 2 2 76 254 5.263 10.63 94.74 89.37 4 27 72 227 0.100 0.100 4.70 13.60 16 19 15 17 2.141 1 2 0.47 0.495
Pbert 2004 late preg 0 2 27 39 3 2 81 77 70.4 77.9 29.6 22.1 57 60 24 17 0.100 0.100 3.60 4.75 23 16 7 4 1.486 16 13 0.67 0.903
Polanska 2004 late preg 0 2 5.6 7.4 10 5 56 37 100 100 0 0 56 37 0 0 0.100 0.100 1.46 1.64 38 23 0 0 ##### 38 23 #DIV/0! 1
Haug 1994 0-5 mo pp 1 maintained cessation at 0-5 mo pp 1 2 2 125 62 252 98 18.25 8.16 81.75 91.84 46 8 206 90 0.100 0.100 1.10 1.06 229 93 187 85 0.398 42 8 2.51 2.237
Lawrence 2003 10 days pp 1 10 days pp 1 17 8 23 41 324 289 8.0 3.5 92.0 96.5 26 10 298 279 0.003 0.003 1.05 1.02 309 283 284 273 0.411 25 10 2.43
Lillington 1995 0-5 mo pp 1 maintained cessation at 0-5 mo pp 1 39.5 73.0 2 2 79 146 25.32 11.64 74.68 88.36 20 17 59 129 0.100 0.100 4.85 8.20 16 18 12 16 0.389 4 2 2.57 2.174
McLeod 2004 4/12pp 1 1 8 6 23 21 177 120 15.8 10.8 84.2 89.2 28 13 149 107 0.100 0.100 1.67 1.47 106 82 89 73 0.647 17 9 1.55
Messimer 1989 0-5 mo pp 1 1 10.91 10.36 5.5 5.5 60 57 8.3 10.5 91.67 89.47 5 6 55 51 0.100 0.100 1.99 1.94 30 29 28 26 1.294 3 3 0.77 0.792
Pbert 2004 0-5 mo pp 1 1 64 101 3 2 191 201 4.2 3.0 95.8 97.0 8 6 183 195 0.100 0.100 7.27 10.95 26 18 25 18 0.704 1 1 1.42 1.403
Polanska 2004 0-5 mo pp 1 1 15 29 10 5 149 144 44.3 16.7 55.7 83.3 66 24 82.99 120 0.100 0.100 2.39 3.78 62 38 35 32 0.252 28 6 3.97 2.653
Hajek 2001 6 mo pp 2 maintained cessation at 6-11 mo pp 1 4.7 5.1 92 86 431 440 22.0 20.0 97.0 97.0 13 13 418 427 0.100 0.100 1.37 1.412 314.9 311.7 305 302.5 0.979 9 9 1.02 1.021
Haug 1994 6-11 mo pp 2 1 2 2 125 62 252 98 18.25 8.16 84.52 88.78 39 11 213 87 0.100 0.100 1.10 1.06 229 93 194 82 0.691 35 10 1.45 1.379
Pbert 2004 6-11 mo pp 2 1 64 101 3 2 191 201 4.7 2.5 95.3 97.5 9 5 182 196 0.100 0.100 7.27 10.95 26 18 25 18 0.516 1 0 1.94 1.894
Haug 1994 12-17 mo pp 3 maintained cessation at 12-17 mo pp 1 2 2 125 62 252 98 18.25 8.16 85.32 92.86 37 7 215 91 0.100 0.100 1.10 1.06 229 93 195 86 0.447 34 7 2.24 2.056
Polanska 2004 12-17 mo pp 3 1 20.5 36.2 10 5 205 181 31.7 12.7 68.29 87.29 65 23 140 158 0.100 0.100 2.95 4.52 69 40 47 35 0.314 22 5 3.19 2.495
Lawrence 2003 18 mo pp 4 18 mo pp 1 17 8 23 41 324 289 4.6 2.4 95.4 97.6 15 7 309 282 0.003 0.003 1.05 1.02 309 283 295 276 0.511 14 7 1.96
0.2
Eades 2012 late preg 0 continued smoking for spontaneous quitters in late pregnancy 2 24 8 14 6
Hajek 2001 late preg 0 2 1.2 1.6 92 86 114 135 22.0 20.0 64.9 53.3 40 63 74 72 0.200 0.200 1.05 1.114 108.8 121.2 71 64.63 1.619 38 57 0.62 0.752
Lillington 1995 late preg 0 2 38 127.0 2 2 76 254 5.263 10.63 94.74 89.37 4 27 72 227 0.200 0.200 8.40 26.20 9 10 9 9 2.141 0 1 0.47 0.495
Pbert 2004 late preg 0 2 27 39 3 2 81 77 70.4 77.9 29.6 22.1 57 60 24 17 0.200 0.200 6.20 8.50 13 9 4 2 1.486 9 7 0.67 0.903
Polanska 2004 late preg 0 2 5.6 7.4 10 5 56 37 100 100 0 0 56 37 0 0 0.200 0.200 1.92 2.28 29 16 0 0 ##### 29 16 #DIV/0! 1
Haug 1994 0-5 mo pp 1 maintained cessation at 0-5 mo pp 1 2 2 125 62 252 98 18.25 8.16 81.75 91.84 46 8 206 90 0.200 0.200 1.20 1.12 210 88 172 81 0.398 38 7 2.51 2.237
Lawrence 2003 10 days pp 1 10 days pp 1 17 8 23 41 324 289 8.0 3.5 92.0 96.5 26 10 298 279 0.003 0.003 1.05 1.02 309 283 284 273 0.411 25 10 2.43
Lillington 1995 0-5 mo pp 1 maintained cessation at 0-5 mo pp 1 39.5 73.0 2 2 79 146 25.32 11.64 74.68 88.36 20 17 59 129 0.200 0.200 8.70 15.40 9 9 7 8 0.389 2 1 2.57 2.174
McLeod 2004 4/12pp 1 1 8 6 23 21 177 120 15.8 10.8 84.2 89.2 28 13 149 107 0.200 0.200 2.34 1.94 76 62 64 55 0.647 12 7 1.55
Messimer 1989 0-5 mo pp 1 1 10.91 10.36 5.5 5.5 60 57 8.3 10.5 91.67 89.47 5 6 55 51 0.200 0.200 2.98 2.87 20 20 18 18 1.294 2 2 0.77 0.792
Pbert 2004 0-5 mo pp 1 1 64 101 3 2 191 201 4.2 3.0 95.8 97.0 8 6 183 195 0.200 0.200 13.53 20.90 14 10 14 9 0.704 1 0 1.42 1.403
Polanska 2004 0-5 mo pp 1 1 15 29 10 5 149 144 44.3 16.7 55.7 83.3 66 24 82.99 120 0.200 0.200 3.78 6.56 39 22 22 18 0.252 17 4 3.97 2.653
Hajek 2001 6 mo pp 2 maintained cessation at 6-11 mo pp 1 4.7 5.1 92 86 431 440 22.0 20.0 97.0 97.0 13 13 418 427 0.200 0.200 1.74 1.823 248.1 241.3 241 234.2 0.979 7 7 1.02 1.021
Haug 1994 6-11 mo pp 2 1 2 2 125 62 252 98 18.25 8.16 84.52 88.78 39 11 213 87 0.200 0.200 1.20 1.12 210 88 178 78 0.691 33 10 1.45 1.379
Pbert 2004 6-11 mo pp 2 1 64 101 3 2 191 201 4.7 2.5 95.3 97.5 9 5 182 196 0.200 0.200 13.53 20.90 14 10 13 9 0.516 1 0 1.94 1.894
Haug 1994 12-17 mo pp 3 maintained cessation at 12-17 mo pp 1 2 2 125 62 252 98 18.25 8.16 85.32 92.86 37 7 215 91 0.200 0.200 1.20 1.12 210 88 179 82 0.447 31 6 2.24 2.056
Polanska 2004 12-17 mo pp 3 1 20.5 36.2 10 5 205 181 31.7 12.7 68.29 87.29 65 23 140 158 0.200 0.200 4.90 8.04 42 23 29 20 0.314 13 3 3.19 2.495
Lawrence 2003 18 mo pp 4 18 mo pp 1 17 8 23 41 324 289 4.6 2.4 95.4 97.6 15 7 309 282 0.003 0.003 1.05 1.02 309 283 295 276 0.511 14 7 1.96
Key: Outcome Data given Sensitivity
analysis
From formula in Merlo

Timing codes:

0. Late pregnancy

1. 0-5 mo pp

2. 6-11 mo pp

3. 12-17 mo pp

4. 18 mo pp

Outcome codes:

1. abstinence

2. relapse prevention for spontaneous quitters