Skip to main content
. 2014 Apr 22;14(4):7181–7208. doi: 10.3390/s140407181

Table 2.

Comparison of smartphone-only fall detection and prevention systems.

Year Article Objective SP Position Sensor(s) Algorithm(s) Alerting Feature(s)
2009 [34] Detection Any Accelerometer TBA (Adaptive: depends on user provided parameters) SMS (time, GPS coordinates, password for activating bidirectional voice call).
[70] Detection Trouser Pocket Accelerometer TBA (Fixed) SMS, voice call, vibration, sound.
2010 [28] Detection Chest, Waist, Thigh Accelerometer & gyroscope TBA (Fixed) Sound alarm, voice call.
[2] Detection Trouser Pocket Accelerometer Discrete Wavelet Transform (DWT) SMS (GPS coordinates), email (Google Map), twitter messages.
[56] Detection Chest, Waist, Thigh Accelerometer TBA (Fixed) Audible alarm, voice call.
[37] Detection Waist Accelerometer C4.5 DT, NB and SVM SMS
2011 [9] Detection Waist Accelerometer TBA (Fixed) E-mail and/or SMS.
[44] Detection Waist Accelerometer TBA (Fixed) SMS (date, time, location)
[71] Detection Pocket Accelerometer TBA (Fixed) SMS (name, time, GPS coordinates, street address)
[72] Detection Hand, Shirt or Trouser Pocket Accelerometer & gyroscope TBA (Fixed), One-Class SVM Not found
[45] Detection Not found Accelerometer TBA (Fixed) Audible alarm, SMS (GPS coordinates), voice call (manual), remote server draws help path
[73] Detection Shirt Pocket Accelerometer TBA (Fixed) SMS
2012 [26] Detection Waist Accelerometer TBA (Fixed) SMS (time, GPS data), draw help path
[27] Detection Waist Accelerometer TBA (Fixed), Median filter attenuate noise MMS (time, map of suspected fall location, and GPS coordinate)
[31] Detection Waist Accelerometer TBA (Fixed), ANN 1 based pattern classifier Notification contains GPS coordinates.
[54] uFall for Detection, uTUG for Prevention Waist Accelerometer, Gyroscope TBA (Fixed) E-mail or SMS, recorded signals are sent to remote server, audio cue (for uTUG)
2012 [74] Prevention (GUG) Waist Accelerometer Segmentation, filtering, dispersion measures calculation Not found
[75] Detection Waist (Back) Accelerometer SVM, SMLR 2 in SP, NB, DT, KNN 3 in PC Not found
[76] Detection Shirt or Trouser Pocket Accelerometer TBA (Considers axis wise data separately) Not found
[77] Detection Shirt Pocket Accelerometer TBA (Adaptive) Not found
[78] Detection Shirt Pocket Accelerometer TBA (Adaptive) Text message
[79] Detection Waist Accelerometer TBA (Fixed), Median Filter, MMS (time, GPS coordinate, Google map)
[80] Detection Trouser Pocket Accelerometer SVM classifier Vibration, sound alarm, SMS (time, location, & health information)
[64] Detection Waist Accelerometer, Wi-Fi module DT Classifier, location estimation using RSSI 4 SMS (name, time, location)
[81] Detection Hand, Pocket, waist Accelerometer, Gyroscope Semi-supervised learning Not found
[82] Detection Not found Accelerometer, Gyroscope Not found SMS (location),
[83] Detection Chest, Waist, Thigh Accelerometer TBA (Adjusted based on user's profile) SMS
[84] Detection Hand, Pocket Accelerometer, Gyroscope TBA (Fixed) Not found
2013 [57] Detection Trouser Pocket Accelerometer TBA (Fixed) SMS (date, time, GPS data), voice call, vibration, sound.
[8] Detection Chest Accelerometer, Gyroscope, & Magnetometer Fisher's discriminant ratio and J3 criterion MMS (time, map of suspected fall location, GPS coordinate)
[22] Prevention Trouser Pocket Accelerometer & Gyroscope C4.5 DT classifier, Hjorth mobility and complexity [42] Alert the user about imminent fall by using message & vibration.
[33] Detection Waist Accelerometer TBA (Fixed) SMS, voice call, others: twitter, email, Facebook.
[55] Detection Not found Accelerometer TBA (Fixed) SP trigger PC via Wi-Fi, PC send alert via SMS, emails or/and voice calls
[58] Detection Waist Accelerometer TBA (Fixed) SMS (time, GPS data), draw help path
[85] Detection Not found Accelerometer TBA (Fixed) Not found
[86] Detection (User's height 164 cm) Accelerometer TBA (Fixed) Server displays current states and triggers an alarm
[87] Detection Trouser Pocket Accelerometer OneRAttributeEval, ReliefFAttributeEval SVMAttributeEval, K* [88], C4.5, NB SMS (GPS coordinate)
[89] Detection (Free Fall) Not found Accelerometer Displacement based algorithms SMS (GPS coordinate)
[90] Detection Waist Accelerometer TBA (Fixed) SMS
1.

Artificial Neural Network;

2.

Sparse Multinomial Logistic Regression (SMLR);

3.

k-Nearest Neighbours (KNN);

4.

Received Signal Strength Indication.