Table 2.
Comparison of smartphone-only fall detection and prevention systems.
Year | Article | Objective | SP Position | Sensor(s) | Algorithm(s) | Alerting Feature(s) |
2009 | [34] | Detection | Any | Accelerometer | TBA (Adaptive: depends on user provided parameters) | SMS (time, GPS coordinates, password for activating bidirectional voice call). |
[70] | Detection | Trouser Pocket | Accelerometer | TBA (Fixed) | SMS, voice call, vibration, sound. | |
2010 | [28] | Detection | Chest, Waist, Thigh | Accelerometer & gyroscope | TBA (Fixed) | Sound alarm, voice call. |
[2] | Detection | Trouser Pocket | Accelerometer | Discrete Wavelet Transform (DWT) | SMS (GPS coordinates), email (Google Map), twitter messages. | |
[56] | Detection | Chest, Waist, Thigh | Accelerometer | TBA (Fixed) | Audible alarm, voice call. | |
[37] | Detection | Waist | Accelerometer | C4.5 DT, NB and SVM | SMS | |
2011 | [9] | Detection | Waist | Accelerometer | TBA (Fixed) | E-mail and/or SMS. |
[44] | Detection | Waist | Accelerometer | TBA (Fixed) | SMS (date, time, location) | |
[71] | Detection | Accelerometer | TBA (Fixed) | SMS (name, time, GPS coordinates, street address) | ||
[72] | Detection | Hand, Shirt or Trouser Pocket | Accelerometer & gyroscope | TBA (Fixed), One-Class SVM | Not found | |
[45] | Detection | Not found | Accelerometer | TBA (Fixed) | Audible alarm, SMS (GPS coordinates), voice call (manual), remote server draws help path | |
[73] | Detection | Shirt Pocket | Accelerometer | TBA (Fixed) | SMS | |
2012 | [26] | Detection | Waist | Accelerometer | TBA (Fixed) | SMS (time, GPS data), draw help path |
[27] | Detection | Waist | Accelerometer | TBA (Fixed), Median filter attenuate noise | MMS (time, map of suspected fall location, and GPS coordinate) | |
[31] | Detection | Waist | Accelerometer | TBA (Fixed), ANN 1 based pattern classifier | Notification contains GPS coordinates. | |
[54] | uFall for Detection, uTUG for Prevention | Waist | Accelerometer, Gyroscope | TBA (Fixed) | E-mail or SMS, recorded signals are sent to remote server, audio cue (for uTUG) | |
2012 | [74] | Prevention (GUG) | Waist | Accelerometer | Segmentation, filtering, dispersion measures calculation | Not found |
[75] | Detection | Waist (Back) | Accelerometer | SVM, SMLR 2 in SP, NB, DT, KNN 3 in PC | Not found | |
[76] | Detection | Shirt or Trouser Pocket | Accelerometer | TBA (Considers axis wise data separately) | Not found | |
[77] | Detection | Shirt Pocket | Accelerometer | TBA (Adaptive) | Not found | |
[78] | Detection | Shirt Pocket | Accelerometer | TBA (Adaptive) | Text message | |
[79] | Detection | Waist | Accelerometer | TBA (Fixed), Median Filter, | MMS (time, GPS coordinate, Google map) | |
[80] | Detection | Trouser Pocket | Accelerometer | SVM classifier | Vibration, sound alarm, SMS (time, location, & health information) | |
[64] | Detection | Waist | Accelerometer, Wi-Fi module | DT Classifier, location estimation using RSSI 4 | SMS (name, time, location) | |
[81] | Detection | Hand, Pocket, waist | Accelerometer, Gyroscope | Semi-supervised learning | Not found | |
[82] | Detection | Not found | Accelerometer, Gyroscope | Not found | SMS (location), | |
[83] | Detection | Chest, Waist, Thigh | Accelerometer | TBA (Adjusted based on user's profile) | SMS | |
[84] | Detection | Hand, Pocket | Accelerometer, Gyroscope | TBA (Fixed) | Not found | |
2013 | [57] | Detection | Trouser Pocket | Accelerometer | TBA (Fixed) | SMS (date, time, GPS data), voice call, vibration, sound. |
[8] | Detection | Chest | Accelerometer, Gyroscope, & Magnetometer | Fisher's discriminant ratio and J3 criterion | MMS (time, map of suspected fall location, GPS coordinate) | |
[22] | Prevention | Trouser Pocket | Accelerometer & Gyroscope | C4.5 DT classifier, Hjorth mobility and complexity [42] | Alert the user about imminent fall by using message & vibration. | |
[33] | Detection | Waist | Accelerometer | TBA (Fixed) | SMS, voice call, others: twitter, email, Facebook. | |
[55] | Detection | Not found | Accelerometer | TBA (Fixed) | SP trigger PC via Wi-Fi, PC send alert via SMS, emails or/and voice calls | |
[58] | Detection | Waist | Accelerometer | TBA (Fixed) | SMS (time, GPS data), draw help path | |
[85] | Detection | Not found | Accelerometer | TBA (Fixed) | Not found | |
[86] | Detection | (User's height 164 cm) | Accelerometer | TBA (Fixed) | Server displays current states and triggers an alarm | |
[87] | Detection | Trouser Pocket | Accelerometer | OneRAttributeEval, ReliefFAttributeEval SVMAttributeEval, K* [88], C4.5, NB | SMS (GPS coordinate) | |
[89] | Detection (Free Fall) | Not found | Accelerometer | Displacement based algorithms | SMS (GPS coordinate) | |
[90] | Detection | Waist | Accelerometer | TBA (Fixed) | SMS |
Artificial Neural Network;
Sparse Multinomial Logistic Regression (SMLR);
k-Nearest Neighbours (KNN);
Received Signal Strength Indication.