Study | Reason for exclusion |
Brumfitt 1973 | This study presented data obtained from earlier studies. Original data were not presented. The data about treatment of asymptomatic bacteriuria were supposedly taken from a study by Leigh 1970. This study however, could not be retrieved. |
Brumfitt 1982 | Not a RCT. |
Christopher 1969 | It was a crossover study. |
Davies 1975 | Some of the subjects in the study were symptomatic. |
De Cecco 1987 | It was a crossover study which used only preliminary studies |
Harris 1982 | 4 antibiotic regimens were compared at the same time and results were not presented by randomization group |
McFadyen 1987 | Only 1 subgroup was randomized. It was not clear why that subgroup was used for randomization |
Pathak 1969 | Nitrofurantoin was compared with placebo. |
Pedler 1985 | The subjects included symptomatic patients. |
Pregazzi 1987 | Single versus traditional dosing schedules of different antibiotics taken together were compared. Results from different antibiotics were presented together (i.e. single dose of penicillins, cephalosporins, and co-trimoxazole versus their traditional dosing schedules) |
Reeves 1975 | The study randomized only 1 subgroup. It was not clear why that subgroup was randomized |
Sanderson 1984 | This trial focused on prophylaxis in women who had already been treated for bacteriuria |
Stamatiou 2007 | It was not a randomized trial. Some of the subjects had symptomatic urinary tract infection |
Thoumsin 1990 | Only preliminary data were published. |
Whalley 1977 | Short-term therapy (of either 1 of 2 antibiotics) was compared with long therapy (of one of the antibiotics) |
Zinner 1971 | It was not for asymptomatic bacteriuria. |
Zinner 1990 | The study included symptomatic patients. |
RCT: randomized controlled trial