Table 3. Characteristics of the included studies: non-surgical periodontal therapy.
Study | Participants | PD definition | Methods | Outcomes | Conclusion |
Lafaurie and colleagues, 2007 [18] | 42 patients, 25 males and 17 females, mean age 38,15 years, submitted to periodontal treatment | PD was defined as at least 10 pockets with PPD≥7 mm requiring periodontal surgery after SRP | BS was collected before and after SRP (immediately, 15 min, 30 min) and were analyzed via blood culture bottles (anaerobic) | Microorganisms growing under anaerobic conditions were identified in the peripheric blood after SRP in 80.9% (34/42) patients. Evaluation times: T1 - 2,4% (1/42) patients T2 - 73.8% (31/42) patients, T3 - 38% (16/42) patients, T4 - 19% (8/42) patients, Frequent MO P. gingivalis, and M. micros in peripheral blood | “Scaling and root planning induced bacteremia associated with anaerobic bacteria, especially in patients with periodontal disease” |
Maestre and colleagues, 2008 [20] | 13 patients, 8 males and 5 females, mean age 58.6 years submitted to periodontal treatment | PD was defined as PPD≥4 mm. | BS was collected before and after SRP (1 min) and were analyzed via blood culture bottles (aerobic/anaerobic) | Baseline: 0% (0/13) After treatment 76.9% (10/13) Predominate anaerobic bacteria of the genus Prevotella, followed M. micros and F. nucleatum. | “Periodontal procedures induce bacteremia and may represent risk of developing systemic complications. The use of antibiotic prophylaxis is crucial for its prevention”. |
Padilla and colleagues, 2007 [21] | 24 patients, 14 males and 10 females, mean age 63,5 years submitted to periodontal treatment | PD was defined as CAL≥5 mm. | BS was collected before and after (5 min.) SRP. Via blood culture bottles (anaerobics) | Baseline 0%. After treatment 29,1% (7/12) of patients with and without atherosclerosis. The most prevalent bacteria in both groups was A. actinomycetemcomitans | “Bacteremia occurred in 7/24 patients after SRP. In 4 patients, the same species found in periodontic pockets and blood cultures were selected in atherosclerotic plaques obtained one week after the dental procedure” |
Forner and colleagues, 2006 [17] | 60 patients (20 with periodontitis), 5 males and 15 females, mean age 43,75 years submitted to periodontal treatment | PD was defined as at least 10 sites with PPD>5 mm. | BS was collected before and after (0.5, 10, and 30 min.) SRP. Via lysis filtration (aerobic/anaerobic) | Baseline 0%, 0,5 min: 75% (15/20), 10 min 35% (7/20) , 30 min: 10% (2/20). The isolated bacteria represented a larger variety of species reflecting the increased complexity of the microflora of periodontal pocket | “Patients with periodontitis as compared with healthy individuals and gingivitis patients are at increased risk of experiencing bacteremia in association with scaling” . |
Kinane and colleagues, 2006 [16] | 30 patients, 18 male and 12 female, mean age 42,3 years submitted to periodontal treatmet | Periodontal disease was defined as having all quadrants with at least one pocket >6 mm, and ≥20 teeth | BS was collected before and after (immediately) via blood culture bottles (aerobic/anaerobic) and PCR assay. | Baseline: Culture methods: Baseline - 3% (1/30), SRP - 13% (4/30), PCR analysis Baseline: 13% (4/30), SRP 23% (7/30) | “Detectable dental bacteremias induced by periodontal procedures are at a lower level than previously reported |
Zhang and colleagues, 2013 [55] | 30 patients, 12 males and 18 females, mean age 47 (±9,5) years submitted to periodontal treatment | Periodontal disease was defined as having at list one quadrant (qualified quadrant) with a minimum of five teeth with probing depths ≥5 mm not at the same tooth. | BS was collected before, five minutes 30 seconds and 10 min after periodontal treatment and plated onto chromogenic agar, chocolate agar, and brain heart infusion agar supplemented with vitamin K plates. Any grow was subcultured and identified to at least genus level. | Culture methods: Baseline - 3% (1/30), SRP - 13% (4/30), PCR analysis: Baseline: 13% (4/30), SRP 23% (7/30) | “Detectable dental bacteremias induced by periodontal procedures are at a lower level than previously reported” |
SRP – scaling and root planning, PPD Periodontal probing depth, CAL -clinical attachment level, PD – periodontal disease, MO – microorganisms; BS – blood sample; mm – millimeters; PCR – polymerase chain reaction
Lafaurie [18] - University-based (Colombia) This study was supported by the Instituto Colombiano para la Ciencia y la Tecnologia Francisco Jose de Caldas; Maestre Vera [20] - University-based (Spain); Padilla [21] -University-based (Chile); Forner [17] - University-based (Denmark) This study was supported by the Danish Dental Association, Colgate–Palmolive and the Danish Foundation for Mutual Efforts in Dental Care; Kinane [16] - University- based (United Kingdom), Zhang [55] – University-based (Australia).