Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2014 May 29.
Published in final edited form as: Biotechnol Adv. 2011 Oct 8;30(5):1185–1194. doi: 10.1016/j.biotechadv.2011.09.016

Table 1. Comparison of various cell-free protein synthesis systems.

Type Advantages Disadvantages
E.coli S30 extract
  1. Simple and cost-effective preparation of extract

  2. High protein synthesis yield

  3. High rate of protein synthesis

  4. Clearly elucidated biochemical knowledge and well established tools for genetic modifications

  5. Low-cost energy sources

  6. Able to fold complex proteins

  1. Lack of post-translational modifications

  2. No eukaryotic-specific modifications

Wheat-germ extract
  1. Wide-spectrum expression of eukaryotic proteins has been achieved repeatedly

  2. High yield of complex proteins

  3. Sophisticated high-throughput method for proteomics

  1. Low yield of extract from cells

  2. Special washing procedure of wheat germ is needed

  3. Poor genetic modification tools

Rabbit reticulocyte
  1. Easy cell breakage and quick preparation of extract

  2. Eukaryotic-specific modifications

  3. High protein yield of hemoglobin protein while moderate/low yields for other proteins

  1. Complex manipulation of animal tissue required

  2. Narrow spectrum of proteins expressed to date

  3. High background of endogenous globin mRNAs and abundance of RNase M

  4. Poor genetic modification tools

  5. Low protein synthesis yields

Insect cell extract
  1. Easy cell breakage and quick preparation of extract

  2. Various eukaryotic-specific modifications

  3. Signal sequence processing

  1. Cell cultivation is expensive and time-consuming

  2. Poor genetic modification tools

Yeast
  1. Low-cost and scalable cultivation

  2. Clearly elucidated biochemical knowledge and well established tools for genetic modifications

  3. Some eukaryotic-specific modifications

  1. Rigid cell wall made from various polysaccharides makes lysis more difficult

  2. High abundance of various ATPases and phosphatases in some organelles

  3. Low protein synthesis yield

*

Batch system