PARylation is independent of cross-linking of PARP-1. (a) A reaction mixture (40 μl) containing purified PARP-1 and 32P-labeled AP site-containing DNA was incubated on ice without NaBH4 under similar reaction conditions as in Figure 1. After this incubation, the reaction mixture was divided into four equal portions and each reaction mixture was supplemented as follows: lane 1, buffer; lane 2, 100 μM NAD; lane 3, 100 μM NAD and 100 ng PARG; and lane 4, 100 ng PARG. All the reaction mixtures also contained 7.5 mM MgCl2. Incubation was 15 min at 30°C. (b) A reaction mixture (20 μl) containing purified PARP-1, 32P-labeled AP site-containing DNA, 100 100 μM NAD and 7.5 mM MgCl2 was incubated as in panel (a). After this incubation, the reaction mixture was divided into two equal portions and each reaction mixture was supplemented as follows: lane 1, buffer, and lane 2, 100 ng PARG. Incubation was 15 min at 30°C. (c) and (d) The experiments were repeated as described in panels (a) and (b), except the DNA substrate had a nick and was 32P-labeled in the nick as depicted above the phosphorimage. The migration positions of cross-linked PARP-1 (XL-PARP-1) and PARylated PARP-1 are indicated.